Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The charade begins

By CosmicConservative
New video shows British detainee 'confession' - CNN.com TEHRAN, Iran (CNN) -- Iranian Arabic language network Al Alam on Friday aired a new video showing one of 15 British detainees apologizing to Iranians for "entering your waters without permission." A few hours later, Iran released a letter said to be written by another British sailor, Faye Turney, stating she had been "sacrificed" to the policies of the British and U.S. governments. The British government responded to the video by criticizing the treatment of the sailors and marines, with Prime Minister Tony Blair saying Iran faced "increasing isolation" for refusing to release the service personnel. There was no immediate reaction by the British government to the Turney letter.
As usual, an individual's willingness to believe any of the coerced statements is inversely proportional to their basic intelligence.

Comments (8)

pace
On one hand, one hopes that these servicemen have come to no harm. On the other, I hope that they did not readily allow themselves to be exploited in this way. I think we have to give them the benefit of the doubt and assume they've been tortured or placed under such extreme duress that they felt they had no choice but to say these things. I also think that Britain needs to quit screwing around and take peremptory action.
CosmicConservative
Actually most military services these days train their people if they become hostages to cooperate as much as possible to avoid torture.
ams182764
I was listening to a Vietnam war veteran who almost escaped from one of the prison camps. He was eventually released in a prisoner exchange before we pulled out. He said that they would torture them daily to make them confess on tape to false crimes. He said that some of the men in his camp were ordered to give names of "war criminals", people that they knew of high repute in the military, so that they could manufacture propoganda to feed to our media. Some of them came up with the bright idea of slipping "Paul Bunyan" and "Clark Kent" in. When other prisoners were beaten senseless and interrogated about them, they knew enough about what was going on to act like they knew of them. (Clark Kent is a famous "pilot", of some repute back in New York. He's thought of as a hero back home). When this stuff reached our shores, it helped to discredit the lies coming out of their prison camps. (Well, these sorts of things went down the memory hole as far as the MSM went, but even so...)
ams182764
He had some colorful choice words when asked about Jane Fonda, who was directly responsible for the deaths of many of these prisoners when she told the prison camp commander the messages that they wanted her to covertly relay home to their families.
pace
Anyone else notice that service woman Faye Turney is wearing a head scarf in the video stills?
CosmicConservative
Yeah, most of the rightie blogs spotted that right away. If a Muslim woman were being held hostage and forced to remove her head scarf, there would be worldwide outrage. But forcing a non-Muslim to wear a Muslim head scarf is considered "being respectful of their religion" I guess. This is part of the double-standard in dealing with Islam that drives the folks at Little Green Footballs, and JihadWatch (to name a few) insane. It is just as offensive to force a non-Muslim to participate in a Muslim custom as it is to force a Muslim to not participate in that same Muslim custom. This seems like an obvious case of reciprocity to me, but the world doesn't see it that way. And my personal opinion is that the reason it isn't seen that way is because Christians are not going to riot, murder and declare fatwahs over it. So in essence the entire double standard that this demonstrates is a tacit admission that Islam is bullying the rest of the world, and for now at least, MOST of the rest of the world is too cowardly to refuse to be cowed by the threats.
Kevin in WI
I'm not very optimistic that we aren't in for this being a long event. This was obviously premeditated. I think what will be most sad about it is that, by the end of it, the average Brit will be somehow blaming us for it (the BBC will make sure of that). The one bright spot is that this will again highlight for the British elites that they can't trust their fellow EU members to stand in their corner when things get tough.