Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Crabs, Remnants and Personal Philosophy

By CosmicConservative
That's a heck of a title. How the heck to I tie those together? One of my absolute favorite sites on the web is Eject! Eject! Eject!. In fact I think it is probably fair to say that his blog is more or less what I hoped this blog would be, but I haven't pulled that off. He has. He publishes one or two essays a month and boy are they doozies. His latest is a discussion of what you might call the "end of decency" in our society, and a very specific analysis of what is called the "Prisoner's Dilemma". Now I've been aware of, and thought about, the Prisoner's Dilemma for a while, and it finds its way into literature, movies and video games. In fact I was replaying Baldur's Gate just the other day and sure enough, a genie appears to you and presents you with the Prisoner's Dilemma right out of the gate. I am not going to recount the Prisoner's Dilemma here, because I'd rather you go to E!E!E! and read it there. He does a much better job than I could, and he has a great deal of further analysis and commentary that is more than worth the reading, it is downright brilliant. I'll wait for you to finish reading his blog... . OK, good, now you should understand why I have the "Remnants" portion of the header. Why do I have "Personal Philosophy?" Because I have one, and have followed it for a long time. I'm basically a rational pragmatist by nature, and by training. That means that my philosophy is fundamentally driven by doing what works, based on analysis of the facts and data present. So when facts and data (in the form of history and personal experience) tell me that punching a bully in the nose is the best way to get them to leave you alone, I tend to promote punching bullies in the nose as public policy. I have no problem with sitting down with bullies and trying to figure out why their souls are so tortured as you tend to their nosebleed, but fundamentally I think if you don't punch them in the nose, they will simply continue to bully you. This is the "Retaliation" portion of E!E!E!s most successful long-term social strategy. And it works if the bully is in the middle school playground, or if they bully is a nation-state promoting suicide bombers. Punch them in the nose. Hard. Make them hurt. THEN sit down and discuss the situation with them. They're not going to listen until you get their attention. Now, what about the crabs? If you've ever seen pictures of people out crabbing, you may have noticed that crab buckets have no top. And crabs are quite adept at climbing. Why don't crabs simply climb out of the bucket and get away? Because when they try, the other crabs grab them and pull them back down into the bucket. This is how I view the "masses" that Plato and Isiah talk about in the E!E!E! essay. They aren't merely innocent bystanders who are misguided decent folks. Instead they are the crabs pulling down those who might otherwise be "remnants." I see this all the time, in all social situations. For example, we have a situation here locally where a local High School teacher who was responsible for the Yearbook content approved pictures and comments from the students using drugs and excusing their behavior for using drugs. The local parents are outraged and up in arms. I, as I so often do, got into the mix a bit explaining that it is simply inappropriate for that sort of content to be in a High School yearbook, it's not an appropriate place to put it. The teacher who made that mistake needs to be "punched in the nose" because she is essentially a PC bully, putting her own ideology above that of the general public good. So when I, and a few others, point out that the behavior was inappropriate, and that she should be punished for such a severe lack of judgment, we are attacked by the PC herd who say things like "who are you to decide what is appropriate in a yearbook?" or "How can you judge another person, are you perfect yourself?" or words to that effect. Essentially I see them as the crabs trying to pull down those of us who have any sense of public decency and responsibility to the same level of moral equivalence and lack of personal responsibility that is, in my opinion, destroying this country. Wrong is wrong. I don't need to have it approved by the PC rubber stamp to know that. My own moral compass tells me so. I wonder how many of us are left who actually have and live by such compasses?

Comments (2)

Drax
I think we all have our own compass, however, I also think that the vast majority of us have had our compasses installed rather than building it ourselves.
Rick Larson
Sure, you should argue your point until those other crabs give up and go home.