Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Existential ruminations

By CosmicConservative
So one of the most commonly asked questions in casual philosophy is "Why are we here." To many people this becomes a religious issue. "Because God made Us." To others this becomes a science issue. "The Big Bang." Some are comfortable believing both. But the truth is that neither of those answer the question, nor does combining the two. Because neither explains a first cause. If "God made us" then what made God? Why is God here? If the Big Bang happened, what caused it? This is one reason I remain agnostic to this day. No matter how hard I try, I can't come up with any plausible reason for anything to exist. It is not possible that there was ever a time when there was "nothing" because by definion "nothing" means that there can be no cause and effect, because there is nothing to cause an effect. So "nothing" is forever. But this implies that "something" has always existed, and that violates every concept of time and causality we have been able to conceive of. So either "something" can erupt out of "nothing" or time and causality are concepts we have not begun to comprehend. Or both. To say "God has always existed" just puts a name to the "something" that has always existed, it does nothing to explain how or why God came to exist. This sort of thing keeps me awake nights.

Comments (7)

ams182764
"No matter how hard I try, I can’t come up with any plausible reason for anything to exist." Hmm. Considering that we define existence within the context of the universe, I wonder if questions about reality/existence/ect can be validly applied to the universe as a whole.
ams182764
Suppose there was a universe of flatlanders, for example, and off-plane to their universe a random sphere hovered. It never will/has interacted with their universe in any way. Does it exist within the context of the flatlander's universe if within the physics of their universe their exists no way for them to interact off-plane? Is our perspective, which is capable of viewing this sphere valid within the context of the flatlander's universe? Just randomly firing off.
ams182764
Given a set of all possible universes, is there anything to distinguish whether a given universe is less real than another within the context of that universe?
ams182764
One more brainstorm, then off to bed. A good pragmatists definition of what we mean when we say something exists or is real is that it is coupled with the universe in some way. It interacts. Things which never interact with the universe, we really have no information about and cannot know anything about, and no one spends time and energy taking them into account. (What account? Mass? Energy? Charge? Something that stores some value in the universe in some way that we don't have the physics for yet? All these things would be points of interaction with our universe). And so, if we then ask the question - does the universe exist? Is the universe real? It just collapses to asking is the universe interacting with itself. Since we define the universe to be the set of all mutually interacting things within which we are a subset, then it's just asking if the universe is equal to itself, which is an automatic yes. So any given universe at all is "real" within the context of the universe. It's just a tautology. It might not hold for a null universe in which nothing interacts at all, but that's not a relevant case. So the definition of existence is local to the universe, IMO.
CosmicConservative
I understand your points here ams, but I'm after bigger fish. If there are infinite numbers of universes, then where did any of them come from? My whole existential question is not about any single universe, or any set of infinite universes, it is questioning existence itself. Why is there anything, anywhere? The fundamental question cannot be addressed by any form of logic that I am familiar with. There are, as I said, only two options, and neither one of them can be explained by logic. #1. Something erupted out of nothing, for no reason whatsoever. Since it was "nothing" before there was "something" then there could not possibly have been a motivation for the "something" to have formed. And if there was "nothing" how could anything have triggered "something" to form? #2. Something has always existed and will always exist. Maybe this "something" is a framework for an infinite number of universes to appear and disappear for unknowable reasons, but whatever the "something" is that has always existed, the concept of "always existed" is impossible to grasp intellectually. No religion deals with this question. No branch of science is attempting to explain it. This fundamental question of why anything exists at all appears to be beyond our ability to grasp at any level. And it is hard to believe that to be due to a lack of capability on our part because you could postulate a race a thousand times as intelligent as humans, and STILL not have any way to answer this fundamental conundrum. It's all too much.
ams182764
Hmm. As far as the big bang goes, I've heard it stated that the axis we know as time curves away to normal as you approach the big bang, so in a sense there is no "before".
CosmicConservative
This is my point. There is no way to conceive of there being no "before". We can say, as Einstein did, that our specific spacetime has a beginning, and there is no "before" in OUR spacetime, but that does not explain how our specific spacetime came to exist, Big Bang or Divine Act Of Creation. Both imply SOMETHING outside of our universe from which our universe sprang. My question is "where did THAT come from?"