Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Fusion? Are we that close?

By CosmicConservative
Polywell - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Problems to Overcome A traditional Farnsworth-Hirsch fusor consists of a vacuum chamber containing a positively charged outer grid and a negatively charged inner grid within; essentially a large vacuum tube with spherical grids. Fusible atomic nuclei are injected as ions into the system, repelled by the outer grid, and accelerated toward the inner grid. Most of the time, the ions miss the grid, but occasionally, given long enough, nuclei strike either the grid or another high-energy nucleus. Most strikes with other nuclei do not result in fusion, but occasionally fusion results. On a miss, the nuclei move outwards, are repelled by the outer grid again, and return through the core. Without the motion of electrons and magnetic fields, there are no synchrotron losses and low levels of bremsstrahlung radiation. The fundamental problem with the system is with the grid itself. Far too often, nuclei strike the grid. This damages the grid, wastes the energy that went into ionizing and accelerating the particle, and most critically, heats the grid. Even if the former problems were not critical, having a fine mesh grid in a reactor producing enough power to be used as a power plant would almost certainly mean that it would be rapidly vaporized. The Polywell concept is designed to avoid this problem. Most notably, it is a gridless inertial electrostatic fusor. Using a cusped, quasi-spherical magnetic mirror, electrons can be confined in a slightly electron-rich plasma.[1] The electrostatic potential from the trapped excess electrons, not a negatively charged grid, confine the fusion fuel ions toward a dense focus in the center. The odds of collision with an electron are vanishingly small, and there is no grid to overheat. While this concept uses magnetic fields, which the original fusor managed to avoid, the fields do not need to confine nuclei — only electrons, which are orders of magnitude simpler to confine.[2] The shape of the magnetic mirror must be a zonohedron by construction, with cusps at each vertex. In Bussard's polywell devices, not all vertices were driven by solenoids to minimize electron losses. This allowed a rhombic dodecahedral field to be constructed from 6 solenoids. Bussard's unbuilt PW-7 would use twice as many solenoids to create a more spherical rhombic triacontahedral field.
Basically this is a fusion reactor design that seems not only feasible, but seems actually economically viable. But the fact that they are getting no funding or support makes me wonder if there is something more to this story than is coming out. Google seems interested.

Comments (4)

ams1491625
Hmm. I've often thought that the grid problem needed to be solved by the introduction of a magnetic field to deflect the particles around it.
ams1491625
The older IEC fusion devices didn't operate at anywhere near the level of activity needed to generate commercial power. Mostly they are used as non-radioactive neutron generators for scanners.
CosmicConservative
The limitations of the grid-based approach is that the grid itself is destroyed by the bombardment of nuclei, or the heat generated. That's why this projected electric field approach is so promising. I just wonder how well it scales, Brussard claims it will scale to the 7th magnitude or something like that.
CosmicConservative
I should have completed that thought. I think the idea that this will scale that much without actually testing it is one of those things that demonstrates the difference between practical engineering and theoretical science. "In theory, there is no difference. In reality, there is a huge difference." I'm not so certain this will scale, but it seems promising enough to try to build a scaled up model that generates power. If I had the money, I'd back it.