Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Film Reviewers and public disagree

By CosmicConservative
Variety has an interesting story:
Variety.com - Film reviewers, moviegoers disagree Box office data this year suggests that filmgoers seem to be having a great time at the multiplexes. The critics, by contrast, may be shopping around for a new line of work. In reviewing "300" last week, for example, A.O. (Tony) Scott of the New York Times, said the movie was "as violent as 'Apocalypto' and twice as stupid." That comment reflected the consensus among critics not only on "300" but also on "Ghost Rider," "Wild Hogs," "Norbit" and the other movie miscreants unleashed on the public since Oscar time. The situation underscores yet again the disconnect between the cinematic appetites of critics vs. those of the popcorn crowd. The kids who storm their multiplexes to catch the opening of "Night at the Museum" don't give a damn what the critics think ("Museum" has passed $525 million worldwide).
There are actually a couple of clever points made in this article, mostly to the effect that movie reviewers as a fraternity clearly prefer disdain to appreciation as a foundation for writing a review. After all, when you can demonstrate your cultural superiority so well with a cleverly delivered put-down, then you can say you've spent a good day at the office. There is a movie and restaurant critic here in Denver named Reggie McDaniel. He's a lot of fun to listen to. He will review a barbecue place and tell you that the real barbecue places are the ones who give you a roll of paper towels because they know you're going to be enjoying their ribs so much that you aren't going to care if you get a little on your chin (or forehead) while eating. It may all be an act, but if so he pulls it off well. He typically loves the movies that the public loves. He calls himself your "Everyday Entertainment Guide" and he does a pretty good job of reviewing movies without putting on airs. I usually find his take on movies to be relatively accurate. He and I don't have the same tastes (he loves horror movies, especially the kind with lots of blood and gore), but his reviews are usually good guides to the actual movie itself. There's another guy here named Robert Denerstein, and he is every bit the self-congratulatory, disdainful "art critic" who will tell you that a movie such as "Night at the Museum" is a travesty after your kids had a great time watching it. He typically has four or five obscure foreign films on his "top ten" lists for each year, just to show what a cultured kind if guy he is. In general if Denerstein likes it, I won't, and if he doesn't like it, I will. So I use him as a sort of reverse barometer on movies. I think most people view most movie critics in a similar fashion. So I don't think this story really qualifies as "news."

Comments (1)

Dadman
Most movie critics (at least those attached to the major media outlets) are elitist snobs infected with the same far left pathogen that is currently epidemic in Hollywood. They tend to like movies full of what I like to refer to as The Three Ds: Darkness, Depravity and Despair. 'American Beauty' is a good example of this. There are many more. Lately, they've also been falling all over themselves to praise films with strong anti-American, anti-Bush themes.