Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Earth from space

By CosmicConservative
This is a decent article about the perspective that the view of earth from space gives people, but this quotation below struck me as odd, and monumentally naive:
The Earth from space: Travelers describe our planet - CNN.com "It was the only color we could see in the universe. ... "We're living on a tiny little dust mote in left field on a rather insignificant galaxy. And basically this is it for humans. It strikes me that it's a shame that we're squabbling over oil and borders." -- Bill Anders, Apollo 8, whose photos of Earth became famous
earthfromspace.jpg So Bill Anders, an Apollo 8 astronaut who took the first famous "tiny blue marble" photo while on the way to the moon, thinks that the two things we on earth "squabble" over are "oil and borders." Nothing there about "religious ideology" or "racial genocide" of course, just "oil and borders." I think I can make a pretty good guess what Bill Anders thinks about George W. Bush.

Comments (4)

ams182764
People often accuse other people of going to war over resources. But the story of the 20th century, or even the 19th, 18th, 17th, ect is that people will go to war over all sorts of crazy stupid things. Entire cities were put to the sword because the people held "incorrect" religious views. Populations of people are driven from country to country by screaming mobs because of blood libel and ethnic hatred. Wars were fought over the intrigues, emotions, and personal vendettas of a reality-divorced royal class throughout much of the middle ages. By comparison, resource wars are almost rational. Two things that really come to mind as actual wars for resources is our westward expansion, and the Japanese invasion of Manchuria. Other than that, it's pretty much tribalism and ideology for the 20th century. This whole Iraq thing would be absurdly simple if it were really about oil. We would simply have taken and held the wellfields, driven the native population off, and shot anyone attempting to interfere with our operations.
ams182764
PS, about borders, I really don't understand people who don't understand borders and sovereignty. They may not be physical, but they have life and death, freedom and slavery consequences for people. The differences between the civilizations can be so stark in some instances that these borders actually are visible from space. See the north/south korea border for example.
CosmicConservative
ams: I completely agree, that is why I described Anders' view on this as "naive." And that is probably a kind word for it. Virtually every war of the 20th century, and as far back as I can think, are over ideology, religion or racial hatred. Very, very few are over borders or resources. Even "Imperial" conquests are not about borders, they are about assimilation, which is more driven by ideology than by a desire to encroach on neighboring borders.
Rick Larson
The coming resource wars: http://www.tomdispatch.com/index.mhtml?pid=10216 Click on the last link in the body of the post for a book recommendation.