Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Wind Power IS Sustainable

By Rick Larson
Really get jacked up when someone insists we can burn fossil fuels for our energy needs forever on the cheap and with no cost to our environment. So it is no surprise to those who know me personally that I ripped a local judge for a decision to deny a permit for a proposed wind farm. What is just doubly bothersome is this wind farm had already been granted the permit by a committee of our elected officials. So I let the Judge have it: ShortLink:MANopinion Hope I don't get pulled over for speeding...

Comments (10)

CosmicConservative
What has this got to do with whether wind power is sustainable or not? And who says it's not? Of course it is. And if you're lucky, you'll get enough electricity to run your TV off of each windmill. Build a big enough windfarm and besides killing lots of birds and using up lots of real estate that could be used for, oh, growing trees maybe, you'll get to trickle a few percentage points of amps into the power grid. Go ahead Rick, I'm sure wind power will make you feel a whole lot better about your energy use. By the way, any idea what the energy cost is in manufacturing one of those big 'ol windmills? How long do you think they have to turn to pay back just the cost of smelting the metals, forming the plastic (which comes from, oh, I don't know.. PETROLEUM maybe?) and hauling the thing to set it up? Then repairing them, etc. When you look at the actual total cost, in money, energy and real estate, I'm afraid they aren't nearly the panacaea you seem to think they are.
Rick Larson
Please, read this carefully: http://www.awea.org/pubs/factsheets/Cost2001.PDF
Rick Larson
Oh, hey, since your concerned with birds you should be aware that wind generators kill approximately 60,000 birds a year versus way over 1,000,000 a year for glass windows. So by your thinking we should'nt use glass for windows? Then there is those monster engines on Passenger Jets. http://www.endlessenergy.com/windenergy.shtml
CosmicConservative
Rick: Heh. That's the argument I use! I actually approve of and encourage wind power. And solar. And tidal. And geothermal. I'm all for being as wise as possible in our energy use. I'm just telling you that if you even could manage to extract enough energy out of the atmosphere, tides and earth's heat to make a difference in the world's energy use, you probably are going to end up down the road with environmental impacts that were not anticipated. That's a LOT of energy to pull out of thin air. (heh)
Kevin in WI
I agree that renewable resources such as solar and wind can become a major portion of our energy supply (20-30% - higher if we want to "overbuild" capacity). The real issue; however, is transmission. Where the winds are, the people aren't. In general, the same is true for solar (which has other problems). I think wind power can make a huge impact, but not until we've mastered relatively low cost (high temp) superconducting wire technology to solve the transmission issue. A buried superconducting "high line" backbone network in the US would be incredibly reliable, and it would facilitate renewables. That's where we need to focus. We make that happen, and our energy options multiply significantly.
Rick Larson
That is what big business and government hopes Kevin. As those in centralized command fight for the answer, those of us who know will purchase and install small reliable sustainable energy devices. Bypass the taxing authority and ending the sedentary lifestyles of big business. You hit the nail right on the head there fellow Wisconsinite. Without the energy from fossil fuels, most people will choose to relocate - should they have the resources. And those (resources) may be soon scarce. But, we can always hope for the best..
Kevin in WI
Wow. You read far too much into my post. I was merely stating that the limiting factor for widespread use of alternative energies such as wind and solar is economically transmitting the power from where it's generated to where the demand is without losing all of it. I'm not really sure what you meant in that first paragraph, but since when does something have to be centralized to be taxed? The onerous LOCAL property taxes inflicted on us here in Wisconsin are a perfect example.
Rick Larson
Wow. Hard to believe you are merely stating the obvious. :-) Just isolate energy taxes from other means of wealth confiscation. It will be much more difficult to raise property taxes because one must write a check and send it in. Whereas with energy taxes, it is collected at the point of sale - an easy process. Zero energy houses do not pay energy taxes and this will leave a hole in authority's budgets, a good thing in my view. Also, zero energy housing will not need transmission lines!
Kevin in WI
Well, I'm not sure what a 'zero energy' house is. If by zero energy you mean that none is supplied from off-site, then (as stated by Cosmic above) don't forget to take into account the tremendous amount of energy consumed to manufacture that beloved solar or wind system. Also, I guess I'll state the obvious again: How does local energy production avoid taxes? How about building permits, standby fees, sales taxes on the equipment, taxes paid on the electricity used to mfg said equipment? Setting aside minor issues such as aesthetics and logistics, how do you propose we come up with the $3-4 trillion necessary to free American homes from the grid (assume 120 million households at ~$25k each), all the while continuing investment centralized generation and T&D so that those not easily or not yet converted can still get power? Back to reason for your original posting: What was the judge's reason for ruling against allowing the wind farm in Manitowoc?
Rick Larson
Yes, zero energy is a term used to denote a building that doesn't use fossil fuels. Here in Wisconsin it is used to highlight the Leopold Center. Ok, so tell me just how much "tremendous amount of energy" does it take to manufacture solar and wind energy devices? And while your at it, compare the cost to something, say, like manufacturing automobiles. And then, do the calculations as to how much energy automobiles use over their short lifespans vs the SAVINGS generated by using these clean free energy devices for decades. Believe it, this can happen and those not recognizing the reality of higher utility bills will be left with a bare wallet and no place to turn. And, my point about taxes is the government can not place a point of sale tax on the energy. Get it? The energy. And I do not propose to free American homes from the grid in short order. This will take 50 years. Come on, this is common sense. I am wondering if you are here to bother me at the behest of the Bitch of the Walleye Central board? The Judge had no reason to make this ruling other than to side with the malcontents. He even ran roughshod over the grandfathered rule.