Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Peak Oil is not the End

By Rick Larson
But Energy Returned On Energy Invested (EROEI) is. There may be a point in the future when the energy needed to draw oil out of the ground will be equal to the energy gained.  But I am of the view the oil will be worthless even before a 1:1 ratio is reached.  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EROEI

Comments (10)

ams182764
You could drive the process with nuke plants. EROEI doesn't have to be 1.
ams182764
Well, to clarify, it doesn't have to be 1 for anything but our primary driving energy source. A hydrogen car has an EROEI of 0.
ams182764
One of my problems with solar and wind, apart from the massive land use dependence for the power, is that, though the EROEI might be there over the lifespan of the generator (I'd have to do the math to make sure), it is returned very very sloowly. It's not very high grade (low entropy) power collection. On the other hand, a nuke plant can return the energy invested in it's infastructure in minutes, and produce arbitrary amounts of power on any piece of real-estate.
Rick Larson
Uranium just pushed past 110 dollars per pound up from 7 bucks just a short time ago. Since 7 dollar uranium virtually stopped the developement of new mining, there is no inventory. And now that the largest uranium mine has flooded, I wonder if there is sufficeint time to correct this imbalance in time for Nuclear to make a difference. Hydrogen can only be compared to a battery as it takes electricity to make it..
CosmicConservative
Rick: Excellent point on hydrogen. I have tried so hard to make people understand this simple point that hydrogen is separated from oxygen using electricity. Because of the laws of thermodynamics, you can't get an equal amount of energy back out when you burn it, so you are effectively losing efficiencies on both ends of the hydrogen fuel cycle. Fusion is the answer man. Fusion.
ams182764
The price indeed doubled this year. That's because demand went banannas in India and China. The supply rate is increasing. There is new mining.
ams182764
http://www.uxc.com/ http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/nuclear/dupr/qupd.html
ams182764
PS, I really don't see how nuclear fusion is going to provide commercial power, or why anyone hangs their hats on it. Have you seen what it takes to run a tokomak, or to build one, much less a hypothetical one that reaches breakeven? They aren't fitting in your car, that's for sure. Betavoltaic batteries or RTG systems on the other hand...
ams182764
PPS, even if the price of uranium were to reach $500/lb (at which point we could afford to extract it from sea-water), that it would cause problems for the economic feasability of a nuke plant. It's still going to provide more energy over it's lifetime than 30,000 lbs of coal. The price of coal is somewhere around $30/ton, which still leaves uranium 4 times cheaper per unit energy. And that's just with conventional reactors. I doubt people will be using the same reactor types that we've built in the 50s when they start building them again. The cost of a nuke plant has nothing to do with the cost of the fuel. Some of it is infastructure cost. Most of it is licensing, legal fees, and political risk.
CosmicConservative
The reason fusion is the answer is because it scales to the point that using electricity to recharge batteries or create hydrogen becomes not only economically feasible, but environmentally neutral.