Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
Well, to climb to "favorite album of all time" this would have to get past the following: Abbey Road Sgt. Pepper Dark Side of the Moon Eagles Greatest Hits Boston's first album But it's a very, very good album. One of the best. Maybe not top ten, but up there. Top 20 maybe.... heh ;-)
Dadman
Holy crap! Are you tryin' to start something. Rumours is MY favorite album, but, personal taste aside, it's still better than all the ones you've listed... Heh...
CosmicConservative
Let's see, I'll just pick one to compare, let's say, Sgt. Pepper. OK, signature songs: Rumours - You Make Loving Fun Sgt. Pepper - A Day in the Life Other recognizable songs - Rumours: - Dreams - Go Your Own Way - Don't Stop (this is a gimme) - Second Hand News - I Don't Want to Know - Gold Dust Woman - The Chain - Never Going Back Again - You Make Loving Fun Sgt. Pepper - Sgt. Pepper (of course) - A Little Help from my Friends - Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds - When I'm 64 - Lovely Rita Meter Maid - She's Leaving Home Time at #1 Rumours - 31 weeks Sgt. Pepper - 15 weeks Grammies: Rumours - 1 Sgt. Pepper - 4 Rolling Stones ranking of top 500 albums of all time Rumours - so low I can't find it. Sgt. Pepper - #1 Total album sales Rumours - 19,000,000 + Sgt. Pepper - 30,000,000 + So the only category that Rumours beats Sgt. Pepper is in time at #1, and frankly that was due to the incredibly weak competition in that area after the well-documented death, resurrection and re-death of Rock and Roll, so that's hardly a fair comparison. I mean come on.
CosmicConservative
Next we compare Rumours to the Beach Boys "Pet Sounds."
Dadman
I checked out that Rolling Stones Top 500 albums list. Rumours is listed at 25. So low you couldn't find it, eh? On the same list Rumours is credited with 19 million sales and Sgt. Pepper with 11.7 million. Where did you come up with the 30 million figure? My guess is you're comparing Rumours domestic sales with Pepper's international sales. Not fair. If you compare apples to apples then Rumours has sold about 30 million albums worldwide - a similar number to Sgt. Pepper. Music is a personal preference. I like the Sgt. Pepper album a lot; I just like the Rumours album more...
CosmicConservative
I got the numbers from different sources so they could be different. Rumours was a huge selling album for sure, perhaps it and Sgt. Pepper are pretty close. Also, I was wrong in asserting that Rock and Roll had died, actually Rock and Roll was still alive in 1977 when Rumours came out, it was dying though... I understand about personal preferences, I was just trying to start something, as you said... I actually greatly prefer the Abbey Road album to Sgt. Pepper, and even Rubber Soul, so you can see that I don't pay that much attention to Rolling Stone, Grammy nominations or album sales myself when determining my favorites. Rumours is a great album, and is probably the best album of 1977. It won the Grammy for that anyway. ;) As far as it being number 25, the page I found last night only showed the top ten or twenty. And I got tired of looking for it.