Here's an interview everyone should read.
FrontPage magazine.com :: Religion of Peace? by Jamie Glazov
It was only in the West that religious power developed in parallel with secular power but distinct from it thanks largely to the doctrinal distinction in Christianity between giving 'to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God's what is God's.' While religious and secular power have certainly commingled at times in the West, it is fully possible for the two to coexist separately. But in Islam, there has never been a distinction between religion and political power; the two are inseparably united. An Islamic society is invariably a theocracy ruled by Sharia (Islamic) law, which is understood as God's prescribed legal code for all mankind, based on the commandments of the Koran and the precedents set by Muhammad.
One of the most compelling quotes from the story is this:
The facile way in which politicians, commentators, and academics dismiss Islam as a 'religion of peace' indicated to us that there was more that needed to be said on the topic. The Muslim terrorists claim to be doing the will of Allah, while Western leaders insist that Islam is peaceful. The obvious question was: who is right? There is no a priori justification to assume that peaceful Muslims represent authentic Islam while violent Muslims do not.
The premise here is one I've heard from other sources and goes something like this:
"If Islamic fundamentalists go about routinely telling the world that their religion demands that all other religions be subservient, and all humanity should be held to sharia law, why do we simply assume that they are misrepresenting their religion? Don't they know their own religion better than we do?"
The quick and common answer from "reasonable moderates" to this sort of claim is "well, isn't that more or less exactly how the Catholic Church imposed its own will on Europe for centuries? How is it any different with Islam? Sure there are radical elements, but this radical fundamentalist boil in Islam will be lanced soon enough and we'll all be able to sit at the table together."
I'm one of those who can see both sides of this argument. I know many Muslim individuals and I have to say that in general I have been very impressed with them, both in terms of their personal integrity and their general ability to get along with other cultures. Since my own direct experience with Muslims has been almost universally positive, I tend towards the "this is the Islamic version of the Spanish Inquisition" side of the argument and I too think it will pass when certain economic and cultural conditions are rectified by the inexorable march of history.
But as I said, I can see both sides. What do you think?
Comments (19)