Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why scientists should stay out of politics

By CosmicConservative
Because they look like damn fools when they try to play that game.
Scientists prepare to move Doomsday Clock forward | Top News | Reuters.com WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The keepers of the "Doomsday Clock" plan to move its hands forward next Wednesday to reflect what they call worsening nuclear and climate threats to the world. The symbolic clock, maintained by the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, currently is set at seven minutes to midnight, with midnight marking global catastrophe. The group did not say in which direction the hands would move. But in a news release previewing an event next Wednesday, they said the change was based on "worsening nuclear, climate threats" to the world.
If this "doomsday clock" had any credibility whatsoever it wouldn't keep flipping back and forth all the time. Apparently it's never been further than 17 minutes away from midnight for over fifty years. This sort of political grandstanding by "scientists" was at its worst during the 1980s when people like Carl Sagan completely destroyed their scientific credibility by putting the weight of their scientific reputation behind ridiculous political efforts such as U.S. unilateral disarmament. This is just more of the same ridiculous nonsense. Why this makes the news is a mystery to me.

Comments (12)

qwerty182764
Doom prophecy is the world's oldest profession. Nations are swayed, governments overthrown, witches burned, entire ethnicities cleansed because manipulative men can't keep from grandstanding before receptive and fearful crowds.
Rick Larson
I wouldn't call it ridiculous nonsense. Whether it being credible, or not, this doomsday clock does have a certain appeal as news and gives thought towards what may be the perception of the scientific community. All but the most isolated does have knowledge of past catastrophic events - including which have occurred during our lives - and this clock feeds into these happenings. Using the clock for political reasons is fair game.
CosmicConservative
Rick: I call it "ridiculous nonsense" for two reasons. One: It is ridiculous. As in "completely devoid of wisdom or good sense". There is nothing about it that provides any value whatsoever. Other than theatrical value. Two: It is nonsense. As in "a matter of little or no importance or usefulness." It has been predicting imminent doom for over 50 years. That alone demonstrates how ridiculous it is. According to the "Doomsday clock" we are perpetually on the brink of doomsday. It doesn't "make sense" that we can be perpetually on the brink of doomsday, and yet survive. There is absolutely no doubt that the world is much farther from imminent nuclear destruction today than in 1962 when Cuba was a flashpoint and both the USSR and the USA were poised to use their nuclear weapons. At that time the Doomsday clock was no closer than 3 minutes to doomsday. Today it is at seven minutes and according to this article, will be moved up, so let's say to 6 minutes. Do you believe we are only twice as far from doomsday today than in 1962? I stand by everything I said. This is pure political grandstanding by "scientists" who have political axes to grind. There is nothing "scientific" about it and as such has just as much scientific credibility as if the Psychic Hotline network published a similar clock.
Rick Larson
Ha! Never expected you to cave in easily! Do surf like mad and came acrossed this website a few days ago. Surely it had some influence to my response, but since a man induced catastrophic event is possible at any time, will stand by my statement that it is not nonsense. These ideas are political fair game just as any conservitive issue. And are we twice as far? Here I would agree they are out of kilter, we may be 2ce as close! http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=newsHighlights&newsId=34
Rick Larson
Never expected you to give in easily! Ha! This issue is just as fair game as any conservative issue and whether it gains traction with the voters, or not, some will always agree, and some may think it ridiculous nonsense. Do surf alot and came across this website: http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=newsHighlights&newsId=34 These guys might be out of kilter a bit as we might be 2ce as close.
CosmicConservative
I guess this line from the page you referenced pretty much says all I need to know: "the dangerous, belligerent U.S. administration" Yep, pure objective carefully researched science there, no doubt! Let's ignore the fact that the Bush administration's nuclear policies are virtually indistinguishable from the Clinton or previous administrations. Unless of course by "dangerous, belligerent U.S. administration" they refer to ALL U.S. administrations since George Washington violated the spanking new constitution to quell the Whiskey Rebellion. Or perhaps it only goes back to the belligerent "Monroe Doctrine" which threatened war against any power who "meddled" in the Western Hemisphere, regardless of whether the U.S. owned the affected land or not. Remember, this site is subtitled "Rational Conservatism" which means we like to deal in facts, not fantasy. The fact is that thirty years ago we quite literally had thousands of nuclear weapons pointed out our major cities by the Soviet Union, with codes typed up and ready to hand out to technicians who would launch them on command. During the Cuban Missile Crisis not only did we have missiles pointed at each other, we also had airborne bombers flying all over the world with active nuclear weapons waiting for the order to drop them. Today neither of those situations exist. To me that is pretty compelling proof that we are much, much further away from nuclear annihilatlion than we were then. I think your link demonstrates exactly the sort of political grandstanding I was talking about. It certainly did not help your position, except perhaps with those who believe it is a "fact" that the Bush administration is run by evil warmongering madmen.
CosmicConservative
Oh, I missed this quote from your link.
Is the Bush Administration Planning a Nuclear Holocaust? - by Michel Chossudovsky - 2006-02-22 Will the US launch "Mini-nukes" against Iran in Retaliation for Tehran's "Non-compliance"?
Yep, real solid Nature Journal-level science on that site man... real convincing stuff. And what's the freshness date on those articles anyway? That one is almost a year old now.
Rick Larson
Don't confuse my ideas with those of this link. I simply refer you to the fact that others are going to use these ideas for political purposes regardless of what you or I think or believe. This is why it is called politics (of course you already know this!). On the flip side, what good are nuclear weapons but to use them? My opinion is Bush will - as he has already admitted nuclear is an option.
CosmicConservative
It seems in retrospect that nuclear weapons turned the forty-five years from 1945 - 1990 into a period where the world's most powerful nations were afraid to fight a global war of the type they fought twice in the previous thirty-five years, quite possibly saving the lives of a hundred million people. I think that's good, don't you? Do you think if we did not have nuclear missiles pointed at each other that perhaps NATO and the USSR might have had a "hot" war instead of a "cold" one in Europe? Most historians seem to think so. Mutually Assured Destruction actually turned out to be a remarkably successful geopolitical strategy. Of course that's only because both nations (three if you count China) were run by rational people who didn't want to die. All bets are off if that condition changes in the future. Do you realize that Bill Clinton repeatedly left nuclear weapons as an option during his reign as President? Do you realize that every single President since Harry Truman has overtly and officially stated that the U.S. reserves the right to use nuclear weapons? Do you realize that it is the official policy of the Pentagon and has been communicated to the U.N. and to every country in the world that the U.S. reserves the right to use nuclear weapons? Why would you even suggest that this is unique to GW Bush? Do you simply not know this to be the case?
Rick Larson
Do you know that the US is the only nation to have used nuclear weapons in war? And to argue that past Presidents made this same statement, while, quite obviously, not following through and actually using nuclear weapons, mean the GW is not going to use them? You make the case on why the terrorists are not more threatening to our society, as GW believes, than any other enemy in the past.
CosmicConservative
Rick: He's been Prez for six years and hasn't used them yet. Basic probability odds are on my side in saying he's not likely to use them in the next two years either. Will he use them against Iranian nuclear bunkers? And if he does will they be clean tactical shaped-charge nukes? And if so, are those the same "nukes" that you are referring to? Other than having "nuclear" in their name they bear less resemblence to a Hiroshima bomb than the Hiroshima bomb resembled fire-bombing Dresden. I try not to get caught up in the rhetoric and try to evaluate the actual actions and consequences. Would I support a surgical strike with a clean tactical nuke with a shaped charge to pierce a nuclear bunker in Iran? Maybe.