Update: Heh... after writing this review I went to Amazon.com to see what other readers thought. Apparently this is the most beloved children's book since Charlotte's Web. The primary "negatives" that are brought up is that it is too intense for kids or that there is a strong thread of secular humanism in the book. Heck, I read "Catcher In The Rye" when I was a kid, and that book didn't bother me for the reasons mentioned here. I seem to be the only one who finds problems with the actual writing. Sigh, and I want to be a writer.....
Book Review: Bridge to Terabithia
By CosmicConservativeI try to read all the books my kids read. I can't claim to have been 100% successful at that, but I'm pretty close. So because my son was reading "Bridge to Terabithia" by Katherine Paterson, and because it is a short book (most kids novels seem to be in the 150 or so pages range), I picked it up and read it. (I'm a pretty fast reader, a book like that is really not much of a time impact on my evening).
It's a story of a boy (Jess) and his relationship over a school year with a girl (Leslie) who moves into the house next door. They both live in a rural area outside of Washington D.C. I can't really review this without spoilers, so if you are wanting to read it, and don't want to know how it ends, you better stop right now.
-------------------
Still here?
Good.
OK, Jess and Leslie become fast friends in part because both have social issues at school. They meet during summer recess but they don't form a friendship until school starts. The story covers most of the typical adolescent angst, including a crush Jess has on his music teacher. The "Terabithia" in the title is an imaginary land they make up so they can pretend to be like the kids in "Narnia." They devise as part of the mystique of Terabithia the rule that they can only enter the kingdom by swinging on a rope hanging over a creek. Leslie is the child of two writers and so is precociously literate, which endears her to their schoolteacher. Jess is part of a poor farming family and he pretty much disdains school. His only real passion is drawing, an activity that he hides from everyone but Leslie and the music teacher.
Over the course of the year Jess and Leslie develop an increasingly close (but never significantly romantic, after all they are about ten years old) relationship and deal with a number of personal and social problems, including a conflict with the school's main bully (a girl in this story).
The "Bridge" in the title is a reference to the terrible tragedy that occurs near the end of the story. One day in the early spring, when the creek is flowing very high and fast, Jess is beginning to fear the rope-swing entry into Terabithia, and when his music teacher asks him to accompany her to the art museum in D.C., he eagerly accepts the trip, both because he doesn't really want to swing into Terabithia that day, and because he has the crush on the teacher. He leaves without making sure his family knows where he has gone because he feared that if he was explicit, they might not let him go. After a magical day (the chapter is titled "The Perfect Day"), he returns home to discover that his family had thought him drowned in the creek because Leslie had attempted to go to Terabithia and the rope had broken, sending her into the frigid, swollen waters of the creek. Her body had been found, but they thought his had perhaps been swept downstream.
The rest of the book (a few chapters) is about Jess attempting to deal with the devastating loss.
OK, so how good is it?
The writing is good, after all it won a Newbery Award, I think. But the author shows a casual disdain for rural life that disturbed me. The natural superiority of Leslie when compared to not just Jess, but any of the kids in the town, was downright insulting at times. The townspeople are depicted as dirt poor backwoods hicks. Other than Jess and Leslie the other characters are one-dimensional and stereotypical. Even Jess's parents and sisters are like shadows hovering in the background of the story, with the single exception of Jess's younger sister May Bell.
I was frankly surprised that the story won such a prestigious award, but perhaps modern editors find such depictions of rural folk to be accurate. Having grown up in a similar community (we even had a huge rope hanging from a tree in our yard that we swung on) I found the entire setting objectionable and condescending.
The final chapters where Jess tries to come to terms with Leslie's death are surprisingly anti-climactic and left me feeling unresolved. Perhaps it was by design, but the whole last bit felt rushed, forced and choppy. I never felt that Jess had actually come to terms with anything. At the very end he builds a bridge where the rope had been so that his young sister May Bell could enter Terabithia safely. But even this felt odd and unrealistic since Leslie had been the driving force for all of Terabithia's magic. I was left feeling that Jess would come over the bridge with his similarly doltish country-hick sister and try to force the magic that had flowed so naturally and easily from the suave, sophisticated Leslie, and his frustration from trying to recreate Leslie's magic would end up with him in therapy (well, probably not since he could't afford it), or lead him to a bad end.
I would have greatly preferred if the "lesson" he learned from Leslie was that everyone has their own magic to bring to the world, and he found his own (through his drawing perhaps) or he helped bring out the unique magic of May Bell in her own way, not Leslie's way. That would have been a lesson worth learning. Instead it felt like he was caught in the past trying to force his own world into the mold that had been Leslie's world, well beyond her own death.
So overall I thought the book was actually a pretty poor read. Again I'm not sure how it got such a major award. But then, I'm just a dumb country hick myself and probably miss the real message which is that Jess is following Leslie's magic and it will one day free him from the crushing despair of rural life outside of Washington D.C.
I dunno. If any of you have read it, let me know what you think.
Comments (3)