Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (9)

CosmicConservative
Rick: I was not aware that you are a Republican. I guess that means you must have voted for Bush in the last two elections. Cool. Now, as in your comment on the SCOTUS CO2 ruling, you again promote this fantasy of a "market" based on "environmental values." This simply demonstrates how out of touch you are with true market forces. The "free market" does not react to moralizing Rick. The reason the free market has not been used as a tool for the environmental movement is precisely because it is a "free market." Meaning that people buy and sell what they are interested in for reasons of personal desire. You can't manufacture a "free market" desire Rick. You can try to hype one up, but if they haven't hyped up the environment enough yet to create a free market environmental movement, it stands to reason that the reason why is because there isn't a market for it. People love to talk feel-good environmental stuff and demonstrate their moral superiority in self-congratulatory marches or protests, but the hilarious irony is that the vast majority of those marchers got to the march in the same gas-guzzling, CO2-spewing, "most dangerous invention in human history" (according to Al Gore) automobile that those of us who live in the real world drive. And they go home after their dose of feel-goodism to homes filled with the same refrigerators, TVs, air conditioners and other appliances that the rest of us go home to. The reason they don't all rush out and by electric cars and Priuses is because it isn't economically feasible to do so. The difference between you and me is that I recognize this as a fact, and those self-righteous marchers seem to think it is due to some conservative plot to keep the people enslaved to the oil companies. When some great corporate industrial giant like Toyota or Honda mass produces a cost-effective replacement for the automobile, then we'll all buy one Rick. Until then people will continue to drive their SUVs to the protest rallies, so they can feel better about driving their SUV in the first place. And feeling better about it is all they are really after in the first place, or they wouldn't be living and driving the same way the rest of us do already.
ams182764
In my opinion, I see two hurdles to creating an alternative to fossil fuels. 1: We need to mow down the red tape that strangled the nuclear revolution in it's cradle, and start using, researching, and developing that whole branch of technology again. Environmentalists have fantasies about windmills and ethanol producing enough energy to replace what we currently get from oil. They won't. Nuclear is one of the only ways that I consider practical. Supposedly you could also get away with it by paving Texas with solar panels also, but I think one is far easier and cheaper than the other. See economic feasibility. 2: We need to create a storage medium that acheives the energy density of gasoline, the reliability of the internal combustion engine, and the safety of the internal combustion engine. So far nothing has come close in any of these categories. This is going to be the real technological hurdle. The other is primarily a social hurdle - undoing three decades of misplaced hysteria, fearmongering, and draconian regulation that made us turn aside from one of the most powerful inventions mankind has produced. (Makes me think of John Galt's engine, sitting in a trash heap).
ams182764
PS. "I don't dislike Newt Gingrich ... " doesn't sound like he's demonizing him or anything. The thing that irks conservatives about "nuanced to the nth degree" Republicans is that they don't do what we sent them to office to do. We sent the Republican congress to office to cut taxes, cut regulation, and restore individual liberty. To try to push back the growth, not only of the government, but on it's intrusive involvement in our lives, schools, homes and buisnesses. The net result of all that nuance and compromise has turned out to be that the Dems have gotten their way. On almost everything. Government is more intrusive, larger, and less constrained, even after we sent these clowns to Washington. That includes environmental regulation, which is now on it's way to becoming our state religion. Seizing people's ranches, obstructing people trying to build things, telling buisnessmen that they can't do what they originally set out to when they started construction because (insert bogus endangered subspecies) moved into the area, raising hell for anyone trying to handle anything more reactive than acetone (actually, acetone has to be treated as hazardous material, did you know that?), ect. That's why we get angry at compromisers. The halfway point between where your compromise currently is and the other side's position is always going to converge on their position.
ams182764
Basically, their needs to be an attitude change in Congress. We don't send Congressmen to Washington to be philosopher kings. We send them there to act on their voter's behalf. That doesn't involve their personal views and opinions. If I could, I'd vote to send a robot to Washington. At least it won't respond to lobbying pressure, fancy dinner clubs, media attention baiting, and the need to be seen as a "deal-maker". It would simply vote the way it's voters wanted it to vote on the issues that came up.
Kevin in WI
I agree with you that we don't send congressmen to Washington to be philosopher kings. However, what they accomplish can seem to be "nuanced to the nth degree" because that is the expected side effect of the meatgrinder of a legislative process our founding fathers created. That's why most unnuanced legislation (usually liberal) is often either hidden within other legislation as a rider or just plain deceptively sold as something else (like this ridiculous union voting rule change they are trying to get passed). I think when Republican legislators become "nuanced to the nth degree" it is simply because they have to in order to accomplish at least some of their goals.
Rick Larson
Not only am I a Republican, but I am a Republican Delegate. Judging by those few semi-snide remarks laced through-out your response, I surmise you are not a do'er - as I am - but just a lonely conservative hiding in your pristine wilderness (somewhere in the cosmic) uncumbered by the forces that effect the climate I live in. I am also proud of the fact my district was the main force behind electing the only Republican candidate, nationwide, to win a Democratic seat - AG JB Van Hollen. And just so you are fully aware of the level of my commitment to the Republican Party, I knocked doors, made calls, paid hefty donations, and attendend strategy meetings through the election process. So, what have you done? But, I am willing to agree that you are simply confusing whacked-out environmentalists who - based on a whim - sieze people's private property, or worse, impose draconian punishment for violating senseless infractions with what Newt and I do agree on, which is proper research to what truly poisons the environment and take measures to discontinue what ails it (the environment). One other diss you must endure; you have either not taken the time to study these issues, or you are simply afraid of the implications and/or don't care one bit about them happily driving along in your resource guzzling CO2 polluting SUV. I'll give you one quote from Aristotle to chew on to help make my point: "That which is most common to the greatest number has the least care bestowed upon it". That is why we MUST take steps to impose a rule set.
CosmicConservative
Rick: Good points. I do not participate that heavily in politics, and the reasons are, in my mind, sufficient and compelling for me not to do so. You can disagree if you want, I have chosen to participate mostly through this blog and other participation online in various incarnations. Not so much with my feet and my money, both of which I need to put to other use in my life at the moment. But I certainly respect the effort you have gone to and appreciate that you are so active. In that sense it is probaby quite fair of you to regard me as a conservative dilettante. I won't challenge that assessment. But, I will challenge your assertion that I do not study the issues or understand the implications. I have followed the science and the debate of Global Warming for as long as it has been an issue, which was just soon after Global Cooling was the alarming threat of the day. As far as the implications of CO2 release are concerned, you and I are simply not reaching the same conclusions when faced with the same evidence. Perhaps you are right, perhaps I am right, more likely neither of us is right and the truth is still out there somewhere waiting to be discovered. But I will continue to assert that human beings are not going to give up the lifestyle they enjoy on their own. And when people start talking about "imposing a rule set" on the populace "for their own good" then I start to smell something that doesn't smell very good. You are the one who raised the issue of "market forces." I believe market forces are already at work to resolve the issues you are worried about, and I have great faith in technology. I know that when the automobile was introduced it was rightly recognized as a great liberator of people from the dangerous, unhealthy and environment threatening use of millions of horses in every urban area on earth. Now automobiles are in the place that horse-driven transportation was a century ago. And I am quite certain that the solution to the "problem" of automobiles is closer than most people think. But there is a much bigger problem than automobiles, Al Gore's myopic visions aside. The bigger problem is the generation of electricity that powers this lifestyle of ours. One of my favorite ironies is watching "environmentalists" brag about their electric cars. I have not yet met one who understands that electricity is not "magic" that it does not appear out of thin air. It is generated in this country almost completely by burning coal or natural gas, both of which pour mammoth amounts of CO2 into the atmosphere. And since it is impossible to convert energy from one source to another without losing energy in the process, the reality of these electric cars is that they actually generate MORE CO2 than the gas cylinder cars they replace. And that is not even talking about the environmental cost of a couple dozen sulfuric acid based lead-acid batteries which run them. It is this sort of selective blindness that makes me consider most "environmental activists" to be dangerously ignorant. I put Al Gore into that category, by the way, because I prefer to believe he is sincerely ignorant than that he is actively evil. When you give up your air conditioners, refrigerators, washing machines, automobiles, power boats and lawn mowers, then you can lecture me on how I have not "studied the issues" Rick. Until then it is just a case of one pot calling another black. Market forces will be what eventually changes the world for the better, but not through draconian imposition of them by people who seem not to understand the law of unintended consequences.
ams182764
About CO2 - it is a colorless, odorless, non-reactive gas which is non-toxic in any reasonable concentration that we will enocunter in the open air. Other than enhancing plant growth, and possibly contributing to a greenhouse effect which will slightly modify our climate change, it has no effects on anybody. The only way it can be called "pollution" is by a moral philosophy that holds that things which serve man are wrong.
Rick Larson
Ok ams, I'll concede the inferred point, in itself, CO2 is not a posionous gas. But how about carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide? Please tell me how does arsenic, mercury, and lead emmisions get on the list? Benzene? Dioxin? Did you know particulate matter is unhealthy? And other than the apparant wasting of my time arranging words on various message boards, I do have a plan. This year I am having solar hot water installed, soon thereafter it will be passive solar heat, then pv for electric. When an electric car is marketed that gets more than 100 miles to a charge, I will install a wind turbine and buy that car! Then, have spent time lobbying various local officials even recently speaking to Wisconsin's Secretary of Commerce Mary Burke. Even going to Madison to meet and follow up with this plan of ours to turn our dairy farms into methane-producing powerhouses.