Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why most people are wrong about evolution...

By CosmicConservative
Including most scientist types I've talked to. Evolution is generally described as a slow, laborious process that takes many millions of years for the tiniest of changes. In fact evolution is so commonly viewed as slow and incremental that the word has come to mean slow changes as you can hear for yourself the next time someone says "we need revolutionary change, not evolutionary." There are some in the biological community who say that change can be dramatic though, but even now they are not the mainstream. The general reason for the resistance to the idea of radical change is the argument that too many genes would have to change for something truly radical to happen. But this is demonstrably untrue, as can be seen by any number of mutations that you hear about all the time. Two-headed snakes, dolphins with four fins, a baby born with three arms, a kitten with one eye... these are not common, but they happen. "But, those aren't genetic mutations, they are somatic ones." This is the usual argument. But if something happens in the womb, and an arm bud on a fetus splits into two, and each then grows to become a new arm, who is to say that a genetic mutation could not cause the same thing? In fact there is evidence that it does. Scientific American ran a story a few years ago about a dramatic evolutionary change in a type of mollusc, the change was so dramatic that it changed the entire internal organ structure of the mollusc, and changed the mollusc from a floor-dwelling to a free-swimming species. The entire change seemed to boil down to a single gene that controlled an internal bladder that was small and filled with fluid in the pre-existing species, but was large and filled with gas in the "new" species. This change essentially pushed around all the internal organs during development, and the result of the change was that the mollusc could control its buoyancy. Or at least that's what the article argued. To me this means that dramatic "revolutionary" change is possible from genetic mutations, because the growth of an embryo into a living thing is, almost by definition, an organic event. Cells react to hormones and seek nutrients and connections they are programmed to seek. A third arm grows not because the genes of the mutated organism "know" how to build a third arm, it grows because something messes up the normal process of creating a single arm, and the cells that are displaced still "think" they are supposed to grow an arm. So they start differentiating into bone, nerve and muscle. The nearby blood vessel cells "know" they are supposed to deliver nutrients to growing tissue, so they reach out to the third arm and create arteries, veins and capillaries. Nerve cells do the same thing. It all comes together as a third arm, or additional flippers, or whatever the cells were "programmed" to do. If a genetic change doesn't affect that process, but changes something fundamental about the architecture (lets say it changes the orientation of one finger from parallel with other fingers to an opposite location on the palm, for instance) the rest of the tissue adapts. And presto, opposable thumbs are born. And if they help the organism to survive, they are passed on. That's how I think it works. That's how major changes are made, such as paws becoming flippers, or vice versa. Things that make tremendous difference in the organism's life, but are tiny little genetic changes that really only affect a basic architectural thing, but the rest of the tissue adapts to the change and new behaviors are born along with the new physical attribute.

Comments (8)

qwerty182764
I suppose it's possible for dramatic change to manifest, but usually the more dramatic a change is, the harder time the organism has adapting to it's circumstances. There's supposed to be some small segment of the genetic code that controls a lot of our body segmentation (how many sets of appendages we're supposed to have, ect). Changes to this region are usually supposed to be fatal due to the dramatic alterations in the resource demands placed on the developing organism. If you ended up with two midsections and tried to grow two hearts, your circulatory system would fail. But it's true, and fortunate, that life is extremely self-organizing, and very failure tolerant for this reason. Everything references it's own immediate circumstances, rather than an overall master plan, and thus can adapt to circumstances where the "plan" isn't happening. Blood vessels will grow to organs regardless of whether they are in the right place or not. Skin will grow to cover everything that isn't covered, regardless of whether or not it's supposed to be there. It's really amazing how well things adapt. Likewise, all life, regardless of the circumstances it finds itself in, will attempt to live the best it can. Mutated or not, in the right environment or not, following "the plan" or not, if it can live it will live. That too leads to incredible resilience and innovation. No matter where life finds itself, it will always orient and head towards success.
qwerty182764
PS. I think for future AI related work, or robotics, we would do well to figure out ways to copy these architectures and abilities. For what it's worth (my problem was extremely simple compared to most biological fitness situations), one of the genetic algorithms I've programmed did seem to exhibit punctuated equilibrium on a certain timescale. (I was too lazy to program a more specific search algorithm). The algorithm was solving a problem with quite a few parameters, so the design space was huge, and there are many possible vectors by which a solution could leave a critical point. When the solution approached one critical point, it would wander around in the vicinity for a while, before suddenly heading off for a better one. It continued until I decided the "fitness error" was small enough that I could stop the algorithm.
qwerty182764
An additional point: The punctuated equilibrium exhibited by my GA wasn't due to the fact that small parameter changes lead to significant differences in the solution. I suppose that can happen with biological organisms and DNA, but there is one additional reason for this behavior: When you are around a critical point (a local maximum along certain axes in design space), small changes in your solution will lead to only small ambiguous changes in your relative fitness. But when a solution begins transit between critical points, changes along specific lines can lead to larger and more clearly directional changes in relative fitness, even if the changes to the physical "solution" are relatively small. One day, flying squirrels may well develop full flying ability for this reason. Once they get going along a path towards the ability to fly, small increments in their developing wings can lead to large changes in their relative fitness, which will drive relatively fast change.
qwerty182764
Speaking of which, on a more political note: For all of the left's insistence on their own deep understanding of science, since they seem to have tripped into the right side of the evolution/creationism debate, and for all of their insistence that the right are a bunch of anti-ideological neanderthals because, unfortunately, some of us are on the wrong side of the debate; they seem to have some pretty mythological ideas about evolution themselves. For example, I don't know how many times I've seen the idea of a "next step in evolution" floated. Or that society or humanity is supposed to become "more evolved" and suddenly begin living in socialist peaceful harmony. Or the number of assumed attributes of said "more evolved" creatures, which always fall out along some line of primitivists who somehow manage to understand the "secrets of the universe" without bothering with "dirty technology" and are fit to pass judgement on the rest of mankind. Well, primitivism is optional, but the rest seems nearly a constant meme that I've seen repeated nearly [i]everywhere[/i]. For moral relatavists describing a directionless utilitarian process of life independently moving towards more successful patterns of living; they sure can come up with some extremely moralistic, teleological visions that evolution is supposed to somehow implement. (Replace this fixed image of "highly evolved" people with "ubermensch", and you begin to see some pretty creepy parralels).
qwerty182764
Dare I mention ESP and magical powers? Those are invariably attributes of the new ubermensch. Crystal healing? Sorry about the quintuple post
qwerty182764
anti-ideological "anti-ideological " - Correction - anti-intellectual
qwerty182764
PPPPPS. I've always wondered: Is there some sort of blog holiday on Sundays or something? I've noticed most people tend to stop posting on blogs and discussion forums around that time.
CosmicConservative
heh, blog holiday? For me it's church, family and the NFL. The combination of which usually wipes out my Sundays. Even on days like today where every team I rooted for lost. And most lost big. I think you and I are not disagreeing about the "punctuated evolution" so much as debating the scale of changes. I tend to think that small architectural changes can have dramatic physical consequences, so much so that from a casual observation that one architectural difference can lead to a new form that appears totally different than previous forms. Some examples, scales developing into feathers; orientation of major skeletal structures; more or fewer appendages (particularly evident in arthropods) and finally larger brains. All of these could be fairly minor architectural things controlled by one or a few genes, but the end result is dramatic.