Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Another reason I am an agnostic

By CosmicConservative
... instead of an atheist, that is. June 6th. Or perhaps better put, June 4th - June 7th, but I'll pick June 6th because of 1942 and 1944. Everyone remembers (do they?) that June 6th, 1944 was "D-Day." But June 6th 1942 was the third day in the most critical battle in WWII, the "Battle of Midway." The Battle of Midway, in particular, was the turning point of the war in the Pacific. It marked the difference between the Japanese forces expanding into the Pacific, and the Japanese forces retreating. Before Midway, the Japanese Navy was a juggernaut that was easily the equal of the Nazi Luftwaffe in terms of territory gained, battles won and intimidation of other countries. In the Battle of Midway, a small group of U.S. Aircraft Carriers, including one that had already been heavily damaged in a previous battle, defeated a much larger force of Japanese ships, including Aircraft Carriers, Battleships and Cruisers. D-Day is a similar situation, a desperate assault on a heavily fortified beach where the enemy had built fortifications for years in preparation for the inevitable assault, and the assault succeeded in spite of monstrous casualties. It can be argued that once the U.S. entered WWII, that it was a foregone conclusion that Japan and Germany were doomed. I've seen the arguments. But I have to say, looking at the world from the eyes of a person on the island of Midway in May of 1942, it would have been hard to convince me of the inevitability of a U.S. victory. But after Midway, it became a foregone conclusion. If you read through the history of the battle, it is easy to conclude that the hand of God had some influence on the events of those four days. Now there are a lot of things, large and small, that enter into my theology, and lead me towards agnosticism, but it is no exaggeration to say that the Battle of Midway and D-Day are two of the strongest arguments that there is a divine intervention in world affairs from time to time. It is with some sense of awe and reverence that I say "Thank God we won."

Comments (23)

Dadman
I believe divine intervention may have also had a hand in the formation of this nation's Constitution and the success (thus far) of the 'American experiment'.
CosmicConservative
Well, once you see the cook's thumb in the soup, you always have to wonder what else he's touched, right?
mtnlurker
I'm sorry but I am not convinced. I stand by my atheism.
CosmicConservative
Mtnlurker: Well, obviously I'm not "convinced" either, but I am equally unconvinced that there is NO divine being out there. I just don't find anything compelling enough to convince me either way.
Dadman
You know, I think most people, even those that describe themselves as faithful, are agnostic to a greater or lesser extent. Faith, even faith that no supreme being exists, is not objective truth and is not based on empirical evidence. I can't tell you I KNOW what I believe is true, but I defer to my faith and try to live my life as if it were true. Indeed, that is what the scriptures ask the 'faithful' to do. There are tangible benefits attached to living in such a way. That I do know...
CosmicConservative
Well, again, if there was any divine intervention in world affairs at the Battle of Midway or the Normandy Invasion, I'm just glad it was on the right side.
Brian
Sometimes you just have a really good day. Someone also says that fortune favors the prepared. And we had a lot of preparation that led to Midway. Breaking Japan's crypto - and not letting on that we knew. The US Navy spending years at the Naval War College war gaming a war in the Pacific.
Dadman
Yes, the universe and everything in it is derived of nothing more than a set of random events...some good and some bad.
CosmicConservative
Brian: The breaking of the Japanese code was probably the single biggest asset the US had in that case, but there were many, many things that happened during and just before the battle, all of them outside of the control of any Allied planning, which just happened to break in the favor of the U.S. side. Things like the scout plane that would have found the US ships having to turn back early. Things like US ships being in a secluded cove where Japanese submarines had planned to stop and refuel to get to their positions, making them a day or two late, time that allowed the US carriers to slip past the submarine net undetected. There is no doubt that there was a lot of planning and execution done by brave and heroic Americans, but I am sure that there was a lot of planning and execution done by brave and heroic Japanese too. And I'm not saying I believe that there was divine intervention, all I am saying is that if you want to find some evidence to support the idea that God intervenes in human affairs, the Battle of Midway is fertile ground.
ams1491625
Hmm. My main problem with the idea of divine intervention in wars is that you can't count on it. Beleiving that God is on your side leads to overconfidence. After you've managed to take Normandy, you can say "thank God we've won". But beforehand, you can only count on your men and materials. Fighting in a moral cause is no guarantee of victory. No one is going to save the Sudanese farmers who have been driven from their land. No one helped Spartacus in his slave rebellion. No one saved the people of Prague from their assailants when they were slaughtered to the last man over the Catholic/Protestant conflict. No one saved the Vietnamese who were left to fight alone against the communists. You just can't count on the morality of your cause to give you victory. Fighting for a just cause can help indirectly. A moral society is healthier than one that has been corrupted by an evil cause. Your men have better morale to be fighting for something they believe in, rather than because they "fear Stalin more than Hitler". But it won't stop enemy bombs from detonating or bullets from flying.
ams1491625
We won WWII, in my opinion, because of Ford, Rolls Royce, Hughs, and Westpoint. We won because we had better industry, better leaders, better intelligence, and the ability to dump thousands of tons of equipment into Europe - to have more at the end of our attacked and exhausted supply line than the Germans or Japanese could conjure up in their own capitols. Had we been only as powerful as France was at the time, or England, the world would be speaking Japanese and German, regardless of the evil of their regimes, or the justice of our cause.
CosmicConservative
You could easily argue, and most "experts" do, that we won World War II because our economy was an almost untapped source of arms, machinery and vehicles that was outside the reach of our enemies to interrupt, while we were able to interrupt their own industry quite effectively. "Great" (I hate that word, but it's accurate in this sense) wars are usually won or lost by who can put the most forces in the field the most effectively and with the best training. There was no country on earth that could match the U.S. in those areas in the 1940s, and few who can hope to do so even today. But my point still stands, if you want to look for support for the theory that there was some divine intervention in human affairs during that great worldwide conflagration, Midway is a fertile place to look.
Drax
Divine intervention? Sorry, can't get behind the notion. I'd have to ask "But, what about the Jews? Where were you then?" Or... "All those Russians were beneath your notice?" Or..."Yet you let it begin in the first fripping place, knowing where it would end, but want CREDIT for intervening in those instances?"
ams1491625
Well, justice is not a natural condition. It was completely, grindingly, nose-in-the-mud absent for thousands of years across almost all of the world. The natural world is one where the slowest gazelle has to run faster than the fastest lion. Where the powerful survive and the weak perish. If you want the world to be just, you have to construct these artificial conditions within the conditions of the natural world. You have to make sure that you are just, but you must also make sure that you are powerful (and perhaps not always in that order, such as during war). You can no more win a war with moral authority alone against force than you can build a perpetual motion machine.
CosmicConservative
Sigh... I probably never should have started this thread... Divine in my sense does not imply "omniscience", "omnipotence" or "ultimate goodness." Those are separate concepts that have very little place in any theology I can wrap my brain around. It is quite possible in my world of "lesser gods" that divine interaction could be required from time to time BECAUSE "God" doesn't control everything, not IN SPITE of "His" control. But, that's going to take this debate further down dark alleyways of supernatural speculation than most people want to travel I expect....
Drax
"Why do Bad Things Happen to Good People?" eh? A limited god (little "g") ain't much of a "god," methinks.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... so at what point does something qualify to be a "god" then? The Greek Gods were severely limited in their powers. None of them were omniscient nor omnipotent. Zeus (and Odin) were able to see anything they wanted to see, but they did not AUTOMATICALLY know everything. And yet they are considered "gods". In fact a "lesser god" of the sort I can envision could be vastly more powerful than Odin or Zeus and still be far from omnipotent or omniscient, and therefore have to still intervene from time to time if they wanted to ensure their plans came to fruition. ESPECIALLY if other "lesser gods" were working actively against them with their own limited interventions. Like I said, this thread is at risk of running down a very convoluted metaphysical side street if we aren't careful. I can see a limited god (with a little g) being of such vast power and capability that there would be little doubt of his/her "godness" were you to actually encounter them.
Drax
A "limited god," by necessity, is a "fallible god," the greater the limitation, the greater the fallibility. While deserving of obedience and fear, such a "god" is undeserving of "worship," thus, not much in the way of a "god" to me.
CosmicConservative
"Worship" is a specific concept that I have problems with. Why would it matter whether a "god" is fallible or not to deserve "worship?" What is "worship" anyway? The whole concept of "worship" is something I find very difficult to wrap my mind around. After contemplating the concept from every angle I can think of, the one overriding thing that keeps floating to the top of my analysis is this: "Any being who demands worship is by definition unworthy of it." That has nothing to do with fallibility, infallibility, omniscience or omnipotence. It is a purely moral conclusion that I reach through purely moral considerations. Demanding worship is plain wrong, and any being who does so is immoral, and therefore unworthy of it. QED. I might go with reverence, appreciation, thankfulness, or similar responses, but "worship" is something else. Now, my own analysis aside, just looking at whether a god deserves worship or not, my opinion is that a limited God who has had to struggle to create a universe that is as fair and decent as possible, who overcame incredible difficulties and who did so at great cost to himself, that God, as fallible as it is, is far more worthy of worship than an omnipotent, omniscient god who has no limitations and yet created THIS particular universe with all its obvious shortcomings. So in that sense I find a limited god far more worthy of worship than an omnipotent one.
Drax
"Fallible" means fallible in all respects, not just that he/she/it can't do some things but also does wrong things; not just that he/she/it makes wrong choices, but has the potential of making EVIL choices...a capricious "god." IF there's someone/thing out there who is actually putting his/her/its hands into the affairs of man, I would like to think that the choices made were RIGHT ones...ALL THE TIME....made for the RIGHT reasons. Since I can't buy into such an omnipotent/omniscent being, I much prefer to believe that there isn't any at all.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I respectfully disagree with your assertions. "fallible" does not mean "capricious." I am fallible, but I like to think I am not capricious. See this goes far afield on the whole theology thing... The whole idea of a "good" god presupposes that the god is capable of making "evil" choices. If "God" is incapable of making evil choices, then that "God" is constrained by definition. The only way to say that someone made a "good" choice is to say that they could have made a "bad" or "evil" choice. So any god that is incapable of being evil is incapable of being "good." Since all choices have some gradations of "goodness" and one choice is by definition the "best" choice, any god who makes a less than ideal choice has made a choice that is less good, and therefore more "evil" than it could have. So for any god to always have to "choose" the "best" choice, that means they are, by definition, not "choosing" at all, and could be replaced by an automaton that simply always does the "best" thing. And since it was incapable of choosing, it can't be called "good" any more than a light switch can be called "good" for turning a light on or off. See, theology gets really weird when you start to really look at what sort of being a "god" has to be. Especially an "omnipotent" and "omniscient" god. If you think about it, if "God" truly is omnipotent, omniscient and purely good, then that god has no more choice in his daily affairs than a cuckoo clock. His omniscience will always tell him the "best" choice. His omnipotence will always make that choice possible, his goodness will force him to make that choice. That's not a god at all, that's a robot. I think this is getting into the realm of theology that probably can't really be done properly in a blog thread... But this is why I can't "worship" and "omniscient, omnipotent, purely good" god. Such a being really only deserves pity.
Drax
Agreed. Not a subject which really can be discussed on a blog (especially in snippets taken between taking care of things in the non-virtual world). Just a couple of things: 1) Of course you're capricious. We all are, from time to time. We do things which even we don't understand why we did them, say things which, upon reflection we shouldn't have, sometimes even saying those things WHILE we know that we shouldn't but not able to help ourselves. It's one of the problems with having emotions and the inability to control them every time. 2) An omnicent/omnipotent god can't be incapable of doing "evil deeds," being limiting in itself. I should have said that a "good" god, even though he CAN do evil things chooses to do good instead, the self-limitation not limiting his knowledge or power. Sigh. Don't know why I stuck my toe in these waters since I don't believe there's anyone/thing out there which takes a hand in human affairs in the first place.
CosmicConservative
The limitation is on an "omnipotent, omniscient, pure good" god, not simply an "omnipotent, omniscient" one. An "OO" god could do anything it liked, for any reason it liked, or for no reason at all. But when you put "OOG" into the mix, for it to be "pure good" then it must always choose a single course of action from the infinity of options because one and only one will generate the most "good" and the least "evil." If it chooses anything but that single option, then it is not "pure good" and is being capricious by definition. This is why I think the concept of a "omnipotent, omniscient, purely good" god is untenable. Such a being is not choosing anything, it is simply reacting to circumstances as they occur. This is why a less than omnipotent, less than omniscient god that is less than purely good is one that I can understand and respect. One that does the best it can with what it knows, and whose power, although stupendous beyond our comprehension, still does not allow it to always know everything and do anything. Such a god struggles to do good and when it succeeds, it does good. But when it fails, it has to suffer the consequences of its failure, just as we do. Of course what I am told is that such a God is just an extension of a human being, and as such isn't really a God at all. I disagree with that and simply say that my understanding of the universe can be explained by such a limited god, but absolutely cannot be explained by an "OOG" god. Our universe, as it exists today and is experienced by all of us, simply cannot be the result of, or managed by, an "OOG" god. It's simply not possible. Now, an "OO" god who has some purpose that requires humans (and presumably other beings in the universe) experience nature as a capricious and sometimes evil place, that is an acceptable explanation for this universe as well, but again, I simply can't wrap my brain around "omniscience" and free will existing in the same universe at the same time. They are mutually exclusive, and since they are mutually exclusive and I prefer to believe in free will, I simply don't believe in omniscience. Similarly since Omnipotence requires omniscience, I don't believe in omnipotence either. And I think all of it is QED.