Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Was 9/11 really that bad? - Los Angeles Times

By CosmicConservative
Was 9/11 really that bad? - Los Angeles Times An interesting editorial from David Bell. Its only problem is that it assumes as a foundational point that the Iraq war was a response to 9/11. There may be societal rationale for that argument but in point of fact 9/11 was never used as a reason to go to war in Iraq by anyone in the Bush administration. The official reasons, and the reasons voted on in the Congressional Record are that Hussein had violated international law, unleashed unprovoked attacks on the U.S. military, ignored several binding U.N. Resolutions it had agreed to as part of the settlement to end the first Iraq war, and was believed to be actively developing WMD including nuclear WMDs. Other than this fundamental error in the cause of the war in Iraq, the article is not bad.

Comments (6)

mtnlurker
So, are you saying we need to wait until 20 million people are dead before we can react? I think recognizing the desire and preventing the capability to annihilate us is preferred.
CosmicConservative
Don't confuse my saying the editorial is worth reading with saying I agree with it. The salient point he is making is that as bad as 9/11 was, can we really say it was the start of World War IV? Islamic fascism is an existential threat to Israel, but is it truly an existential threat to the United States? Was it sufficient to declare a global war? I think those are valid questions that are worthy of debate. I've said from day one that the arguments against war in Iraq are understandable and defensible.
Rick Larson
The bombing of Afghanistan was a proper response to 9/11. The war in Iraq is a failed attempt to grab their oil resources, and to intimidate any other country interested in trading oil in Euros.
CosmicConservative
Rick: I guess you must believe that, you repeat it enough times. You never answered my question last time, so I'm sure you won't answer it again. If the war was to steal their oil, why didn't we evil Republicans use their oil to reduce oil prices and ensure a victory at the polls last November? I guess we just forgot, huh?
Rick Larson
I did answer. How can they ship oil if the pipelines are constantly being sabotaged? Come on, the United States would jeopardize it's world standing, it's currency valuation, and the blood of it's children to merely rid Iraq of terrorists and WMD? Why not the terrorists and WMD in a non-oil producing countries?
CosmicConservative
Rick: I can see that logic and reason are ineffective in debate with you and I choose not to use emotion and insults, so we'll just have to let you continue with this belief of yours that the United States chose to go to war with Iraq to get their oil, but somehow neglected to protect the oil fields and pipelines, instead concentrating their forces in the urban areas and terrorist rich zones with no oil for some unfathomable reason. If that's what you want to believe, and you enjoy believing that your own government is evil, knock yourself out. It's not worth the effort to try to dissuade you of your paranoia.