"Political dissension is doubtless a less evil than the lethargy of despotism: but still it is a great evil, and it would be as worthy the efforts of the patriot as of the philosopher, to exclude it's influence if possible, from social life. The good are rare enough at best. There is no reason to subdivide them by artificial lines. But whether we shall ever be able so far to perfect the principles of society as that political opinions shall, in it's intercourse, be as inoffensive as those of philosophy, mechanics, or any other, may well be doubted." Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Pinckney, 29 May 1797Or to put it another way, dissent is only patriotic where it is responsible and civil. So the usual misquotation of Jefferson is pure contrariness. Here is what patriotism is to me: "I want my country to be the best country it can possibly be. I want to respect and honor the good things my country has done, and I want to acknowledge and rectify the bad things my country has done." Patriotism is not about flags, bumper stickers or carrying protest signs. It's about living your life in such a way that you advance the goals of making your country the best it can be. Patriotism is as much about responsibility as it is about pride. Spiderman's Uncle Ben had it right when he said "With great power comes great responsibility." Patriotism means standing up and being counted when your country is on the wrong track. But it also means defending your country's honor when it has been unfairly attacked. It's about honoring and respecting the laws and traditions of your country even while you are working to rectify bad laws or change bad traditions. It means respecting the views of your fellow countrymen, not "even when you disagree with them" but "ESPECIALLY when you disagree with them". It means honoring the service of those who have answered their country's call to duty, whether that duty is carrying a gun, carrying a bandage, carrying a victim from a burning building or carrying a bill up the capital steps to try to convert it into a law. It means representing your country when you are outside of your country, or when you are interacting with citizens of other countries. It means recognizing and advancing your country's best interests in the global community. I don't have flags flying at my house, except for one small flag that we have in our living room. I don't have "patriotic" bumper stickers or other patriotic paraphernalia. I don't wear my patriotism on my sleeve, I try to wear it in my heart. I love this country more than I love anything else outside of my family. I have deep and abiding respect for the ideals put forth by our founding fathers, ideals that they themselves did not live up to, but recognized as natural law. I love that this country was founded on a faith in the fundamental goodness and common sense of individuals. I acknowledge with great regret the things that have been done in the name of this country that were evil or ill-advised. But I also honor the things that have been done that have advanced or defended the concepts of personal liberty. I do not have a blind eye to the past or the future, I see great good and great evil in what has been done in the name of government "of the people, for the people and by the people." But by far I believe the good has outweighed the bad. I honor the great individuals our country has produced, from George Washington and Thomas Jefferson to Ronald Reagan. I can look at the lives of those men and see the contradictions they lived, and still admire the soaring of their spirit even while they were mired in the muck of their lives. Those ideals lived on and rectified even many of the evils they themselves were unable to see or change in their lives. I admire our military men and women. I am proud to know that we have the greatest military power the world has ever known, and that we have tried to manage that military might responsibly. I recognize that there are differing opinions on how well we have managed that might, but overall I am convinced that there are few countries that would have managed such power so responsibly. My type of patriotism doesn't ignore warts or scars, but it is the type of patriotism that can see the beauty through the warts and scars. And some of the beauty is even in some of the scars. I can simultaneously feel shame for our heritage of enslaving an entire race, and feel admiration for having fought one of the bloodiest wars in human history to end that enslavement. I've spent too much time on this already. Perhaps more to come later. But if not, I'll just end by saying, my patriotism is not a simple thing, it is a complex set of emotions that encompass as much of our history and culture as I have knowledge of. But in the end, I am proud of America, and I am proud to be an American. That's my kind of patriotism.
On Patriotism
By CosmicConservativeWhat is patriotism?
The two extreme bumper-sticker slogans I've heard from right and left go like this:
Right: "My country right or wrong!"
Left: "Dissent is the highest form of patriotism."
The first one is simply jingoism.
The second one there is usually attributed, erroneously, to Thomas Jefferson. What Jefferson actually said about dissent is the following:
Comments (10)