Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Black holes and the information paradox

By CosmicConservative
So I've mentioned a few times here that I don't "believe in" black holes as currently described in modern cosmology. I've hinted at my reasons, which include the fundamental problem with determining "where" a particle is according to Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle, and my problem with the "loss of information" in a black hole, which is usually described as the "information paradox." For these reasons I've debated the concept of a "singularity". Here is an interesting analysis of the same issues: The way the information paradox is "resolved" is to create a scenario where objects exist in two places at once, and not at the quantum level, but at the macro-cosmic level. In principle this means that entire galaxies could have two copies of themselves, one inside and one outside a relativistic boundary such as a black hole's event horizon. Am I convinced? I'll need to ponder it. At least this proposal addresses one of my core problems with black hole theory so far, so I have to respect that at least. Man, physics is weird.

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative » The Trouble With Physics
[...] This made me feel good because that’s what I’ve been saying for twenty years, as I said in the post “Black Holes and the Information Paradox” a few months ago. So since he called my own perspective on this “wise” I’m inclined to think he is brilliant. [...]