Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Lies, damn lies and statistics

By CosmicConservative
Check out this story...
New York Daily News - Home - NYPD frisked blacks at 5 times rate of whites The NYPD conducted more than 500,000 stop-and-frisks last year, with blacks five times more likely to be searched than whites, according to statistics released yesterday. Blacks accounted for 52% of the 508,540 individuals stopped and checked last year, according to data released by the City Council's Public Safety Committee. That percentage has changed little in nearly a decade - it was 50% in 2000 and 52% in 1998. But the total number of frisks soared from the 97,296 conducted in 2002. Among the top reasons cops gave for stopping an individual were that the suspect was in a high crime area or had made "furtive movements," according to the statistics. Hispanics accounted for 29% of the searches last year and whites 10%, the data showed.
OK, so if I'm reading this properly the bottom line of the story is that the individuals New York City police are stopping and frisking are black 50% of the time and white 10% of the time, with hispanics making up most of the remaining 30%. Here is a quote from the FAQ page of the New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board, which is a civilian oversight group that keeps an eye on the New York Police.
In 2005, the race of victims whose allegations the CCRB substantiated were as follows: 12% white, 57% black, 20% Latino, 3% Asian, and 8% "other." In comparison, the New York City population is 35% white, 25% black, 27% Latino, 10% Asian, and 4% "other." At the same time, 62% of police officers who had complaints substantiated against them were white, 12% black, 24% Latino, and 2% Asian. This is consistent with the overall demographics of the NYPD in 2005, which was 58% white, 16% black, 23% Latino, and 3% Asian.
In other words, when complaints were lodged against the police, the rate at which blacks and whites were exonerated by the CCRB were virtually identical, which is what you would expect if there were a random distribution of abuse cases in arrests. On the other hand, if there were some systematic effort to target blacks instead of whites, you would expect the rate of blacks being exonerated would greatly outstrip that of whites, which does not seem to be the case. So the question that has to be answered is this. At what rate are crimes committed in New York City by different races? If blacks commit 5 times as many crimes as white people do, then it would be appropriate for black people to be arrested, detained and convicted five times as often. So, how do we find out what the rate of crime is? You can't use arrest statistics because if there is a systematic effort to unfairly target blacks, then the arrest rate would not match the crime rate. Is it possible to determine the crime rate based on race? I dunno. I'm looking for ideas.

Comments (4)

CosmicConservative
Yeah, and why would unreported crimes be skewed in one direction or another? A common sense approach would suggest that unreported crimes are probably distributed across the spectrum the same way as reported ones. Is there some reason you suspect otherwise?
Rick Larson
Just pointing out the figures of how much crime is more than reported. And in second thought, here in Milwaukee anyway, blacks are "hanging out" in public on a much greater scale than other races, hence more frisking.