Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A Black Swan

By Rick Larson
In most cases people who think swans think white.  But every so often nature throws us a curve and produces something rare that takes us out of our routine thought.  Similiarly, our life is a series of cycles constantly repeating the same motions and ideas. And in this context, life generally stays the same. But there are instances that are shocking and so out of the ordinary that it changes life as we had known it. This change is always looked at as history, as an event, when, in fact, the actions of people during these changes hardly reflected any knowledge of this changing event. World Wars come to mind. The Industrial Revolution. The stock market crash of 29 and 87. These are the events that changed humans unexpectedly.  These are ideas were conveyed in the first few chapters of a book I have begun to read: Black Swan by Nassim Nicholas Taleb.

Comments (4)

Rick Larson

The author brings up an interesting contradiction: How can one have a belief against abortion, yet then agree with capital punishment?

I take this one step farther: How can one belive abortion is immoral, yet the continuing killing in Iraq not?

He also compares the idea of one wanting low taxes, yet agreeing raising taxes for war is ok.

Interesting to explore these feelings...

Dadman
Rick: I do not support abortion, yet have no issue with capital punishment for the most heinous crimes. I detect no contradiction. Developing humans are innocent beings guilty of no offense while death row inmates are guilty of murder and in some cases mass murder. Captial punishment seems an appropriate punishment for brutal killers. The key word here is 'punishment'. What are developing humans guilty of, Rick? Anyone with a brain should be able to comprehend the distinction. If a criminal entered my home with evil intent I would have no issue with killing him. None. Would you consider it an 'immoral' killing? If our soldiers in Iraq kill terrorists or insurgents who are guilty of blowing up innocent people in a Baghdad marketplace or elementary school would you consider it immoral killing? Is fighting, dying and/or killing in the name of liberty, freedom, self-determination, etc. immoral, Rick? I am endlessly fascinated (and troubled) by people like you, Rick, who have lost the capacity to make intelligent distinctions. Abortion is simply not equivalent to capital punishment for terrible crimes. Killing to defend life and liberty is not the same as abortion. To suggest it is simply stupid...
CosmicConservative
This moral confusion on the Left between capital punishment and abortion is just one more example of their problem with the concept of personal responsibility. Capital punishment is punishment for behavior that is so heinously anti-social that death is considered an appropriate response. This requires judgment and recognition of the value to society of punishment as a deterrent for others. It also demostrates a recognition of the value of an innocent life being taken by saying that the penalty for taking an innocent life might be to take the life of the murderer. This is a way of valuing the life of the innocent victim. The left doesn't get that. Since the Left has a problem with all of these concepts (personal responsibility, judgment, punishment, deterrence) they don't understand the difference between killing an innocent child and killing a genocidal maniac. It is interesting to me that Rick, supposedly a "conservative", buys into these Leftist concepts as he has in so many others.
Kevin in WI
Well, I'm in the middle (more like first 1/3) of this book and it is an interesting, albeit somewhat obvious, premise. I forecast for a living (not weather) and agree with the author that the easiest all too human trap to run into is the belief that fundamentally unpredictable events are predictable. It is an assumption we make due to the perceived clarity of past events. We always interpret a cause (or causes) as THE cause (or causes). When, in reality, we are either creating nonexistent causes via our analysis or selectively applying some causes to form a theory. Its a good book.