My take on Alito's rulings as described below:
• A 1991 challenge to a Pennsylvania law requiring married women to notify their husbands before seeking an abortion. The court struck down the restriction. Alito dissented.
This is the case where Alito tried to figure out O'Connor's "nuanced" position on abortion and privacy, but O'Connor ruled in the opposite direction, so all this case tells me is that O'Connor's position on these issues is more than "nuanced" it is "incoherent." I can't really glean Alito's abortion position based on this, although I would call it "encouraging."
• A 1995 challenge to a Pennsylvania law that required women seeking to use Medicaid funds to abort a pregnancy resulting from rape or incest to report the incident to law enforcement officials and identify the offender. Alito provided the decisive vote striking down the abortion restriction.
This appears to be a case of conflicting constitutional issues. To make this a single-issue abortion question appears to be unfair to me, there are also issues of privacy rights, accessibility and potential personal safety to deal with. Since Roe V. Wade was the law of the land at the time, it is completely reasonable to me that Alito did not rule on "abortion" but on fairness and safety. Although I would put this in the category of "concerning."
• A 1997 challenge to a New Jersey law that prevents parents from suing for damages on behalf of the wrongful death of a fetus. Alito ruled that the Constitution does not afford protection to the unborn.
This is quite literally a proper legal decision assuming Roe V. Wade is the law of the land. If fetuses were afforded Constitutional protection then you couldn't abort them. With Roe V. Wade being the law, it is hard to see how Alito could rule on the legal merits of the case and conclude that fetuses are afforded such protections when they are aborted at a rate of more than a million a year. This is one though that you could argue Alito demonstrates perhaps a too-literal legal perspective and SHOULD have allowed his own moral compass some leeway. But it doesn't do much to determine how he would rule in the SCOTUS his decision would MAKE the law instead of interpreting existing law. I would put this in the category of "troubling."
• A 2000 challenge to New Jersey's ban on so-called partial-birth abortions. Alito struck down the law based on a recent Supreme Court decision.
This sounds very similar to the one above, also "troubling."
Basically my take is that Alito takes his job very seriously and interprets the law as best he can using the SCOTUS rulings as his guide. As I have said before, that doesn't say much about how he will rule as a SCOTUS justice, although it does show me that he is probably more willing than unwilling to follow existing precedent, which might not be good news for single-issue abortion opponents.
I still like him though. He sounds like he is intellectually consistent and very diligent about his job as it is written, which means to me that he will almost certainly follow the guidelines of judicial restraint and will be an interpretive justice as opposed to a legislative one. Of course I am not a single-issue abortion person, I am just as concerned with issues like how the Commerce Clause is interpreted, personal privacy rights, Second Amendment issues, Due Process, etc...
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.