Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Murder as amusement

By Dadman
When I see stories like this I get this sick, ominous feeling in the pit of my stomach that the fabric of our society is completely unraveling...
CNN.COM - Teen 'sport killings' of homeless on the rise At least three homeless people in Kalamazoo, Michigan, reported being attacked by teens on bicycles during a 10-day span in October, according to the homeless coalition. In Huntsville, Alabama, six teens -- one of them 13 -- beat a homeless man with golf clubs, the coalition reported. But perhaps the most shocking of these examples was 2006's first recorded case of teen-on-homeless violence. On January 12 in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, a surveillance camera captured two teens beating a homeless man with bats. Prosecutors say 17-year-old skateboarder Tom Daugherty, 18-year-old Brian Hooks, a popular hockey team captain, and a third unseen teen, Billy Ammons, a high school dropout, assaulted two more homeless men that night.
I've been feeling that ominous feeling more often lately. I felt it in the aftermath of the 2000 presidential election when the orderly, peaceful transition of power seemed to melt down. I feel it when I think about the tens of thousands of illegal immigrants pouring into our country every month with no end in sight. I feel it every time a Democrat opens his or her mouth and emboldens our enemy with their irresponsible words. I feel it every time I turn on the TV and catch even a few moments of what passes for objective news. I feel it when my son tells me what goes on in his high school and what passes as 'normal' behavior these days... I think I need a vacation on a deserted island...

Comments (12)

mtnlurker
Is this a rejection of morals based on an ancient mythology that has no bearing on our current environment. Even thought I am attacking religion I am really asking a pertinent question as to what the cause may be.
mtnlurker
I really hate my fat fingers. Note misspelling of though.
CosmicConservative
I understand what Dadman is feeling and what mtnlurker is trying to say. Is the "unraveling" of society that gives Dadman that ominous feeling in his belly the result of teens saying "there is no God, so there's no real consequence to our behavior if we don't get caught doing it." Perhaps. But that would presume that teens killing homeless people with sticks is new to the world, and from what I can tell, it's not new. Teenage thugs have been around for as long as there have been humans. Is there more or less thuggery today than, say, 100 years ago? 1,000 years ago? 10,000 years ago? The problem is that there's really no way to tell. What gets reported today isn't the same as what was reported in the past. Child abductions is one glaring example. From all the hoopla surrounding child abductions in the past few decades, many people have concluded that there has been a sudden spike in child abductions, but actual study of statistics reveals that the rate of child abduction has not significantly changed in our history. It just gets reported more. Is that the case with beating up strangers with sticks? I suspect it is.
ams182764
I think this is just what humans are, pre-civilized. 1000 and 10,000 years ago, one tribe would murder the next wholesale to take their wealth, the villiage priest would sacrifice someone he didn't like to the sun god and the whole villiage would celebrate his death. People would take out their rage on slaves, whipping boys, and scapegoats. People are not naturally kind, fair, charitable, or benign. They are pack hunters. Tribal, territorial animals. Civilization made them a way that we take completely for granted. They are taught to be that way.
mtnlurker
So, the question boils down to, Is man basically good or basically evil?
JSullins
No, it boils down to this: *I* am basically good. The rest may or may not be basically evil. :D Sorry, feeling a little wacky today. It's been one of those weeks so far.
ams182764
I think people are basically animals. Imperfect men have taught other imperfect men how to be civilized over a long and iterative process. I wouldn't say we are especially more evil than any other part of nature, but if a pack of young healthy dogs comes up on an old, weak, sick dog, charity isn't their most likely response.
Dadman
I'll try to resist getting into a religious debate. Let me just say that just about anything humans 'believe in' can be categorized as mythology - not just religion. And mtnlurker's assertion that religious principles have 'no bearing on our current environment' is just absurd. I don't know what books you are reading to learn about religious-based principles, but the books I read teach me about love, charity, patience, selflessness, service, altruism, humility, honor, integrity, innocence, etc. You're right, mtnlurker, none of these principles would have any bearing on teens beating homeless people to death... But, I wasn't really thinking about religion, or the lack thereof, when I made made my posting. I was thinking more along the lines of what seems to be a serious erosion of civility - both social and political - all around us and how it worries me. Perhaps it's just a perception, and not actually true, for the reasons Cosmic mentioned. But I think in this case the perception is true. I think America is becoming a little more dysfunctional all the time for a myriad of reasons. I hope I'm wrong...
CosmicConservative
Perhaps America has been an anomalous society for 200 years and is now just returning to human norms of behavior. Which, of course, would be grounds for serious disappointment. I'm just not sure. When I look at political debate I agree that it is less civil than it was 20 years ago, but not by much. I was a fan of Ronald Reagan when Ronald Reagan was the favorite target of liberals. There is not much that is said about GW Bush today (idiot, puppet, incapable of speech, incapable of thought, etc.) that was not said just as viciously about RR. I particularly remember Garry Trudeau's Doonesbury's book "In Search of Reagan's Brain" which takes a rather obvious perspective on one of our greatest Presidents. If you go back further, all the way to our founding fathers, two of our most powerful political figures, including the sitting vice president at the time, squared off in a duel over political campaign claims on each side. One, Alexander Hamilton, was killed by the other, Aaron Burr. It's hard to get more politically divisive than that. So I'm not sure that it's actually "worse now than ever." It seems to go in cycles.
ams182764
I'm not saying that it's going any particular direction. I'm just trying to point out just how artificial and fragile civilization can be. The difference between a Palistinian insurgent jumping up and down at one of those rallys, celebrating his kid brother blowing up an Israeli schoolbus, and a Californian medical researcher devoting his life to developing an artificial eye to cure blindness has almost everything to do with how we are raised. The culture that develops around such people has everything to do with what their parents taught them about right and wrong, and what is important.
Dadman
So the question may be are we doing an adequate job of teaching the current generation the difference between right and wrong? Are we doing a better or equal job of it today than we did in the past? I don't think we are. I think we spend too much time arguing over what actually is right and what actually is wrong. The line between the two seems to be getting fuzzier with each passing year...
mtnlurker
There seems to be not thought of reprisal in these teens. There is also no empathy for their victims. I understand it is easy to dehumanize other groups of people that are not like you. And they seem to care little for human life. I see a number of issues that could be factors in this behavior.