Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A "Free Speech" victory

By CosmicConservative
Georgia rules Potter can stay on school shelves - CNN.com ATLANTA, Georgia (Reuters) -- Harry Potter fans in Gwinnett County, Georgia, can breathe a sigh of relief. The Georgia department of education Thursday upheld a decision by the county board that would allow the wildly popular series by British author J.K. Rowling to remain in school libraries, Gwinnett school system spokesman Jorge Quintana said. In October 2005, Laura Mallory, a mother with children at Gwinnett elementary schools, asked a local committee to ban the books about a young wizard, saying they were violent and promoted witchcraft.
I have never understood this bizarre behavior of people who want to ban certain books, especially Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter, the first is one of the best books ever written, actually THE best according to multiple critic "best of" votes over the years, the second one is the most popular children's book in my lifetime, and anything that gets kids to read 400 page books has got to be a good thing. Especially when these same kids are probably watching and reading much worse on a regular basis.

Comments (5)

Drax
It is impossible to understand the minds of such people. They believe in witchcraft. That should be a pretty big clue that they are not entirely sane.
qwerty182764
From what I can tell, debating various internet nuts, these guys think that the world and everything in it is some sort of spiritual trap or test to overcome. They seem to believe that God is a ruthless tyrant (despite their protests to the contrary) who actually hates everything that he (paradoxically) created and is willing to send it all to hell, and if the believers don't keep their eyes on the ball, they'll go right along with everything else at the end of the world. (Thank you Jonathan Edwards...) If you believe such things, then the world is a dangerous temptation, and any sort of wonder it inspires, or even just mindless frivolity or fun is a mortal threat to your soul. Especially if the fun involves things you can dredge up disapproving Biblical passages for, such as sorcery and witchcraft. These people don't care if we are reasonable, or if they are paranoid. They'd rather not take any chances with infinite stakes.
CosmicConservative
I used to have regular debates with fundamentalist Christians. I've sort of stopped because it's usually more productive to argue with a lump of coal. But when I did, I used to ask them how they were going to be "eternally happy" in heaven knowing that their mother/father/son/husband/wife/daughter/best friend was suffering eternally in hell for the single "crime" of not believing Jesus was the path to eternal salvation. I would ask them things like, "Okay, I can see how you might be caught up in the wonderment of heaven for, say, a couple million years, but eventually you might wonder "Gee, how's ol Dave doing? Is he really still in hell, suffering eternal torture and pain?" And then, say a few billion years into eternity, don't they think they would go to God and say "Um.. God ol' buddy, I'm just sort of wondering if you might reconsider Dave's case. After all, Dave was a good guy, a wonderful person who never did any harm to anybody, but he just couldn't buy the Jesus thing. I'm pretty sure after a few billion years of hell, he's reconsidered his position on that. Don't you think maybe you could ease up on him a bit? I mean after all, you've got OJ Simpson up here for converting on his death bed and all...." I used to blow their minds when I would say, "If you are right about the universe, then there is no evil act a human being could do that would justify eternal damnation. It simply isn't possible to do that much evil in a single human lifetime. Now maybe you could argue that Hitler, for example, deserves a few million years of torture, but eventually he'll have paid even his debt to the universe, don't you think?" One of the reasons I left religion behind is because I eventually concluded that for most people God and Santa Claus were exchangable concepts. God is sort of the uberClaus. He sees you when you're sleeping, he knows when you're awake, he knows when you've been bad or good, so be good for goodness sake! Except Santa gives you a few lumps of coal, and God tortures your eternal soul for, well, for eternity. I've run sort of off the track here. Sorry about that. As far as people who want to ban books because they have witchcraft stories in them, I simply point out that the Bible has witchcraft stories in it. So by that logic, they should ban the Bible. This is one of the (many) areas that the Bible presents a view of the world that is internally inconsistent. The best example of this is when the Pharoah's wizards create snakes from their staffs to attack Moses. The Bible does not say that the wizards pulled sleight of hand, no it says they turned their staves into snakes. So it must be true. But such powers are also said by the Bible to be only God's powers. So how did the Pharoah's wizards manage to create snakes from staves? Did God do it for them, just for dramatic effect? As allegory this story makes perfect sense. Moses was demonstrating that HIS God was more powerful than the Pharoah's God. The snake battle is a substitute for the Gods battling each other. Moses' snake wins, which demonstrates the superiority of HIS God. But as literal truth doesn't this also prove the existence of the Pharoah's Gods? Where else did the Pharoah's wizards get their power?
CosmicConservative
Oh, by the way, I believe it was Aaron's staff that was changed into a snake, not Moses. A little detail they left out of the movie I think. It was much more dramatic to have Moses do the staff to snake spell. And that's the way it has entered the collective cultural consciousness now. But in the actual story, I think it was Aaron's staff.