Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jury Duty over again

By CosmicConservative
We have a "One Call or One Day per year" policy for jury duty, meaning that I have to go sit in court for at least one day per year, but no more, unless I get put on an actual jury. If I don't get called onto a trial, I am off the list until next year. So far I have spent one day in court every year, and only once had to actually go through the selection process, where I was the last one released before the trial began. Today the defendent plea-bargained his case at the last minute and we were released after about three hours of sitting and waiting. I have mixed emotions. Nobody likes to be inconvenienced by a jury trial, but I do think plea-bargaining is abused in this country and I can't help but think justice is not being served by so many plea-bargained cases.

Comments (5)

Drax
"Justice" is a much over-used word when viewing the legal sausage making process. Without plea bargaining, the courts would be bogged down beyond all redemption. In fact, one of the few bargaining chips defendants have is "I'll take it to trial." We NEVER know if someone is "guilty," even after the verdict. We generally think that we have a pretty good idea, but certainty is almost always elusive. In ANY trial, there is the possibility that the innocent will be found guilty, and the guilty freed. Pleas prevent this "injustice" from happening, allowing the defendant to decide his level of risk and the State to have closure on a case without an inordinate expenditure of funds. (For example, I tried a simple assault case for two weeks, shutting down that courtroom for two weeks over what was essentially a couple hundred dollar fine. But, my client was innocent (although found guilty by the moron of a judge--overturned on appeal--and a sizeable settlement against the city on the civil case) and wanted his day in court. Trials are dangerous animals. Pleas are certain. Trials are lengthy. Pleas are quick. There really isn't a good argument to reduce the number of plea bargains other than those which are made in bad faith, which isn't an argument against plea bargains as much as they are an argument against prosecutors who don't perform their duties as they should.
CosmicConservative
SIgh, if I had wanted a reasoned and thoughtful analysis of plea-bargaining, I would have posted one myself. ;) You make good points, I guess I have to defer to an actual attorney, but I still can't help but think some criminals "beat the rap" through plea bargaining by taking advantage of a court system that is overwhelmed with frivolous lawsuits and drug cases.
Drax
Heh. I'm always amused by the "frivolous lawsuit" argument. You want to know what a frivolous lawsuit is? It's one that, after appeal to the highest authority, is DETERMINED to be frivolous. What do I mean by this? Well... Let's take, say, Brown vs. School Board of Topeka Kansas. Wouldn't you say that this case, one which was not only CLEARLY decided earlier by the Supremes, was absolutely contrary to the existing legislation, and was contrary to the "popular" sentiment at the time....would DEFINE "frivolous?" I mean...how much more clear could the law on the subject BE? Yet...the Supremes turned the law on its head. The same argument could be made as to any case which attacks Roe v. Wade. In fact, when it comes to almost any area of law, there is generally a FIRST case which bucks the current legal thinking, and BECOMES the current legal thinking. (Think Miranda, think Biven v. 6 Unidentified Agents of the FBI, cases such as this which break new ground.) If the lawyer thinks the law is WRONG, then he should fight for his client, regardless of whether or not someone else thinks the lawsuit is "frivolous" or not. It is how the law is CHANGED...or reinforced, depending on what the JUDGES say...not what the LAWYERS say. So...blame the judges for not slapping down "frivolous" lawsuits, but understand that, on appeal, the judges may have egg on their face when the higher court not only determines that the case was not "frivolous" but warranted changing the law.
CosmicConservative
OK, I'll tell you what I mean by frivolous lawsuits. I mean lawsuits that are designed to be settled out of court because they are easier to pay than to fight. I work for a large Fortune 500 corporation and I can tell you that I have been in meetings where the discussion centered around settling the lawsuit not because we were in the wrong, but because is cost us too much money to prove we were right. I argued against this on principle every time, but usually lost that argument based on pure economics. If I have been in that many meetings myself, then I have to assume this is rampant in the courts today. I suppose you could argue that because these are usually settled out of court, they don't clog the courts, but I think they still pull resources off of other things, including resources that could otherwise be in court settling a real case.
Drax
Ah. Now, we're not talking about frivolous lawsuits, but legal blackmail (Jesse Jackson has made a dang good living doing just that...) I will admit that there are tons (and tons) of cases presented (although not generally filed) which attempt to extort money from someone on a "bean-counting" premise, i.e., that it is more economical to settle a case (no matter the merits) than it is to defend against it (the ubiquituous "cost of defense" case). The only way to stop these kinds of cases is for the sued to stand up to the lawyers. Unfortunately, the cost of doing so is probably prohibitive. For example, a while back Allstate had a policy of not settling any case where a chiropracter was the source of determining the medical "damages." They would go so far as hiring a "bio-mechanical engineer" to testify to dispute damages. They took a horrendous beating at the trial level and ended up not only paying out more than they would have had they settled the case, but were forced to pay their lawyers and experts tons of cash as well. It's difficult to sort out the "frivolous" from the legitimate, since there are very few wrongs for which there isn't SOME legal remedy or, at least, doesn't have the color of a legitimate lawsuit.