Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

This surprised me...

By Dadman
Check out this list of celebrities who have been killed by drugs or alcohol. I guess it may be more fair to say that I'm not surprised, but I was not aware that some of those included in the list were even deceased, much less deceased as a result of drug or alcohol abuse. I have been a dedicated teetotaler for nearly 30 years now and when I see stuff like this it reinforces my dedication. Society pays an enormous price in terms of lives lost, suffering, crime, violence, child abuse, etc. just for the freedom to throw back a cold one.

Comments (13)

CosmicConservative
I don't know how exhaustively researched this list is, but there are several I saw that I would argue do not fit the general theme of "famous people who died because of drugs or alcohol." My recollection of Natalie Wood's death is that she drowned after receiving a head injury, presumably from hitting her head on the dinghy she was trying to board after arguing with her husband and some friends. Nobody knows when in the night she attempted this, and so nobody knows if she was drunk at the time, or simply slipped and fell in the dark, which happens all the time to non-drunk people. Others seem to stretch the point considerably, such as Sigmund Freud, who at the age of 80 and in very ill health, can hardly be considered to be the victim of drug abuse when he decided to end his life on his own terms. So color me a bit skeptical about the overall quality of research on this piece. The only one of the list that "surprised" me was Margaux Hemingway, I had either never known, or had forgotten that she had died. Otherwise I was aware of most of the ones I knew, and most of the ones I didn't know must not have been that famous and so I wonder why they were on the list except to stretch the point.
Dadman
Stretch the point? It's hardly a stretch to make the point that alcohol and drugs kill lots of people many of which have been celebrities. If you added 'average joes' to the list how long do you suppose the list would be? I believe the list would include millions of names. Way too many...
CosmicConservative
I think some on their list are disputable whether drugs and/or alcohol are really significantly involved in the deaths, that's one thing I mean by stretching the point. The other thing is that they specifically lead the story by saying how famous these people are and then we get an obscure basketball player, a bunch of obscure actors and some "one-hit-wonder" types, hardly an indictment of the celebrity lifestyle. This, in fact, seems to me to stress exactly the opposite point, which is that if they had to stretch the list this far to make the point, then celebrities are not, in fact, dying in great numbers and therefore the entire theme of the article is undercut. Now, that is not to say that I don't think there is a tremendous problem with alcohol and drug abuse in this country, but I'm afraid that I don't see this as particularly ground-breaking news. This goes firmly in the "dog bites man" category of news story and as such I have to wonder how slow the newsroom was for them to decide to put this ersatz public service announcement together to remind people that "alcohol kills." They could just as easily have done a "famous people killed by tobacco" piece, or "famous people killed by cars" or "famous people killed because they fly in small private or chartered planes." That last example would have included these famous names at least: "Wiley Post, Will Rogers, Jim Croce, Big Bopper, Richie Valens, Harry Chapin, John Denver, Buddy Holly" and a host of athletes, businessmen and entertainers at least as well-known as the people in this list, in my opinion. I'm not downplaying the dangerous role that drugs and alcohol play in our lives. I'm saying that this story has some flaws that appear to have gotten past the editor because they view the message to be more important than absolute accuracy, and that smacks of social activism to me, not news.
Dadman
It simply is what it is: a list of 'stars' who have died as a result of drugs and/or alcohol. You seem to be arguing for the sake of argument...
CosmicConservative
Perhaps I am, it's been a tough week at work and I'm not myself. Or maybe I am myself. But I am sorry that I don't agree with your statement, either part of it. First these are not "stars" by most definitions, and second, I found more than a few that I dispute clearly died due to alcohol or drugs. So it's not really a "list of stars who died of alcohol or drugs" it's more a "list of stars and marginally famous people who died in some way that the writer was able to claim was related to drugs or alcohol on order to create a list they thought was impressive enough to make their case, dubious though that case may be."
Dadman
Whatever... It's just a list, Cosmic, not an agenda article. It's a list that contains some names that surprised me. It reminded why I am so anti-booze, anti-drug in my own life. End of story...
CosmicConservative
I guess my real point on this is that the article makes a valid socially conscious point that needs to be reinforced, but the writer was lackadaisical in compiling the list and the editor did not feel it was worth the effort to fact check, and that just smacks of laziness or amateurishness to me. That's all. If it's that important of a story, I wish they had made the story more compelling so that I came away with the right message instead of wondering why this writer got this assignment and why this editor didn't think it was worth holding to normal journalistic standards. I guess it's similar to my thought processes on Jessica Alba's thumb rolling down her swimsuit. My mind always jumps to trying to figure out what the motivations behind the situation are, and why it was done the way it was. I know I am weird. But that's how my mind works most of the time.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and perhaps part of my response is that I am not fundamentally "anti-booze" or even fundamentally "anti-drugs." I drink. I took quite a few drugs the past month for pain after my surgery. I oppose illegal drug use but I can't help wonder why we outlaw marijuana but not alcohol when every study I've seen indicates that alcohol is at least as bad as marijuana and frankly I think much worse. Since I'm not inherently anti-drinking, I don't find that public service messages like this resonate with my internal compass. When reading a story like this my thoughts go immediately to things like motivation. I don't see a lot of difference between stories like this and stories that paint gun ownership as inherently dangerous and irresponsible. Or car ownership for that matter. There is no doubt that I am very strongly libertarian in many ways, especially on social issues like this. I also think a list like this has only intellectual impact, not visceral, and people don't typically change their basic behaviors due to intellectual impact. So I question the value of running a story like this in the first place, much less running one that was haphazardly researched and borderline slanderous in some cases. I know, for example, that the estates of some of these "famous" people have disputed these "official" stories vigorously and in some cases the "death by overdose" has been proven to be overblown. There is even significant dispute to this day on the death of Marilyn Monroe and whether it was suicide or not. To put suicide deaths on this list itself, and there are several, is questionable to me because it stands to reason that if drugs were not available, then a gun, knife, open oven door or noose would have worked just as well. So the fact that someone chose to OD on sleeping pills does not imply that they had a "drug problem" in my mind. Sigmund Freud is only the most obvious example from the list where this is the case. Sigh... you may be right, I may be arguing just for argument's sake, but the story bothered me for a number of reasons.
mtnlurker
I found the story and pictures interesting. But I have to agree with Cosmic that as I went through the pictures I was questioning why some where there. There was very little impact other than that.
Dadman
mtnlurker: I'm not surprised you agree with Cosmic and I'm frankly not interested if the list had any impact on you or not. It was my posting and my opinion. I was not seeking validation...
CosmicConservative
I didn't mean to be so contrary on this. I wasn't responding to Dadman's opinion on this, just the actual "news" piece. Dadman sometimes posts "pet peeves" posts of things that get him riled up, and this sort of "news" story is one of my pet peeves, which is what I was responding to. I apologize if it was taken in some other way.
Dadman
This was never a news story. It's just a list...a tragic list in my opinion...
CosmicConservative
I see now that this was not linked off of their news page, but from their general home page for the TV station. I somehow had thought this was on their "news" page. I stand corrected on that, although I still think it's a haphazard, poorly researched list that is put together more for effect than for accuracy.