Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Reading fiction enhances empathy

By CosmicConservative
This study is pretty interesting.
The more fiction a person reads, the more empathy they have and the better they perform on tests of social understanding and awareness. By contrast, reading more non-fiction, fact-based books shows the opposite association. That’s according to Raymond Mar and colleagues who say their finding could have implications for educating children and adults about understanding others.
Heh, there so many ways to go with this. I could go snarky and say, "OK, so reading about make-believe people and make-believe situations makes people better at dealing with real-world people and real-world situations?" Does this mean that people who watch fiction movies are more empathetic than people who watch documentaries and nature shows? Or is the effect constrained to flipping actual pages? So, if I read "Huckleberry Finn" and then follow that up with "A Brief History of Time" does that mean the effects cancel each other out? So does the reading of "fiction" include fantasy, sci-fi or romantic novel genres? I'd like to know more about this.... I mean does reading Tom Clancy have a different effect than reading Gore Vidal?

Comments (6)

Drax
Is it a "chicken or the egg" situation? Are those who tend to read fiction RATHER than non-fiction more empathic to begin with, and those who read non-fiction RATHER than fiction more analytical? I can see how fiction, which frequently more engages the imagination rather than the mind would be more attractive to the more "caring" among us, while non-fiction the more "intellectual." Nothing, however, precludes one from reading both, and taking the best of both worlds, eh?
CosmicConservative
I think the truth is that people who score well on empathy tests can just remember the names of the authors of the books they've read, while people like me just remember the stories.
qwerty182764
I'd like to think of myself as intellectual, but I haven't read all that many non-fiction books lately. Of the nonfiction, it's mostly soft stuff - historical/political stuff. I do read a lot of fiction. (I'm not going to count the time I attempted to work through the opening chapter of a quantum physics book - PS, it seems there's an endless supply of people out there claiming quantum physics as the justification for crank-devices, perpetual motion machines, crystal pyramids, rank solipsism, and "Lit-crit-correct physics"). I wonder what proportion of the QP geniuses quoting paradoxes even know what problem initially gave rise to the field?)
CosmicConservative
Qwerty: Hmm. that sounds like a challenge. There were several more or less concurrent physics problems/paradoxes that came to light right at the turn of the 20th century. You could plausibly argue that any of them could have "given rise to the field." One of them, at least, was the short-frequency black-body radiation problem, sometimes called the "Ultraviolet paradox" or the "Ultraviolet catastrophe." Another was the photoelectric effect for which Einstein's work led to his Nobel prize. Another was the scattering phenomena of x-rays fired at gold foil by, I think, Neils Bohr. If I put my mind (or Google) to it, I'm sure I could come up with half a dozen more examples in a short time. Maybe you have something else entirely in mind. Please share it with me, as a one-time "physicist" (that's my degree anyway) I'd like to know what you think gave rise to the field. There are many who suppose that perpetual motion can be found in the quantum foam somewhere. In fact you could argue that it is found there since the frequency of electron "orbits" appears to be eternal. Although I suppose you could argue that it is not since at some time billions of billions of years from now, even the protons will decay. But that's getting pretty picky. Quantum physics is, in my opinion, a science of nearly pure observation at the moment. There are few, if any, theoretical frameworks that predict quantum mechanical behavior. There are mathematical frameworks that describe the phenomena we detect, and do it so well that Quantum Theory has been called the most successful theory in the history of science, but nobody yet has proposed a widely accepted theory of WHY quanta exist. Because of this relative blank slate that we have to describe our universe's fundamental foundation, I think there are likely incredible discoveries to be made yet in that field, some of which could plausibly be considered "crank devices" to our current understanding of the universe. A hundred years ago, when Einstein proposed that you could extract energy from matter at the ratios predicted by E=m*c*c people said HE was a crank. Such olympian energies were thought to be reserved to the gods. In fact that's what Oppenheimer said when the trinity test proved successful. "I am become death, the destroyer of worlds." I'm a born skeptic, but there is something deeply weird about the universe. So weird that I believe we have just begun to scratch the surface of what we can accomplish by harnessing that weirdness.
qwerty182764
"One of them, at least, was the short-frequency black-body radiation problem, sometimes called the “Ultraviolet paradox” or the “Ultraviolet catastrophe.”" Well, that was the one in the opening chapter of the book, so it was the one I thought of as the "original" problem. (Wasn't thinking of it as a challenge to you or anything). "We'll begi with a brief overview of classical electrodynamics, thermodynamics, and a brief derivation of the Rayleigh-Jeans curve for blackbody radiation" BAM. Dynamic coupled field equations 1. Needless to say, it's not the sort of thing one can read casually like an ordinary book. :-P
CosmicConservative
Heh. I hear you. What's bad is that I used to understand that stuff. Heck, I could even do the math! Not any more.