Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The "Modern Liberal" defined

By CosmicConservative

Open the original video on YouTube

This is probably all over the net now. I've seen it linked a few times, but hadn't listened to it until tonight. Evan Sayet is a Hollywood writer who gave this speech at the Heritage Foundation, one of the nation's top conservative think-tanks. In it he describes what he believes to be the fundamental problems with "modern liberalism" or "Liberalism with a capital L" as he calls it. Among the things he says that I think are somewhat profound are: 1. The book "The Closing of the American Mind" predicted much of what Liberalism has become today. 2. Liberalism as it exists today is essentially a "cult of indiscriminateness" where the only "good" in the world is the unwillingness to define "good" and therefore "evil." 3. This cult inevitably leads to the wrong conclusion when applied in practice. 4. Our culture has allowed this cult to indoctrinate our children for 40 years. His rationale for why this cult leads to the wrong decision goes like this: "If you truly believe that it is wrong to discriminate between options, then you must believe that there is no expectation that one option would lead to a better outcome than another. So if one outcome does consistently succeed while another consistently fails, then the only conclusion must be that the successful one cheated, and the failed one was victimized. So the very success of an option is evidence of its immorality, and therefore must be opposed fully." This, he says, is why Reagan, Thatcher, Bush and even Guiliani are always compared to "Hitler." Because discrimination is always wrong, and all of those conservatives discriminated. Reagan and Thatcher discriminated against communism. Guiliani discriminated against prostitutes and street thugs. Bush discriminates against terrorists. Therefore they are guilty of the same discrimination evil as Hitler because Hitler discriminated against Jews. It's a very entertaining talk. Unless you're a Liberal. In which case you should probably prepare to be thoroughly discriminated against. Which will raise all of your moral hackles and you will be certain to decide that Evan Sayet is evil. Which, I think, might just prove his point.

Comments (3)

ams182764
While "discrimination" and "generalization" were historically used as euphamisms for some rather ugly racism, you can't inductively reason without generalization (the actual concept, shorn of it's loaded connotations). Inductive reasoning is a lot more general and robust than deductive reasoning (which can only work given clean premises, about which many implications are known). It's how we get most of our information about the world. Generalization of trends in the data lies at the very foundation of how this works. While the 100th time you touch a red stove burner might not yield a painful reaction, most people don't hold on to the logical possibility of the inapplicability of previous data after the second or third mistake. When you have liberals shrieking about us generalizing and discriminating, when we (inductively) reason that most terrorists that have attacked us in the past have been Muslim (though I suppose you could also throw in a category for Eco-Terrorists), and therefore we will proceed to focus our search based on past trends, they are absolutely right. We have generalized. We have discriminated. An association has been formed. But the real root of our disagreement is that we don't hold that it is wrong to form associations about the world. At a fundamental level, the mind works by forming associations based on feedback. While it does not follow deductively that because past terrorists have been religiously motivated by fundamentalist Islam, that future terrorists will be as well (the next big attack could be by Canadians disgruntled by the next Olympic hockey match), it is still not a terrible rule.
ams182764
Logical reasoning is a subset of math, and math is an extremely powerful tool. But when reality hands you a fuzzy, limited cloud of points through your fallible senses, rather than a complete-time-history omniscient analytical set of equations describing your situation, you have to resort to drawing lines and curves through the data. Syllogisms only work when your model holds, and your model itself probably came from empirical observation.
» Pertinent repost… CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains
[...] and preserve the traditional definition of marriage. The debate reminded me of a video of Evan Sayet Cosmic posted back in April, 2007. It’s worth [...]