Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Computer-enabled gameplaying...

By CosmicConservative
I think I have mentioned this before, but I play role-playing games. Currently I have one weekly session and I alternate "Game Master" responsibilities between me and one of the players so that one week (this week, for example) I am the "Game Master" and the next week, I am a player. If you aren't familiar with the concept of role-playing games, here's a Wiki link that will explain the whole thing. So, basically this just confirms beyond question that I'm a geek. Just in case I ever decided to run for a political office, I'm pretty certain that having a D&D history would be a show-stopper for most folks in deciding whether or not to vote for me. But oh well, some people like to play poker, other folks like to play pool, I like to pretend I'm a wizard or a druid or a knight and run around and fight imaginary injustice in imaginary worlds. To each his own. Back in the early days of my role-playing habit, I used to dream about games like "World of Warcraft" or "EverQuest" thinking that combining my role-playing interest with my computer interest would be a natural synergy of two of my hobbies, and that the result would be more enjoyable than doing either on their own. But it hasn't turned out that way. I enjoy playing games like WoW, and I enjoy using my computer, but I still prefer the old-fashioned paper-and-pencil version of D&D to the online games that were inspired by them. And the reason why is very simple. The boundaries of a good pencil-and-paper role playing game are quite literally defined only by the imagination of the people playing it. In contrast, the boundaries of an online or single-user computer role-playing game are defined both by the limitations of the computer itself, and by the pre-existing limitations of the game designer's imaginations. But even in a "pencil-and-paper" world, it's not really pencil and paper anymore. I do my character sheets on the computer, and I use some tools to do things like create random maps or random monsters just to make it easier to fill out the worlds I create. But now I am trying to figure out what the ideal fusion of computer technology and role-playing games really is. And I think the answer is that the computer should enable the imagination of the GameMaster, not constrain or replace it. Here is what I think would be ideal. Suppose there were a service available that divided its community into "GM" and "player." And the Game Master were given tools to create worlds. Those tools would include mapping tools, character creation tools, monster and treasure creation, etc. All of the things that you have to do in the pen-and-pencil world to create a viable campaign, but all of it stored and normalized on a massively multiplayer system somewhere. Players would then log in to a campaign run by the GM, just as pen-and-pencil gamers get together at a local gaming tavern or at somebody's house. The game would proceed much as a pen-and-paper game proceeded with the following improvements: 1. The massively multiplayer online system would manage all the "grunt work" necessary to run the game. It would keep track of things like how many arrows you have used, how many spells you have cast, your current hit points, who's turn it is in the initiative rolls, etc. All the little painful details that drive players crazy and lead to so many arguments. But not critical things like attack rolls, or saving throws, etc. Those would be done separately on a hidden screen with the DM and player working together so that the game player still felt like they were in control of the dice for those critical things. 2. The system would allow on-the-fly modifications by the GM. For example, the GM might decide that things are too slow, and call up a random encounter. Or the GM might think the game is going too badly for the players and might remove some elements from the game to compensate. In my head I see this as being similar to the GM grabbing some miniatures from his box and putting them on the game board. 3. The system should provide a multi-player environment where the game can be visually experienced simultaneously by all players. Again in my head I see this as players moving their "miniatures" by using the mouse on their turn and selecting their avatar (for lack of a better term) and moving their character wherever the rules allow. The map itself should be presented according to what the player's character's abilities are. Only those parts that are visible to the character should be visible to the player, and that may be different for different characters. A dwarf, for example, should be able to see in the dark, but not a human. As the characters move around, they would see the world in real time. 4. Weapon damage and spell effects should be totally under the control of the GM. If the GM desires they can choose a "by the book" approach, where all effects are strictly produced using random effect tables. If a player receives a critical hit, oh well, time to roll up a new character. Or the GM could choose to override those rolls and direct the action totally according to their own idea of how things SHOULD happen. 5. The GM should be able to create or modify the game environment at will. Overnight the GM could decide that the church in town has a secret set of stairs leading down to a hidden underground series of tunnels and chambers. Using sophisticated mapping tools the GM should be able to create the new dungeon according to their desires, populating it with traps, treasure and nasty beasties. Upon logging in the next day, the player party could find the secret entrance and be experiencing the new dungeon without any clue that the whole thing was just a flash of inspiration from the GM the night before. I believe the technology exists to provide this sort of experience today. I know that people like me would have a huge interest in playing games run this way. I would greatly prefer it to the constrained and limited MMORPGs of today. If you normalize things somewhat by providing appropriate level advancement and treasure for the types of encounters, then an entire community of players could compare and contrast their abilities. I envision being able to log in and seek out others who are in the mood to play, people who might be on another continent. GMs could log in and open their world up to those who are interested in playing, and a short negotiation could take place before a suitable party could be created and the game could begin. Or, of course, set teams and GMs could have long-term sessions that would last months if they like. Of course there is no reason that this approach would not take advantage of all the cool visual effects that modern MMORPGs offer. Fireball spells should go off in spectacular fashion. Arrows should fly and blood should spill. Taken far enough characters could even take on the voice of their players through the use of microphones so that the characters actually talk to each other. The bottom line here is that this provides a feedback mechanism between the game players and the game designer so that the game itself is never boring, predictable or limited. Of course there will probably be some limitations to this approach, but in general it should provide a much superior gaming experience when compared to the current shrink-wrapped options out there.

Comments (10)

JSullins
Phew, long one! Very interesting. I like your ideas -- have even considered some of them myself in the past. 1) Are you proposing the development of a system similar to what you have described? 2) Are you interested in hearing some of the difficulties that come to mind when considering this system? :)
Dadman
Have you heard of Second Life? Seems like it might have some, but not all, of the functionality you are looking for...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I haven't checked out second life. It's free too, isn't it? JSullins: Sure, I'm always willing to hear why my great ideas suck.
JSullins
My last post.... went *poof*.... I think.... so I'll try again. Second life: is dominated by pornographic content, I have heard. It is a rather open model, and doesn't focus on gameplaying, per se. I think. Cosmic: I didn't mean to imply that your idea sucks! Just that certain challenges come to mind when considering the implementation of a system like one you described. And, you didn't answer my first question!
CosmicConservative
I am definitely interested in pursuing this. The "fast" way to pursue it is to find an existing game engine that we can use as a foundation. But the problem with that approach is that it may come with the very limitations built in that I am trying to overcome. The "right" way to pursue this is to architect a new game engine from scratch. The problem with that approach is that it might take a lifetime to complete at the rate I can currently devote time or resources to it. What would tip the scales is a company (like Wizards of the Coast) who might bankroll the effort. That would be cool.
Dadman
I've heard that some corporations are using Second Life to facilitate their new employee integration programs. I don't have any first hand experience with Second Life; I've only read a few articles pertaining to its use as a tool to train and integrate employees... If it is indeed an open model that accommodates free, unfettered expression, I guess it makes sense that the smut peddlers are open for business in Second Life... Too bad...
CosmicConservative
I'm going to have to check 2nd Life out one of these days....
ams1491625
"The “fast” way to pursue it is to find an existing game engine that we can use as a foundation. But the problem with that approach is that it may come with the very limitations built in that I am trying to overcome." Hmm. You know, I think I've always leaned GM myself. Not that I've done too many pencil and paper RPGs (other than that one p&p rennaisance kingdom strategy game with my brother). But in almost every computer game I've owned, one of the key things I look for is "can I play with the development tools", or at least mess with the rules. I've created an entire alternative version to Civ II taking place on Mars. I've created my own fractal, incredibly expansive (hideously difficult) Descent II map (and one particular robot in the mine metastasizes when you kill it). I've written my own tetris-like game from scratch. One of the cool things about Morrowind or Oblivion (2 from Bethesda Softworks) are that they come with their own development tools, so you literally can create your own towns and cities and stick them in the game world. I think MMORPGs would be awesome if they allowed for something similar, where GMs all over the world could independently create and link their own game-worlds. The job of the game company would be, as you said, to provide a good engine that allows a lot of stuff and an enourmous art library to use. That and no subscription fees. Just box fees. So I think I just landed with both feet into the land of geekiness.
Mad Morf
You're looking for NeverWinter Nights... The game is playable solo, without a network. But, and here's the interesting part, there is a huge online community to play with AND there is a game designer module so you can customize to your hearts content AND you can run your own MMORPG server and invite your friends... My RPG buddies have been separated by work and various things over the years, but a couple of years ago we decided to try NWN.... It was great! Now NWN2 is out, haven't looked at it, but I'll bet it's just as much fun... Mad Morf
CosmicConservative » Computer aided role playing...
[...] Remember this post of mine about using computers to improve role playing games? [...]