Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

String Theory, M-Theory and Quantum Gravity

By CosmicConservative
My ancient degree in physics (from 1984) is so out of date that I am probably not qualified any longer to hold an opinion on such arcane theories as String Theory, M-Theory and Quantum Gravity. But I will anyway. ;) I'm reading this book (The Trouble With Physics) by Lee Smolin right now. It is a borderline heretical book in the theoretical physics community, not only because it challenges the "science" of String Theory, but because it is highly critical of the community itself. Basically the book presents both of these arguments as well as Lee can manage it, and unfortunately he bounces back and forth between the arguments so much that it is hard to stay focused on either one. But I have to admit that I'm pretty much convinced that there is something wrong in physics today if even a fraction of Smolin's arguments and anecdotes are correct. Now I have been critical of String Theory myself for a long time. I have frequently said that "String Theory" is to physics as "Creation Science" is to biology. In other words, "Creation Science" is not "science" and "String Theory" is not a "theory." Not according to the long-held scientific definition of "theory." But if you say this publicly you will come under attack from String Theory zealots. Which has happened to me personally on some other blogs or message boards in which I have participated. So I know that's real. And the existence of String Theory zealots (and now M-Theory zealots) is enough to worry me. Zealotry is the antithesis of science, and when an entire branch of science is infested with zealots, it indicates to me that there is something very wrong with that branch of science. This is the same criticism I have had of climatologists on Global Warming, although I think that is a more severe example of science being infused with zealotry. The bottom line is that we have had 30 years of virtually no progress in the fundamental questions that String Theory has been attempting to solve. I can't remember a situation such as this in the past two centuries in physics. Since Maxwell, or even back to Newton and Galileo, a "theory" that could not predict new behavior and provide experimental proof that is verifiable with repeatable experiments would not last 5 years, much less 30. I think the next ten years will usher in a new revolution in Physics and I'm starting to think that it will not be String Theory that leads that revolultion. Smolin urges physicists to pursue background independent theories since General Relativity is background independent and there is no way to reconcile General Relativity with Quantum models unless we can have quantum models work in a background independent framework. Most, perhaps all, String and M theories are background dependent. I will be looking to see if anyone follows Smolin's lead. I personally think he's onto something.

Comments (4)

mtnlurker
Do you need a degree in physics to read that book?
ams182764
Hmm. I wonder how many string theorist zealots actually understand anything non-narrative about how string theory is supposed to work?
CosmicConservative
ams: I think a lot do, theres actually a strong consensus in String Theory about how things are "supposed to work" and that includes most of the typical scientific things such as calculations, theorums, models and peer review. But the problem is that all they've done so far is describe something that is "supposed to work." Some of the core assumptions about the theories have never been proved. So it's a strange situation in science where a lot of undoubtedly brilliant folks are working hard an very deep and difficult concepts, but the very foundation of those things is unproven, but is ASSUMED to be true. That's the real problem. When there is an effort to take a promising branch and demonstrate its viability, it invariably runs into these foundational problems and is abandoned after a few years as a new branch becomes the latest "thing." Keep an eye on the Large Hadron Collider, I think it's supposed to go online this year, and if it does, we will immediately be looking for a particular particle (called the "Higgs boson" I think) with a particular mass. That is the most concrete prediction String Theory has made. As I think I said though, there are other theories that provide similar predictions, so it's not a "proof" but it will be some evidence that perhaps there is some light at the end of this tunnel. If it doesn't show up, then all bets are off.