Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Thomas Sowell on Judges on National Review Online

By CosmicConservative
Here is an article that I am almost entirely in agreement with:
Thomas Sowell on Judges on National Review Online It is understandable that liberal Democratic presidents, beginning with Franklin D. Roosevelt, loaded the Supreme Court with liberal, Democratic justices. What is far harder to understand is how a whole succession of conservative Republican presidents — Nixon, Ford, Reagan, and Bush 41 — managed to appoint so many liberals to the Supreme Court.
In the U.S. today there is no single person, including the President himself, who has the power of the nine Supreme Court Justices. The point Sowell is making here is that conservatives have abdicated their responsibility to hold the line on conservative appointments and the result has been that liberals have managed to take virtually total control of the nation's legal system through the SCOTUS. This is because liberals vigorously (and venomously) oppose any remotely conservative appointment (such as Bork or Thomas) while conservatives rubber stamp any radical liberal appointment (such as Ginsberg). I am not a "single-issue" political person, but if I were, this would be the single issue I would focus my vote on.

Comments (7)

mtnlurker
Are Bush's last two appointments steps in the right direction? I think so.
ams182764
I think attempting to appoint judges that agree with us is only treating the symptoms, not the disease: the radical imbalance of power given to the Supreme court. We've let them essentially act as a seperate legislative body, with unaccountable power - no one can veto them, and you have to move heaven and earth to remove a judge. They have lifetime terms and are appointed, rather than elected, which, in retrospect, seems to me to be a big mistake.
CosmicConservative
ams: The point between electing constructionist judges is that those judges (like Scalia and Thomas) would tend to rule for constitutional ends, instead of personal ends. And that's a very hard thing to do I would guess, since to rule constitutionally might very well mean that the individual case would be settled in a manner counter to your own wishes. I'm starting to worry that the Judicial Branch is broken and something dramatic will be required to restore balance between the courts and the other bodies of government.
Kevin in WI
All of those Republican presidents had to get judges approved by a Democrat controlled legislative branch. However, the Democratic presidents often had a sympathetic legislature. I'm not surprised things have turned out like they have.
gjh
Judges just by their nature are conservatives. They can't be anything else. It is like policemen, they have to be conservative to do their jobs. If you took all of the justices and dropped them into a room of a cross section of America they would be the most conservative of the group. I say conservative, not reactionary like I'm an reading here. There is a huge difference between conservative and reactionary.
CosmicConservative
Ruth Bader Ginsberg is to conservatism as Keanu Reeves is to acting. The only room in which Ruth Bader Ginsberg (or John Paul Stevens) would be the most conservative person would be a room with Howard Dean and Jack Murtha. And I'm not even sure about it then.