Open the original video on YouTube
The song is perhaps the most metaphorical and cryptic of all Rock songs. The meaning of the lyrics have been debated and analyzed in bars and in elite Ivy League art classes. Don McLean refuses to reveal their meaning, saying that they represent his own personal journey through life in the previous decade, leading up to its release in 1971. The summer of my parent's divorce was the summer that this song reverberated across America. If you didn't experience it, you probably can't understand how powerful the effect was. Based on this single song Don McLean became a rock superstar with his own prime-time network TV show. And the song is 8 minutes long. Why did it resonate so deeply? Here are some clues. Obviously the "day the music died" has always been perceived, correctly I believe, as the day Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper and Ritchie Valens were killed in Iowa in an airplane crash. But to Don McLean their music represented a time when music was happy, optimistic and innocent. "I can still remember how that music used to make me smile." And Don wanted to make music like that, but the music died because the America he knew (Miss American Pie) was going away. This sense of loss of innocence and happiness from music pervades the song. It is frequently suggested that the end of the song, the verses referring to "we were all in one place, a generation lost in space" is referring to the infamous free concert at Altamont, California in 1969 where the Hells Angels ("No angel born in hell") provided the "security" and the concert dissolved into anarchy and violence (one man was stabbed to death by the Hells Angels) as the Rolling Stones performed "Sympathy for the Devil" on stage. To McClain this journey of ten years took Rock and Roll from the "rhythm and blues" he "dug" so much through the cynicism of Bob Dylan, the idealism of the Beatles, and finally to the nihilism of The Rolling Stones, ending with Mick Jagger calling himself the Devil ("And as I watched him on the stage, my hands were clinched in fists of rage, no angel born in hell, could break that Satan's spell") as murder and mayhem was occuring in an audience that was stoned or tripping out of their minds. And as that was happening, people from the audience were begging the Stones to stop the music so order could be restored, and Mick Jagger refused to do so. There are clear and cryptic cultural references throughout the song. The "King" is obviously Elvis, and the "Jester" who stole his thorny crown is Bob Dylan, which marked the transition from Rock and Roll being about sock hops and blue suede shoes, to the political activism of the "beat poet." But even that wouldn't last because even as Dylan was on the stage, the "quartet" (The Beatles) were practicing as (John) Lennon read a book on Marx and the idealist phase of Rock was about to replace they cynical jester. There's a lot more. I used to have the entire song memorized and would argue with my brothers about the meaning of the verses. It is sort of sad in a way that nobody today would understand any of the song without a middle-aged guide.Last Past Blaster: Bye Bye Miss American Pie
By CosmicConservativeThis song, more than any other, captured the feel of the 70s, a period of my life that started with my parent's painful divorce and ended with High School graduation, two years of college and learning to make my own way through life.
Comments (2)