Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Intelligent Design

By CosmicConservative
A couple of folks have asked me to put up some indication of my perspective on "Intelligent Design." I will try to put a few words down, but this really should probably be covered in much more detail because my opinion is somewhat complex. Basically I am not a proponent of the concept. It strikes me as faith-based, untestable and lacking in imagination. It also strikes me as anthropomorphic, which is always a warning bell to me. The fundamental premise of "Intelligent Design" seems to be that nothing as complex as the universe could have "just happened." Therefore it had to have been created. The immediate rational and logical rebuttal to that is that a creator of the universe would presumably have to be more complex than the universe itself, so that creator would also have to have a creator by the same logic that says the universe has to have been created, and this immediately degenerates into the logical fallacy that I think of as "turtles all the way down." From a rational, logical perspective therefore, "Intelligent Design" offers nothing new, except as a dodge against charges of religious bias. And that brings me to my second major problem with "Intelligent Design." You can easily track the history of the concept and it is clearly a ruse to get around attempts to remove Creationism from public schools. Or to put it another way, it is philosophically dishonest and disingenuous. And everybody knows it. My third major problem with "Intelligent Design" is that word "Intelligent." I can't even begin to describe the problems I have with this universe if it had, in fact, been "designed." Let's start with ticks. Ugh. Why create such disgusting beasts? Better yet, let's look at tooth decay. Creating bacteria that have no function except to destroy teeth goes beyond the ridiculous and into the downright nasty. It is fun to say that God must have a sense of humor, but when you consider things like tooth decay and ebola, it appears that God has a nasty streak. And I don't like contemplating a God with such a nasty streak. However, having said all that, there is really no intellectual or philosophical conflict between Intelligent Design and conventional cosmology, so long as you have some scale to employ. It is clear that here on Earth Intelligent Design has been going on for some time. Maize, for example, is clearly a designed grain. Dogs are designed. A wide variety of domesticated plants and animals have clearly been designed. In this case the "Intelligent Designer" is the human race, but there is no reason to stop there. It is quite conceivable that human beings themselves are the result of "Intelligent Design." All it takes to support such a theory is to find evidence that aliens have been interfering in earth evolution for thousands, millions or even billions of years. There are any number of books that take this premise that intelligent space-faring races modify and direct the evolution of life on other planets (my favorite are the David Brin "Uplift War" series). But such a possibility does not require divine intervention, all it requires is a "progenitor" race that evolved naturally and which has been "designing" life forms ever since. But that's not what the proponents of "Intellient Design" are talking about, at least not in general, and not in the lawsuits that have been brought forward on the subject. What they are talking about is the Christian concept of an omnipotent, omniscient God who designed everything. And in that sense I remain as skeptical today as I have always been. Perhaps I'll expand on this at a later date. But it's late and I've got to get to bed.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.