Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

We're doomed! Doomed I say!

By CosmicConservative
Now this is the kind of doomsday threat I can get behind! Forget that pantywaisted Global Warming stuff, nothing beats a good asteroid impact for pure bone-chilling panic.
U.N. urged to take action on asteroid threat - CNN.com SAN FRANCISCO, California (Reuters) -- An asteroid may come uncomfortably close to Earth in 2036 and the United Nations should assume responsibility for a space mission to deflect it, a group of astronauts, engineers and scientists said on Saturday. Astronomers are monitoring an asteroid named Apophis, which has a 1 in 45,000 chance of striking Earth on April 13, 2036.
Wait, did I read that right? The U.N. is going to save us? We're doomed! Doomed I say! Update: Oh, and what's this nonsense about "deflecting it?" Heck, let's lasso that puppy!!!

Comments (8)

ams182764
How? The UN can't manage a mercy mission to Africa. How are we supposed to believe they can handle a rocket, even supposing they could procure one capable of reaching this asteroid without a massive pan-Euro-Russian embezzling festival, while the US pays the bill?
ams182764
"The favored approach to dealing with a potentially deadly space rock is to dispatch a spacecraft that would use gravity to alter the asteroid's course so it no longer threatens Earth, said astronaut Ed Lu, a veteran of the international space station. The so-called Gravity Tractor could maintain a position near the threatening asteroid, exerting a gentle tug that, over time, would deflect the asteroid. " This is preposterous. It's one of these ridiculous limp-wristed "alternative" ideas that I did calculations for before. No spacecraft that we could possibly put up would have mass capable of effecting the trajectory of a 1000+ ton rock in geologically significant timescales. I don't know why people are so opposed to using a nuclear device. Just detonate a nuke with a gas cylinder behind it to provide the necessary impulse. Or just h-bomb it until the whole thing evaporates.
CosmicConservative
The number of ways to deflect asteroids is limited only by our imagination. The gravity tug is feasible, but only if you are very, very certain of your orbital calculations and you use the gravity tug when the asteroid is several million miles away. Other feasible options are: 1. Attach a solar sail. 2. Paint one side with reflective aluminum. 3. fire lead slugs at it from a linear accelerator. 4. Detonate nuke (the problem with this one is that you might just end up with a lot of small asteroids that are impossible to manage and still on a collision course.) 5. Focus a high-intensity laser on its leading edge. Etc. etc. The reason people are glomming onto the gravity tug idea is that it is the only one that doesn't require touching the asteroid and has virtually no chance of shattering one giant asteroid into a bunch of big ones.
ams182764
Right, but you'd have to know the position of the asteroid several (perhaps several HUNDRED for some of these schemes) orbits beforehand to produce sufficient deflection. I suppose if you had a NERVA engine and sufficient propellant, you could land on the side and boost it out of the way if you could get there within half an orbit of impact. However, this gravity tug would still use propellant while depending on an absurdly weak force to pull the asteroid. It would be more efficient just to land on the side and physically push. If you're within an orbit of impact, just start launching nukes. If the first one doesn't get it, the next few will. And the binding energy of any rock cloud should be sufficiently small to deflect most of the mass on a trajectory that would miss. After all, these sub-asteroids would all be reacting against each other via the gas cloud from the nuke device.
CosmicConservative
I mostly concur, although I like the elegance of just painting it silver and letting the sun push it out into a larger orbit. There's a surprising amount of energy in sunlight and over time it adds up.
ams182764
1000 W/m^2 at Earth radii from the Sun would add to something like 6E-6 N/m^2 of force against a normal perfectly reflecting surface. Remebember, these asteroids are supposed to be fairly massive to be dangerous to life on Earth. If you had a 1000kg (nevermind 1000 ton rock) and needed to make, oh, say a 2m/sec dV to elevate the orbit to miss Earth, you would need to wait 9 years before it happens. There's a lot that can happen to an orbit in 9 years just from the planetary gravitational perturbations alone. I suppose it's fine if you have that sort of warning. But I suspect if there were an asteroid projected to impact in 2 years, it would take the UN 9 years to draft a resolution that pays off every interested party to consider an action sometime in the future!
ams182764
Oh wait. Flawed assumption on the surface area. I used 1m^2 surface area. The actual normal surface area (assuming sphere, 1000kg/m^3 density) would be something like 1.28m^2.
CosmicConservative
I think it's perfectly reasonable to have a few decades warning, we do in this case, in which case the "paint it silver" approach seems to be a pretty good contender in the "save the world" sweepstakes. But if we see one incoming that we didn't spot until it was only a few million miles away because it is coming directly at us the whole time, then yeah, roll out the nukes.