Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Black Caucus: Whites Not Allowed

By Dadman
I don't understand why we put up with this. It's blatantly racist, yet everyone turns a blind eye to this kind of reverse racism. Why? When I see stories like this I like to engage in the mental game of replacing all 'black' or 'African-American' references with 'white' and vice versa just to see how it reads. For example: White Caucus: Blacks Not Allowed Pretty outrageous, huh? And yet the Black Caucus of our nation's Congress does it with impunity. I just don't get it. Haven't we as a nation moved beyond blatant race-based politics? Alright, that was a stupid question. I know the answer and it's a shame...

Comments (13)

mtnlurker
I don't think a White Caucus is outrageous. If it is good for the goose, it is good for the gander. I don't view myself as racist. I do my best to ignore color in my relations with other people.
Rick Larson
Outrageous yes, but just like there are Packer fans and Bear fans, there will be blacks and whites. And right now blacks are better at exploiting than whites.
Dadman
I believe any kind of race-based caucus that actively discriminates against others due to their race is outrageous. I can't support it in any way, shape, or form...
CosmicConservative
I think there's not a whole lot of difference between this "black caucus" issue and affirmative action, which is essentially favoring one race over another according to legislative and judicial fiat. Still, I don't think racial equality has been met yet. My concern is whether it can be met when such racial gameplaying is done because such things simply give fodder to racists to claim "reverse discrimination" and in the long run may be propogating racism more than they are ending it.
Dadman
The question of racial equality aside, this Congressional Black Caucus is actively discriminating against white congressmen who have large black constituencies in their districts and want to be part of the caucus to help them be better representatives. They are being denied entree' simply because they are white. This tells me that with the Black Caucus race trumps all. In my book, that makes them clear racists (and clear hypocrites) and I don't think it should be tolerated.
Dadman
Contrast the actions of this Black Caucus to President Bush lauding the accomplishments of Dikembe Mutombo and the good samaritan from New York. Try to imagine the Black Caucus, or any modern black leader, extending the same courtesy to anyone with white skin. I can't imagine it. Reverse racism is very real and I believe those that practice it should be called out at every opportunity.
CosmicConservative
As in so many things, I am conflicted. I am constitutionally opposed to reverse discrimination, both in the sense that I believe it violates the actual U.S. Constitution, and in that it offends my OWN constitution when I encounter it. But, I acknowledge that racism is still a powerful force in this country. I am in the deep south as I type this and I have seen the houses flying the Confederate Flag and I know, as surely as any black person knows, that they are flying that flag for any abstract "states rights" reasons, they are sending a message to their peers and to those they seek to oppress. I absolutely believe that it is harder for a black person to be successful in this country than for a white person to be. I once worked at a bank in the south. I worked with a black guy named Ray. Ray was doubly discriminated against because of the wideheld perception that he was gay. I like to think that he and I were friendly, and when we worked together he and I treated each other as complete equals. But when I graduated college I was immediately offered a job as a "manager trainee" by the bank president, and Ray was not. Ray not only already had his BA degree, he was working on his Masters. This is one of the reasons I left that bank. I am absolutely certain that bank discriminated against blacks and gays. And I benefitted from it, for the short time that I stayed there after realizing the situation. If I had the slightest desire to have stayed there, I know that I would have advanced up the bank management ladder well above him, although he and I were, in my opinion, roughly equal in intelligence and ability. And I would say he was my superior in wit and personality. He should have gotten the job offer I got. So as I say, I'm conflicted.
Dadman
And certainly those who practice white on black racism should be called out as well. I'm merely trying to say that two clear wrongs don't make a right. At some point we have to acknowledge that what the Black Caucus is doing is just not right (e.g. denying membership to white Congressional members who have a clear need to understand and engage black issues). Above, you are making a case for affirmative action. In my mind, it's a different issue. Affirmative action may indeed be, for the reasons you articlulate, justifiable. I'm a child of the South too; I've seen how it can be...
Ed Minchau
"a blind eye to this kind of reverse racism" There is no such thing as "reverse" racism. No matter who is practicing it, it is just plain old racism. As for affirmative action, that is actually doubly racist. First, it assumes that white people should be held to a higher standard than others; secondly it assumes that black people would fail if held to the same standards as others. And, I'm pretty sure that it isn't what MLK was thinking when he was talking about his children being judged on the quality of their character rather than the color of their skin.
Dadman
I agree, Ed. But there is another side to the argument for the reasons Cosmic mentions. That said, my view of it is really more in line with your view...
qwerty182764
Affirmative action does more damage than that. When minorities make it through a college course and into a carreer, anymore there is an underlying assumption that they must have gotten through a difficult course of study on the grade inflation and low admissions standards given to them on account of their race. If they get hired as part of a mandatory racial quota, there is an assumption that they couldn't have gotten in on their own otherwise. Just part of playing ball with Uncle Sam. Mandatory racial quotas are hurting minorities more than helping, IMO.
gjh
Who was denied membership in the Caucus? I haven't read anything about it. I'd like to tune into this fight if I knew the right station.
Dadman
gjh: The article I linked to references Tennessee representative Stephen I. Cohen and respresentative Pete Stark of California, both Democrats and both white. This kind of thing doesn't happen very often because most white members of Congress know the unwritten rule that white folks are not welcome in the Caucus...much like black people understood they weren't welcome in the front of the bus... Thank goodness for Rosa Parks. Too bad Mr. Cohen wasn't able to overcome black racism in our own Congress. Maybe next time...