Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Book Review: The Trouble With Physics

By CosmicConservative
by Lee Smolin. A fascinating book. I've sort of reviewed it in parts as I was reading it, but I'll go ahead and sum it all up here. Smolin is trying to make two separate, but related, points with this book. First he is trying to explain to the lay public why String Theory (and its latest revision, "M-Theory") is not yet an actual theory in spite of its domination of theoretical physics now for almost 30 years. Secondly he is trying to explain why the community of theoretical physicists has some serious problems which he believes greatly reduce creativity and revolutionary thought. He manages to do both of these things, but unfortunately he weaves them together so much that it's hard to stay focused on one at a time so that by the time he's gotten his story complete, the reader can be a little lost so that the impact is greatly lessened. In honor of Smolin's focus on "foundational" issues, I'm going to address the book's foundational issues. To go after point #1 Smolin's main point is that all current (and proposed) quantum theories (including String and M Theories) are background dependent theories, meaning that they only work if the calculations of the theories are applied to a strict geometrical coordinate system much like you learned in middle school, but applied to a higher number of dimensions (usually ten or eleven). But this is in direct conflict with General Relativity, which is background independent and whose calculations operate in a flexible space-time continuum where there is no background coordinate system and the coordinates of space and time ripple and warp as energy and matter move through them. This is a pretty compelling argument, and it should be since this argument has been going on since the 1920s, with no end in sight. His main point in this area is that theoretical physics should be applying significant resources to the problem of defining a background independent quantum theory which allows general relativity to "emerge" from the quantum effects. There are very few people on earth working on this problem today. This is really the problem that Einstein and Bohr left for us to solve, and it hasn't been solved yet. String Theory, he argues, is not making much progress in this direction, and after 30 years, it should have. Which brings us to his other problem. Why isn't there more effort on these non String Theory areas? He tries to show that the current theoretical physics community is overrun with cronyism, financial opportunism and a sort of groupthink that has identified String Theory as the solution regardless of its actual verifiability. He gets fairly philosophical on this point, attempting to define "science" in his own terms. Basically he disagrees with the common idea of science as the application of a well defined scientific method. Instead he breaks science down into two areas, which he calls "revolutionary science" and "ordinary science." Ordinary science is performed by science craftsmen, people well trained in the use of scientific skills and methods. These are the people who take theories and turn them into engineering, and they are critical for success. But, he argues, these are not the people who create scientific revolutions. He gives several examples (including most of the great names in physics in the 20th century, such as Einstein and Bohr) of revolutionary scientists and tries to make the case that they are revolutionary because they focus on foundational issues and think deeply about them for long periods of time. The physics craftsman is one that makes a name for himself and quickly moves up the ladder of physics academia, establishing themselves as a member of the fraternity of physicists. The physics revolutionary typically is either unwilling or unable to get such jobs because they are not usually the most gifted physics tool users. By virtue of choice or circumstance, they labor for years in solitude on very deep questions that most physicists find to be unrewarding in terms of career recognition. Einstein, who worked in the German Patent Office when he made most of his great advances, was one of these. Smolin essentially says that the theoretical physics community is currently heavily favoring the physics craftsmen over the physics revolutionaries. The result is that incredibly detailed and difficult work is being done in a few areas, but in spite of all the hard calculations and transformations involved, not much progress has been made. He ends the book with a series of pleas to his readers, separating them according to their roles. He asks the public to hold physicists feet to the fire and demand to see results from the vast investment of money into physics research projects. He asks academic administrators to stop stacking the deck with String Theorists and to actively seek out new Einsteins by offering positions to physicists with unusual theories. He offers some suggestions on how to weed out the true visionary from the crackpot. For the theoretical physics community itself he asks them to rededicate themselves to the ideals of science, particularly those involving listening to dissent and subjecting their theories to experimental proof. He then says that he himself will attempt to adopt the role of visionary or revolutionary. As he puts it "I'm going to go off somewhere for a while and think." I have to say that I find myself feeling that Smolin is onto something. Of course I've been a String Theory skeptic for many years, so perhaps that's not new. But perhaps more importantly this book has made me view my own career in a different light. I did not pursue a Masters and ph.D. in Physics when I could have, and now I wonder if that may have been a blessing. As he describes things, I don't think I would have been successful in theoretical physics for the past 30 years. I would likely have been one of those struggling to find employment because I would want to focus on foundational issues. Those are the things I've thought about my whole life, and I don't see any reason to think things would change once I got into a Physics career. So I may have ended up a very frustrated physicist. As it is I'm a frustrated software development project manager, but I make a better living. ;) I highly recommend the book if you have either a desire to understand the issues in physics today, or if you are interested in the sociology and politics of physics academia. It opened my eyes in both areas.

Comments (1)

ams182764
I'll have to get that book. I'm an engineer, so I have some background with a lot of different types of physics, most of which takes some very very general laws and spends a lot of time setting them up for specific classes of situations which we'll encounter. My solid rocket propulsion class started with a bunch of basic thermodynamics, then took the equations down to the isentropic flow cases, then took some burn rate stuff from chemistry (a lot of which is empirical), then took a lot flow physics stuff (but pared that down to the basic situation as well). Towards the end, we had dozens of very complicated equations that described the one specific situation - our solid rocket problems (we worked two or three of them, after a semester of boiling down the physics). All those elegant sets of neat equations don't look so elegnant after an applied situation and an engineering professor has mauled them! I should get back into physics and figure out how people get that stuff to begin with as well. There are many involved pieces of math that flew by in our classes, which I never had the time to see how they were all derived.