Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Anti-war sentiment grows in Americans aged 50+

By CosmicConservative
Poll: Anti-war sentiment grows in Americans 50 and over - CNN.com WASHINGTON (CNN) -- As the war in Iraq steadily plummets in popularity, opposition has grown mostly among Americans older than 50 and Democrats, survey results released Monday show. When President Bush announced March 19, 2003, that U.S.-led forces had begun military attacks, 15 percent of Americans 50 and older strongly opposed the invasion, compared to 18 percent younger than 50. Four years later, the fighting is opposed by 52 percent of Americans 50 and older, and by 42 percent younger than 50.
The majority of those over 50 who oppose the war are a bunch of aging baby boomers who want to relive the glory of their youth by reliving Vietnam protests. You can tell by listening to the chants and songs they are singing at the rallies. When I was a kid they were called "flower children." What do we call them now? "flower geezers?"

Comments (44)

gjh
If you look at the demographics of the boomers, it is probably their children or grandchildren who are fighting this war. I feel if you have a dog in this fight you have the right to have feelings, one way or the other. The problem with the way this war has been sold, it is like a video game. The government even prohibits pictures of the dead guys casket from being shown. There is a total detach from the reality of this war. I notice that this blog hasn't commented of Walter Reed or commented on the reduction of money that be being allocated to our injured soldiers. I guess in your view this war couldn't be going better.
Boyd
While it still astounds me that I'm in the "over 50" crowd these days, all I can say is that I must be completely out of touch. I run across virtually no one in that age group that doesn't support the war, albeit while acknowledging that the war and pacification efforts could have been done better. And I live in Virginia, not far from DC. Back home in Texas, I daresay the war supporters are even more numerous.
CosmicConservative
gjh: What is to comment on the Walter Reed "scandal?" Should I point out that the problems in the hospital are not in the area of health care so much as in normal maintenance? Should I also point out that due to Democrat initiatives in protecting civil service jobs, the people responsible for that maintenance are not military personnel and cannot be fired by the generals who are taking the blame for the problems that exist there? Should I point out that this sort of government run enterprise with all its faults is precisely what Hillary and others on the left are proposing to replace the privately run hospitals who CAN fire the maintenance staff if they let the place fall apart? Do you really want to go there? As far as the reduction of money for our soldiers goes, do we want to compare Bush vs. Clinton in that regard? Reagan vs. Carter? This is my blog, I'll comment on what I want to comment on. You want to take up issues like that, give us a link to your blog and we'll go there.
gjh
Clinton didn't start a war on a country that was no threat to the US and maim tens of thousands American kids and turn his back on them. Stay on the message, don't respond with I'll take my ball and bat and go home. Is this president supporting the troops or only giving the usual right wing lip service? That is the only question I asked. Who are going to support these limb and brain damaged kids that this war has created? Nothing of this refers to Clinton. Clinton never mentioned in the comment.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Clinton asked permission to start exactly that war, pledged that he would start that war and said that such a war was essential to the safety of the United States, and then didn't have the fortitude to follow up on any of his promises. You can interpret history and current events how you like gjh, I interpret them differently. History will decide who was right. I stuck with Reagan when the Left called him a doddering war-mongering fool, and he proved to be right and is now recognized as one of our greatest Presidents. So the record of the Left in evaluating history and current events is hardly laudable. War has casualties. That's why it's war. If you aren't willing to accept the casualties, don't go to war. But if you DO vote for a war, then allow the appearance of casualties to break your resolve and cause you to try to create an alternate history to support your current views, then you are not only guilty of poor judgment when you voted for war, you are now guilty of lack of courage in your own convictions. Of course you are always able to argue that you were so stupid that an illiterate moron was able to fool you into voting for something you didn't believe in, but that's hardly a compelling endorsement of your character now is it?
gjh
Listen Reagan, as you call him began the war on the working class, I'm quite sure you make less than $300,000. so you are one of the ones to get screw by him. You never answered to questions of the previous post! Where do you stand? Does the president and your subsequent stand support the troops? Who will pay for their injuries and treatment? Who will bear the brunt of this war? Are you going to contribute by your less than $300,000 income per year or are the rest of us slobs that only make $80,000 a year going to pay for it for the rest of our and childrens lives. Where do you stand or like the rest of the reactionary right just going to hide hehind your rich daddy or behind a philosophy that is idealistic rather than reality based.
CosmicConservative
gjh: You can rail against history and Ronald Reagan the rest of your life. Your class warfare rhetoric tells me all I need to know about your willingness to accept basic facts. I support the troops, their mission and the President's authority to have gone into Afghanistan and Iraq in the first place. Those very troops you accuse Bush of abandoning continue to support him and his policies by a large majority. I suppose you join John Kerry in believing that just shows how ignorant and hopeless they must be. They are getting their injuries treated. There is always waste and mismanagement in any organization, and that includes the military. I am quite confident that both Republicans and Democrats will work as hard as they need to for the troops and their medical needs. Who bears the brunt of this war? Not you gjh, that's for damn sure. Nor your kids nor your grandkids. Military spending today is lower than it has been for most of the last 60 years. I've posted proof of this before. So these claims that this war is somehow bankrupting this country are patently and obviously false to anyone who cares to actually look at the facts, but we've already determined your proclivities in that regard. My "rich daddy" was a sharecropper's son who enlisted in the U.S. Air Force and fought in Korea and Vietnam. He made something of himself, but fell on hard times late in his life and left very little behind when he passed last month. It's nice to hear an ideologue like you invoke his name in vain while I'm still dealing with his recent passing. It is clear that you are not interested in discussion, only insults and classic Leftist rhetoric invoking class warfare, stereotypes of conservatives and the "reality based" community. It's such an original diatribe gjh, you should patent it before someone steals it from you.
gjh
Every prediction John Kerry made about this war has come true.
Rick Paffenroth
Cosmic...You say the majority of those over 50 who oppose the iraq war are trying to relive their "glory days" when they protested the Vietnam war. First of all this is a somewhat offensive statement to me. But then I'm sure you could care less about that. Secondly, I'm curious as to your view of what happened in Vietnam, the war, the protests and opposition to the war, the withdrawal which doomed us to 'defeat", how the world would be different today if we had stayed the course and "won" the war, whether the massive loss of life would have been justified, even if we had stayed and "won" the war. I've heard the typical conservative response to the above questions and I'm just wondering where you stand.
CosmicConservative
Rick: The U.S. withdrawal from Vietnam, which occured when Democrats in Congress refused to authorize funds to keep the troops in Vietnam (sound familiar?) led directly to the utter defeat of South Vietnam and the forced indoctrination camps and political trials that killed tens of thousands of our previous allies, and forced "re-education" of hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, more. The withdrawal of US Troops also emboldened Pol Pot in Cambodia to initiate his own political purges that led to the murder of millions of Cambodians in the "Killing Fields" of Cambodia. Democrats and anti-war activists such as Jane Fonda and John Kerry, have the blood of millions of innocent lives on their hands. You can be as offended by that as you like. I don't really care, I care more about the millions of dead and the further millions who suffered for years, including the Vietnamese Boat People. Would the world be significantly different today? Well, for millions of Vietnamese and Cambodians who would still be alive today, yes. For you? Probably not. Because Vietnam was a proxy war with the Soviet Union and China, and the US effectively won that war, although another one with China is brewing. In that geopolitical sense Vietnam was a battle in a larger conflict and the loss of Vietnam was acceptable from a purely strategic sense. But I care for more than pure strategy, I care about innocent lives, U.S. Prestige and honor, and the reputation of the U.S. military, all of which were sacrificed by naive anti-war zealots who seem to think "Give Peace A Chance" means "at all costs, regardless of the outcomes."
Rick Paffenroth
So tell me exactly why you think we were involved in Vietnam, and were the reasons justifiable in your mind?
JSullins
At the risk of hijacking this conversation, I wanted to comment on a different, but related observation of mine. I am a conservative. I have a rich father (which I mention only because it has been injected above by gjh as somehow relevant), though unilke me my father has spent much of his adult life as a registered Democrat. In most cases, I tend to agree with other conservatives on issues. However, I was against the war from the start. The reason is this: I don't accept the taking of human life as a good solution to problems. This occasionally causes me some personal philosphical challenges, as one might expect. This is where it gets interesting, though... I am still appalled by the arguments and behavior of the left in regards to the war. Why? Because it is plain to me that the left is motivated not by any concern for human life, but rather by their hatred of the right and of George Bush. The left has done more to alienate people like me, who might under other circumstances have a voice in opposing the taking of lives, than they have done to further the goals they supposedly have at heart. I am motivated by a belief that human life is sacred, the left is motivated by their obsessive hatred. The difference is significant, and telling. From this, I can conclude that it doesn't actually matter to leftists who oppose the war whether or not innocents are killed, tragedies occur, or people are tortured. What matters to them is whether or not they can humiliate and defeat conservatives, George Bush, and America. It doesn't matter what the cause is, they will oppose conservatives just because of their hate. That's my observation. I state that it is particularly compelling, humbly of course, because I am not in favor of the war. I do not regard GWBush as evil, a liar, or any of the other absurd labels applied to him. Rather, he is a man who earnestly seeks to do what is right. In that regard he is different from his predecessor, who always struck me as trying to do what *other* people thought was right. The essence of true leadership lies with our current president, and I won't hate him for it.
CosmicConservative
Thanks js that was a very compelling response. Rick: There are a lot of reasons we went to Vietnam, some idealistic, some practical and some driven by forces you would probably find comparable to pure evil. But in general I believe what people say publicly unless there are compelling reasons to believe otherwise. And what JFK and LBJ (the President who committed us to Vietnam, and the President who ramped up our forces to such an extent that we lost tens of thousands of lives there) said was that we were doing the work of liberty by attempting to contain communism so that it did not spread into new areas of the world. Now let me point out a few interesting points here that are relevent to JSullins post above: 1. I think JFK is the most overrated President in American History. His "legend" when compared to his actual record is the widest disparity of any President I can think of. I think JFK was borderline incompetent. I think he damaged U.S. credibility worldwide in a number of ways, and I think he was bamboozled by a Soviet Union that blustered and bluffed more than they actually threatened. 2. I despise LBJ. The man was vile. He was personally abusive and profane. He had no ambition beyond the pursuit of personal power. He was perhaps the most vicious streetfighter in U.S. politics since Aaron Burr. He could lie as well as Bill Clinton and could flip-flop as quickly as John Kerry. He was an embarrassment to the office of President. But I believed both of them when they publicly stated their reasons for being in Vietnam. Because I am willing to entertain the notion that people I don't like aren't automatically liars every time a word comes out of their mouths. And I don't personally attack either one of them when discussing their policies. Some of their policies were horrendous, some were admirable. The Bay of Pigs was a travesty. The Peace Corps was downright inspired. So I am quite comfortable with the conclusion that the overriding reason we were in Vietnam was a direct result of the stated policy of Communist Containment. Now, what other reasons were we there? Here are a few. 1. Because we had an active treaty with them. 2. Because we made a promise to the French to hold the line when the French, as the French so often do, bailed out when the going got tough. 3. Because we had an idealistic commitment to the goal of a democratic Vietnam. 4. Because we needed to have a proxy war with China and the USSR so we had some idea of the relative strength of our weapons systems, strategies and tactics in case we actually went to war with either or both of them. I am sure you read #4 and say "aha!" That's fine. I am not quite so quick to call #4 a bad thing from a purely strategic perspective. I don't like the idea that we were in a "hot war" with both military and civilian casualties in order to keep the USSR and China aware of our capabilities and therefore to convince them that perhaps a war against the U.S. was not in their best interest at the time. But I can certainly see its effectiveness as geopolitical strategy. It also kept the pressure on both of those governments to keep funneling money and resources into Vietnam where we could engage them, instead of funneling that same money into Honduras or El Salvadore where we could not engage them. It is no coincidence that after the end of the Vietnam War, the communist influence in South America skyrocketed. I try to have no illlusions about my government or my country Rick, and that means I am as unwilling to believe the worst about them as I am to believe the best. My problem with the Left these days is that they have taken cynical distrust of America as core dogma. There is no balance. America is always wrong. This is doubly true when the country is run by Republicans. JSullins is right. What I see on the left these days is a thin veneer of disingenuous concern for Iraqis that is painted over a massive bulk of hatred of U.S. foreign policy, hatred of the U.S. military, and first and foremost, hatred of G.W. Bush.
Rick Paffenroth
Thanks Cosmic. I agree pretty much with your assessment. And my comment is that not one American life, let alone over 50,000 was worth it based on these reasons. This is why I was opposed to the Vietnam war from the beginning. I
CosmicConservative
So, Rick, what would be worth 1 American life? Grenada? Panama? Bosnia? Europe? What's the standard?
Rick Paffenroth
Good question Cosmic. I think you have to judge each situation on it's unique circumstances and draw your own conclusions. There is no standard.
CosmicConservative
Rick: So when people judge those unique circumstances and draw different conclusions than you, why do you think your judgment is superior to theirs?
Rick Paffenroth
That's an interesting question also. I would tend to say it's more to do with right and wrong than superiority. (I'll leave feeling superior to you conservatives LOL) What I do when forming an opinion on an issue is to read and gather as much information about the issue as possible and then form an opinion based on facts and how those facts relate to my value system. What about you Cosmic, why do feel your opinion is superior to those of opposing views? Let's suppose that you supported the Vietnam war from the beginning (I'm not really clear on your position) and I opposed it. Given the 30 some years that have elapsed since the end of the war, who was right and who was wrong?
CosmicConservative
Rick: I sometimes wonder if people have an internal irony meter. When you say something like "(I’ll leave feeling superior to you conservatives LOL) " does your irony meter go off the scale? Does your hypocrisy flag shoot up the pole? Do you even recognize the hypocrisy and irony you are displaying as you say it? To use your own debate tactics, let me address the "who is right or wrong" on Vietnam by saying "Gee, I though 'right and wrong' were concepts that liberals accused conservatives of fixating on. Imagine a liberal making that an issue." I think this assertion by either conservatives or liberals that their precious conclusions are reached through analysis of facts, while the other side's idiotic conclusions must have been reached through mind control or ignorance is one of the more irritating things I see in modern debate. So, as an example, Newton created his Law of Gravity based on a careful observation of facts. Newton is recognized as one of the greatest, if not the greatest mind in history. And yet he was wrong, and Einstein proved it. Does that mean Newton saw facts wrong? Does it mean he interpreted them wrongly? Does it mean that he created a theory that was inconsistent with the facts? The real world is not that black and white. Although Newton's and Einstein's theories of gravity are completely incompatible, both were "right" and both were (probably, the jury is still out on Einstein) "wrong." It is far more valuable to ask if they were "effective" in achieving the goal of improving our understanding of the universe. And both were and both still are. So to look at Vietnam we have to look at a lot of different things before we can say "right" or "wrong." We can start with the policy of Containment. Was that a "right" policy or a "wrong" policy. Based on the results of the policy, and the fall of the U.S.S.R, which was brought about as a direct result of that policy, it sure sounds like a "right" policy from the vantage point of an anti-communist, free-market advocate like me. But, was it "right" in 1962 when we were on the brink of nuclear war? That's a lot harder to say. But I will stipulate that "Containment" was A right policy, if not THE right policy for the sake of argument here. Now the question becomes "Was Vietnam the right place to draw the line in the sand to exercise that policy?" Based on the reality that once Vietnam fell, the effort of the USSR and China to spread communism in South America increased dramatically, then I would argue that from a purely strategic perspective, it was better for us to keep the fight as far from home as possible for as long as possible, even if the fight was doomed to lose (which I do not believe to be the case). So in that sense Vietnam was the "right" place to confront the spread of communism because that's where China and the USSR were focused on spreading it. That's sort of like saying the "right" place to fix a leak in a boat is where the water is coming in, not where you think the water might come in later. But then a whole host of questions come up involving the actual strategy and tactics of defending Vietnam against Communism in the first place. And there are lots of arguments on both sides. We did too much, we did too little, etc. etc. etc. I personally did not oppose fighting communism in Vietnam. My dad was part of that. I did, however, oppose the indiscriminate dropping of bombs with little regard to their impact on civilians. I thought that was a cowardly way of waging war (similar to Clinton's strategy in Bosnia, for example). I argued that we should have instead mounted a major invasion of North Vietnam, and if China reacted as they threatened to react, then fine, take them out too. I doubt if China would have declared war on the US in the first place, and if they had, I think we'd have kicked their asses in short order, and we wouldn't have some of the problems we have today. See, my theory is, if you are going to do warfare, then do it. Commit massive force to the most strategically critical areas and take out the command and control centers first. That meant take out North Vietnam, not fight a long and costly defensive battle in South Vietnam while the real enemy remained safely behind the lines where they just had to dodge some bombs from time to time. Now, once we are engaged and human beings have pledged their fortunes, their lives and their sacred honor to fight alongside us, I believe we have an obligation to honor that commitment. So the abandonment of South Vietnam was a monstrous "wrong" in every sense. It is hard for me to find a worse moment in American history than when we were pushing desperate human beings away from helicopters knowing that they would be targeted for torture and death from our enemies. That is shameful beyond belief, and when the U.S. Left cheered that moment, that formed a huge base of my opinion of the Left and its motives, its values and its ideology. Little has changed since then to change my mind. Is that helpful?
gjh
JSullins No one hates GWB because of the war. The left is totally disappointed in him for everything else. The US Attoney scandal is one, the Jack Abramoff case in Guam where the Grand Jury was beginning investigations and the Federal Prosecutor is fired ending the investigation, We all know what happened to Abramoff. The failure to enacted the findings of the 911 Commission but using 911 every time to justify war in Iraq. Used it again this week. The Kratrina fiasco blaming everyone but FEMA and still not lifting a hand to fix the problem. The list goes on and on. We on the left only wish that he only screwed up Iraq. He has screwed up the whole Federal Gov't. Wait till he is out of Office and he can no longer run interference on the investigators. Here is the kicker he took the largest surplus in the history of the world and in 6 short year spent it all and drove this Nation into the largest deficet in the history of the world. That is the true reason the left doesn't like GWB. Conservative my a__!
Rick Paffenroth
I'm sorry that my lame attempt at humor rankled you. I did not intend it that way. And yes, I do see the irony in it. Your take on the Vietnam war is very well thought out and your articulate your thoughts well. I disagree that Vietnem was the right place to draw the line in the sand to stop the spread of communism. I really never believed the average Vietnamese peasant really cared what form of government they had, they just wanted to be left alone to take care of their rice paddy. And I never believed that by allowing communism to spread in SE Asia, that we were somehow in more danger ourselves. The real issue came when we decided to get out, and the horrendous slaughter that came about. I don't agree with the peace at any cost crowd. But on the other hand, such difficult decisions with their catastrophic results would not have to have been made had we been more careful and the rush to war and all it's possible consequences been better thought out. And in agreement with you, once the decision is made to go to war, for God's sake do it right and don't pussyfoot around. I totally agree that the world is anything but black and white. That is why, even though a lot of my long held political and social beliefs tend to lean to the left, I continue to seek out information and opinions and news from the other side of the spectrum. And I have learned a lot in doing so, and my opinions have been changed about some relevant issues. I also believe I have a bettered myself as a person by being open to opposing points of view.
CosmicConservative
Rick: Well, it's sort of hard to see the twinkle in your eye while reading the words on this blog. If my response was harsh, I apologize, I simply reacted to the actual words I read instead of the intent with which they were put there. You and I will have to disagree about whether Vietnam was the right place to draw the line. I might point out that the United States did not draw it there, NATO did, and France was the first to try to hold the line after losing North Vietnam a few years earlier. You can believe that communism spreading around southeast asia was no threat to the United States. I consider that opinion to be geopolitically naive. But even beyond the "it's no skin off our nose" argument, I still believe that it was one of JFK's finer moments when he said that "no burden is to great, no price is to high, to ensure the success of liberty in the world" or words to that effect. And even though we "lost" in Vietnam, we bottled the Chinese and USSR aggression for almost 20 years, two decades that led to the bankruptcy of the USSR. As far as whether you have had opinions changed by people on the other side, so have I, but not on this subject. I am generally regarded as quite liberal by most of my conservative friends. gjh: You sure are selective in your outrage. Are you unaware that Bill Clinton illegally fired the White House Travel Office? Were you outraged that he wanted to put his own cronies in those cushy jobs? Do we want to discuss Hillary's Whitewater involvement? How many of the 9/11 Commission's recommendations is the new Democratic majority implementing gjh? Remember they promised to implement ALL of them. How many have they done? Katrina is an area where Bush took too much blame. The book on disasters has always been that the first 72 hours are the responsibility of the state and the city. How much blame do you assign to Nagin and Blanco? If you believe it would have been significantly different if it had happened in 2000 instead of 2005, you are simply naive. Your last point is why conservatives don't like Bush. How is the spending going in Congress since the Dems took control gjh? $25 billion in subsidies including money sent to the Spinach growers who infected children with e. coli being tacked onto the military spending bill doesn't outrage you? Imagine that. There was never a surplus anyway, and if you believe there was, then you are blind to the reality of the U.S. Government budget practices. For a few years under Clinton the US took in more money than they spent, but it barely made a dent in the actual deficit. Looking at U.S. deficit as a percent of GNP (which is the only fair way to look at it) Bush has put it back to just about where it was when Clinton took office. Which coincidentally is just about where it was when Kennedy took office. Now, any decent economically minded conservative can certainly try to explain to you that Clinton inherited the benefits of Reagan and Bush I winning the cold war and the massive reduction in military spending that allowed. And any decent military minded conservative can certainly try to explain to you that Clinton reduced the budget primarily by gutting the military to the point that it had to be rebuilt under Bush II. But I am quite certain such arguments are lost on you since by definition liberals are wonderful and conservatives are evil. So I'll just point out that in the last two years GW Bush has cut his personal contribution to the deficit in half, and at the current rate of surpluses, by the time he leaves office, he'll be just about where he started. Hardly the disaster you try to paint it to be.
gjh
The travel office was let go at the beginning of the first term and replaced the same way that all new appointments are made. They get replaced the same way as the cabinet. 2ndly what did they find about the Clinton involvement in Whitewater? They found that the Clintons lost $55,000 of their investment. Look at the Starr investigation. The only thing he did in his expanded "investigation" was cost the taxpayers about $60 million. He also expanded it include letters to Sock the cat and the cost of fan letters to the first family pet. What sanctions were doled out to the Clintons after the Whitewater Investigation? Stop with the petty crap already!
Rick Paffenroth
I find Kennedy's line you quoted to be quite noble (no price to great to ensure liberty in the world), but at the same time if you look at where our government has chosen to either get involved or not get involved, the nobility thing kind of fades into some rather non-compelling self serving special interest crap. This brings up one of my favorite arguments against both the Vietnam and now the Iraq war. It is impossible to go into a country and try and force democracy on them when the majority of the population of said country is not willing to stand next to you and fight with you to sustain said democracy. Both Bush and Kennedy played the let's make a democracy card, and it didn't work in Vietnam, and it is not going to work in Iraq either, both for different reasons, but when you break it down for the reason I stated above. The majority of the population has to want it for themselves and be willing to die for it too. And you know as well as I do that there are many instances in history where we have chosen to support brutal dictators who subjected their citizens to treatment that was anything but democratic, all in the name of serving our own interests. Not very noble to me.
CosmicConservative
gjh: "Stop with the petty crap already!" You first. You are so quick to explain away the "scandals" of your ideological companions as just a bunch of conservative demagoguery, while insisting that all of the "scandals" of conservatives are already proven. You don't even realize how partisan you are. It's not worth the time to try to reason with you. You appear to be incapable of it on partisan issues. My personal opinion is that both sides are pretty much equal in most regards, and I make my judgment based on proof, not on rumor or partisan hatred. I think there have been legitimate scandals on both sides, and I think there have been ridiculous overblown investigations into innocent activity on both sides. That's what is different about us gjh.
CosmicConservative
Rick: Points well taken. And I think I was clear when I said that I am realistic in my veiw of our government, neither thinking they are above criticism, nor thinking that they are purely evil. The United States has done awful, horrible things both with Democrats and with Republicans (and Whigs ...) in power. And the United States has done noble, wonderful things both with Democrats and with Republicans (maybe not Whigs) in power. I don't think I said I approved of the "force democracy on an unready question" aspect of either the Vietnam or the Iraq wars. I think that's a pretty good argument against it. In fact I am pretty much opposed to "nation building" anyway. However, I did then, and still do now, believe that Saddam Hussein was a threat who needed to be removed. And I hold Bush I accountable for being unwilling to complete a job that needed to be done. But many of the things that we did AFTER defeating the Iraqis in the field of battle seem pretty foolish to me, perhaps the most obvious of which was the disbanding of the Iraqi military and sending them home with guns, no jobs, and a reason to hate us. That could have and should have been handled better. I don't think you and I are so far apart as you might think.
gjh
Disagreement does not equate with hatred from my side.
CosmicConservative
So you assert, but then you "debate" with comments like this:
"Where do you stand or like the rest of the reactionary right just going to hide hehind your rich daddy or behind a philosophy that is idealistic rather than reality based."
If you are able to hurl such nasty and stereotypical insults at people you claim not to hate, I hate to think what you will do when your emotions actually get involved.
gjh
To disagree is not to hate, to ask a question is not hating, it is just asking a question. In framing a question, asking if you believe in the philosophy is not hate. It's asking a frickin question. Asking you to explain something I don't understand. If you don't like the question say so, but quit acting like, remember I said acting, not being, a cry baby.
CosmicConservative
gjh: You can rationalize your insulting behavior any way you want. I'm not buying it. Your "technique" in a debate is to hurl unwarranted insults at people you don't even know, mischaracterize their positions according to your own stereotypical prejudices and then to ignore cogent, relevent rebuttals to the few salient points we are able to extract from your comments. It is not only possible, it is quite likely, that you are not able to recognize these tendencies you display, but I assure you, it is quite clear to the rest of us.
gjh
Now that we have the foreplay out of the way, what sanctions were levied on the Clintons as the result of the Whitewater investigations?
JSullins
gjh: I find it quite hard to believe that you are somehow not motivated by hate. Your denials are preposterous, in fact. Your comments regularly are dripping with venemous and insulting statements, which often serve no purpose other than to demean. Cosmic has bent over backwards to remain civil with you, and you have the truly amazing audacity to attempt to claim you are, "just asking questions." Give. Me. A break. If you want anyone to listen to your positions on issues, you must at least recognize the kind of hypocrite you are presenting yourself as now. I suspect, however, that you don't really care if anyone listens. You just want to spit out that bile that wells up in your mouth everytime you think of conservatives. And yes, I realize I was directing my comments rather personally just now. I admit it freely, rather than denying it. The difference between us, I suppose.
gjh
JS Maybe you can tell everyone what sactions were placed on the Clintons as a result of the Whitewater Probe. If someone tells the same false story over and over again that story become true in the minds of the listener. I can't count the number of times I hear the Whitewater Scandal as proof the Clinton were dirty. The problem is no one can come with the goods.
CosmicConservative
So gjh, what sanctions have been placed on the Bush's as the result of ANY probe. Bill Clinton was disbarred from practicing law and was impeached by Congress for lying under oath in a court of law while under investigation for sexual harassment against Paula Jones. That's what the history books say about Bill Clinton's "sanctions." And that says enough for me.
gjh
If you personally don't like the man, I can live with that, but don't lie about the past, as fact. Time will be the judge of JWB. As I have said in the past, we will be more embarrassed by JWB than everyone was of Nixon. Take a deep breath, walk around the room, relax.Just because someone disagrees with you, they don't hate you, they just disagree.
CosmicConservative
gjh: You live in an alternate reality man. I don't even know what you are trying to say. When did I ever say Clinton received sanctions for his Whitewater activities? I said it was a SCANDAL, just as the current firing of federal prosecuters is a SCANDAL. SCANDALs are not defined by WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE TRUE but by WHETHER OR NOT THE PRESS CALLS THEM A SCANDAL. Understand that? Even if we take you at face value that there was nothing to Whitewater (which explains why Susan McDougal was willing to do 18 months in jail to avoid testifying against the Clintons, doesn't it?) then that just VERIFIES MY POINT about scandals being on both sides and being overblown on both sides. It is your willingness to be outraged by unproven "scandals" of the Bush administration while accepting the most generous interpretations of the "scandals" of the Clinton administration that I am referring to. I treat both more or less equally, I think Clinton was unfairly targeted, and I think Bush has been unfairly targeted. However, the DIFFERENCE in the two is that Clinton was FAIRLY targeted for his obstruction of justice and perjury, which led to his disbarment and impeachment. When Bush has something like that on his record, we'll consider the two of them to be more or less EQUALLY corrupt, OK? Until then, Clinton wins it hands down. Whatever you are smoking man, you need to tone it down.
gjh
Why are you angry? This is a discussion man. Maybe you should be smokin' something.