Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Blasphemy Challenge

By CosmicConservative
The atheists are on the move:
The Blasphemy Challenge The Rational Response Squad is giving away 1001 DVDs of The God Who Wasn't There, the hit documentary that the Los Angeles Times calls "provocative -- to put it mildly." There's only one catch: We want your soul.
What do you think about this? Hat tip to mtnlurker.

Comments (14)

mtnlurker
I saw this on Fox News and the anchor was livid. He was yelling at the guest. And I thought the guest was calm, cool and collected. You should check out the interview on foxnews.com.
CosmicConservative
How's that Dadman? I think this is legitimate debate material. I'm really wondering what people think about this sort of thing. Do you think this is legitimate behavior? Or should it be stopped? I actually fell right into the same old trap with the "playing into Satan's hands" comment. I shouldn't have been that flippant, but as mtnlurker pointed out on another thread, I've been a little offbeat the last few days for some reason. I have heard religious people for years accuse atheists of having a "religion of atheism." Well, this guy is putting that to the test. He really is treating it like a religion. Religions proselytize, so is he. Religions have rituals, he is too. Religions have spiritual tests. He's creating one. So I guess what I'm really wondering is what people think about atheism actually starting to act like a religion. What does that mean?
Dadman
I was aware of this prior to your post and I basically have no issue with it. Atheists have the freedom to profess their 'faith' or lack thereof, and deny the Holy Ghost or any other ghost they so desire. I do think that their effort is essentially an in-your-face mockery of religious faith, but that's just my perspective. I'm sure these noble atheists think the actions of Christian evangelists are rather in-your-face too... To each his own... I'll be away for a while...by the way...
CosmicConservative
I don't think it's always a mockery. I think there are some people who truly believe that religion is dangerous and they actively want to "save" people from it. In that way I see them as more or less the same as religious people who want to "save" people from the sin of non-belief. I personally don't care for either side trying to convince me that they know ultimate truth.
Dadman
If they are atheists, then dragging the Holy Ghost into it plays no purpose, except to mock those who believe in the Holy Ghost. If they are Satanists (which I don't think is the case) then maybe it's just a case of them choosing sides. But I think any reasonable, rationale person can perceive the mockery component to this YouTube stunt. I'm surprised you don't perceive it in this specific case...
CosmicConservative
I'm not saying this stunt doesn't involve mockery, I'm saying that there is a defensible case to be made that religion has done so much harm to the world that people should be saved from it. The "dragging the Holy Ghost" into it reads to me more of a "put your soul where your mouth is" stunt directed at those who will make the pledge than a mockery of religion. It's a way of metaphorically burning your spiritual bridges. But then I'm not religious so I'm not as sensitive to the mockery as others might be. Although I see it clearly enough in Piss Christ and Dung Madonna and other works of "art."
Dadman
They're atheists. They don't believe in scripture. They don't believe in the Holy Ghost. They don't believe in a human soul. They don't believe in hell. They don't believe in damnation or the notion of blasphemy. Why, then, are these things central to their 'challenge'? You may see a clever metaphor; I see blatant mockery. Otherwise, they would simply state their belief that there is no God and religion is evil - in a rational, reasonable way. Of course, that approach would never receive the same level of attention that their 'Blasphemy Challenge' has. And attention is something they are certainly seeking...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I'm sorry you feel that way. It isn't true. At least I don't think so. In fact mtnlurker warned me not to post the link because it might cause some friction and I thought otherwise. Looks like he was right. I'll try one more time to explain why I don't think it is necessarily blatant mockery. If someone claims to be an atheist because they want to get attention, or think it's "cool" or just want to be contrary, when asked to directly blaspheme God, they might well think better of it. So this "pledge" could be a way of saying "if you have any latent Christian beliefs, then this is where you either shed them or turn back." That could be why it's central to their challenge, or at least one reason why. But you may be right, maybe it is blatant mockery. I just think there's more to it than that, even if mockery is part of it. By the way, atheists don't necessarily disblelieve in a human soul, they by definition disbelieve in an all-powerful deity. Existence of a soul is another issue.
Drax
I remember in law school, I had a friend from India. He was, if I recall correctly, a psych major pre-law. When we were "in our cups," and the conversation turned to religion, if anyone professed to be an athiest, it wouldn't be long before he would launch into some really VILE remarks about Jesus. He seemed to get a kick out of the visceral reaction which many were elicited from many of the so-called athiests. I guess this is the reason for the "test." There are few raised in America who are willing to say out loud that they believe that Jesus was either insane or a con man (both legitimate conclusions if he was not the son of god, which, of course, he couldn't be if there wasn't one...) The Christian faith (in its most basic form) is instilled very deeply into us at a very early age...
Dadman
Books are published nearly every day making the case that Jesus was insane or a clever con man...or that he didn't exist at all. Many of them are bestsellers. I think the notion is gaining much more credibility all over America...and the world.
CosmicConservative
I have heard people say that there are only three options for Jesus. 1. He was truly the son of God. 2. He was a con man trying to profit from the Messiah prophecy. 3. He was insane. I think there is a fourth possibility. That is that he was a sane, decent, human being who saw a way to do something that he truly believed would make the world a better place. He knew that adopting the role of Messiah would allow for the spread of what he conceived of as a superior religion that would improve people's lives, and he sacrificed himself to make that world possible. I prefer to think of him in terms of option 4 than 2 or 3, and I appear to be incapable of accepting him as option 1. Of course all of this assumes that there was an actual historical person named Jesus, which is another point of contention in the debate...
Dadman
I try to go with option 1 as best I can, but it is a clearly a matter of faith and hope, not certain knowledge.