Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire Review

By CosmicConservative
I like the Harry Potter books. I have read all of them and should probably do a review of Harry Potter and the half-blood prince. For what it is worth, I think "Goblet of Fire" was the best story in the books. I say the best story because the writing of Goblet suffered from poor editing, which is common when a writer becomes a "star." Most of Rowling's books could use some serious editing. I really liked the previous Harry Potter movie, "The Prisoner of Azkaban" which I thought had some of the best cinematography and editing of any movie I've seen lately. As the books have progressed the characters are developing from children into teenagers and now into young adulthood. Because the movies take so long to make the actors are outgrowing their parts a bit, but for this movie at least it still works. Goblet of Fire is the first book where you start to get the feeling that Voldemort is really a dangerous and evil wizard. In previous books his powers are weak, his followers are scattered and his attempts on Harry's life are serious enough, but don't come across as really determined. In Goblet of Fire you see a lot more of Voldemort and his followers, the "Death Eaters." One scene in particular, when a party of Death Eaters send an entire crowd of normal wizards into panic, starts to get the point across. Goblet of Fire is very dark, and is the first of the movies to get a PG-13 rating, a rating it well deserves. If there was a sunny day in the movie, I don't remember it, most of the movie is shot in rainstorms, or in dingy dungeons or at night. The Goblet of Fire itself is essentially a magical device that controls the entry and selection of contestants in a major wizard competition between three wizard schools. The winner receives the coveted "Tri-Wizard Cup" which is said to grant lifetime fame to the wizard that wins it. Harry being 14 is not allowed to enter since the Goblet is magically protected from anyone under 17 entering the competition. One student from each of the three wizard schools is selected by the Goblet. The three schools are Hogwarts, a female wizard school and an all male school. One student from each school is selected, with Cedric Diggory being selected for Hogwarts. The student from the all male school is none other than Viktor Krum, the world's greatest Quiditch Seeker, and a hero of Ron Weasley's for that reason. Of course there is something afoot though, because the Goblet unexpectedly also spits out Harry Potter's name, even though Harry swears he did not cheat to enter it. Being a magical competition, once you are entered, there is no way out, and the competition is dangerous, even for 17 year olds. The competition is in three trials, with the winner in each of the first two trials gaining an advantage in the final trial. The first trial involves fighting fire-breathing dragons, the second involves merfolk and the final trial involves a menacing hedge-maze. To reveal any more would be to spoil some of the scenes. Most of the movie centers around Harry's efforts to survive the trials, and his difficulties in personal relationships, most notably with Ron Weasley with whom he has a falling-out. Hermione, Ron and Harry all struggle with their respective opposite sexes, and teenage date-angst provides some of the funnier scenes in the movie. But that's about all the fun there is. The reason for Harry's involvement in the trials is slowly revealed and is tied to the rejuvenation of Voldemort himself. The final scenes are not merely dark, they are difficult to watch and could easily cause some small children to have nightmares. It probably is no spoiler to reveal that Voldemort is fully restored to his power in the end, and then he and Harry have a confrontation. People die in this movie, including at least one that the audience gets to know and like. This is not like the previous movies where nothing really bad happens and Dumbledore seems to be able to make everything all right with a clap of his hands and a folksy bit of wizard-wisdom. Dumbledore himself reveals his own limitations to Harry, and in this movie, perhaps for the first time, Harry really has to draw on his own resources to survive. The action is well paced, with peaks of activity during the trials themselves, and several threads weaving around the main plot line. There are memorable new characters, including a possible love-interest for Hagrid of all people. I thought the scenes dealing with young hormones and youthful infatuation were well done. The special effects were spectacular, but not the focus of the attention, which is as it should be. The acting was spotty, but better than earlier movies, and Daniel Radcliffe, who portrays Harry Potter, probably did his best work by far in this movie. In previous movies I felt the boy who played Ron Weasley had done the best acting of the child stars, but in this movie I thought Harry and Hermione were both better. Ron mostly seemed to have difficulty deciding if his character was petulant or moody, and ended up being both, but sometimes at the wrong times. The final fifteen minutes of the movie are powerful and moving. They send a signal to those who have not read the books that things are about to get very unpleasant for wizards everywhere. The series which began as a sort of modern day fairy tale, is now moving into more of a gothic horror story. My only complaint is the same one I always have with JK Rowling. Bless her heart, she simply cannot write realistic wizard battle scenes. Her idea of magic is that it is completely arbitrary and anything can happen, and of course that's usually how Harry gets out of trouble, not by mastering powerful spells and delving into the mysteries of magic, but by stumbling on some sudden trick or spell that has never been hinted at before, but seems to be just the thing Harry needs at just the right time. It always comes across to me as Harry winning because the author meant him to win, not because he really deserves to win. As good as the books are, and as good as the movies are, a bit of realism in the conflict would have made these great movies. Harry should really be a powerful wizard, not just have a reputation that he seems befuddled by. That worked for the first book, but when he's confronting Voldemort, it is not quite believable that he can stand up to him. Rowling should have made that conflict more compelling by having Harry actually be a precociously powerful wizard, not one who constantly needs Hermione's help just to pass his classes. Still, I highly recommend it.

Comments (1)

Cullen
I agree with your review and feel quite the same. I have long had problems witht he deus ex magus that solves all the HP issues. Being that she's writing, supposedly, to the juvenile market, you want to read some kind of message into her conclusions. You are lead to believe that she's saying: The magic/power is in us alll, you just have to believe and study and you can overcome adversity and acheive greatness. Which is a great message. But she doesn't make it. Hermione is the only character who studies diligently and really deserves any kind of great benefits, but she doesn't get it. Harry blunders through everything and somehow he's an amazing and talented wizard. Doesn't make sense. Oh well. Fun movie, though.