Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

House Intel Chair suspends staff member - Yahoo! News

By CosmicConservative
So, a potential source for a classified info leak.
House Intel Chair suspends staff member - Yahoo! News In a letter obtained by The Associated Press Thursday night, Rep. Ray LaHood (news, bio, voting record), R-Ill., a committee member, said that an unidentified staffer requested the document from National Intelligence Director John Negroponte three days before the Sept. 23 story about its conclusions.
I don't think I need to tell anyone what I think should happen here if they can prove this "staffer" did in fact provide the documents to the NY Times. I don't think anyone doubts what I think should happen to the NY Times editors either.

Comments (41)

fred
It's a good ploy, suspending somebody without evidence because "coincidence, in this town, is rare". Sure, if someone broke the law then they should be prosecuted. But since this was not information about troop movements, tactics or covert operations I'm not outraged by it at all. On the contrary, I think the NIE conclusions on global terror trends are something we need to know sooner rather than later. If the NIE conclusions were leaked for political purposes prior to the midterms, then keeping it quiet until after the elections would have been just as politically motivated. So in this case I commend whoever took the legal risk to leak the information. If they end up in jail I just hope they saw that as a possible conseqquence from the start.
CosmicConservative
So you commend lawbreakers because they advance your political ideology. At least you admit it. What was that you said about the Beauprez campaign again?
fred
In this case I do commend the lawbreaker. I don't know: what was it I said about the Beauprez campaign?
CosmicConservative
Something about how they should be investigated if they did something illegal. But you ended by saying you trust the court system to work it out, so I guess you do the same here.
fred
That's right. Breaking the law may sometimes be the right thing to do. But it's still breaking the law. You don't need to tell us what you think should happen to the leaker and publisher in the NIE case. But I'm not clear what you think should happen to the leaker and the "publisher" in the Beauprez case.
CosmicConservative
I make a distinction between national security espionage and local law enforcment espionage. But, if they broke the law, they should do the time. It is clear to me that publishing national security secrets is against the law. It is not clear to me that publishing information from an FBI arrest database is against the law. Perhaps your superior research skills can find the relevant statute to clarify that for me.
Drax
1. Leaking the information was against the law, doing so for political purposes was dispicable. 2. Keeping the information "secret" until after the election may simply be a case of keeping the information "secret" because it needed to remain "secret." (Even that which was subsequently released to counter the parsed portion which was purposely leaked was highly redacted.) This constant refrain from the left that every action by anyone in the Bush administration which does not agree with their viewpoint has some base motivation grows old. ("They must have kept the information secret until after the elections because releasing it before the elections would have harmed them.")
fred
No, you do it. You need the practice. :) I'm glad you see the need to make distictions. Moral absolutism doesn't work.
CosmicConservative
The distinctions I am making are not arbitrary ones, but ones that are relevent to the severity of the crime. As far as I know there is no crime in publishing the FBI database info, although there is a fine for accessing it for anything other than official use. I think the fine is $5,000 but I'm not sure. The NIE leak that you are so pleased with was not merely a politically motivated one, it was a dishonest one. Bush declassified the entire summary so people could see that the context of the original leak was specifically chosen to cast the worst light on a report that was, at worst, a mixed bag analysis with as much good to say as bad. It is generally accepted that telling only partial truths to convey an incorrect message is morally equivalent to a lie. This is, in fact, precisely what the Left accuses Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld of doing. And yet you are perfectly fine with it when it gores your particular ox. At least I condemn such acts no matter who does them. Your "Moral absolutism doesn't work" comment reminds me of comments like "generalizations are always wrong." So fred, when do you think rape is justified?
fred
I prefer the entire report to be released, or at least those parts which are not a legitimate security concern. You, however, are on record as preferring not to know the contents of the report. Rape is justified only if you live in the old testament promised land.
CosmicConservative
fred: You have, once again, completely ignored the questions I've asked and resorted to making up things about my own motivations to obscure your unwillingness to answer them. I am not "on record" saying I prefer not to kow the contents of the report. I am "on record" saying that if the report is classified, then revealing the report is a crime. I personally would be quite happy to obtain total omniscience because I am sure I would know how to handle ultimate knowledge. You, on the other hand, I do not trust with it. Now, am I supposed to believe that you approve of rape as described in your version of "the old testament promised land?"
fred
You asked two rhetorical questions and both have been answered. The answer to your third question is no. As a member of a very recently enlightened culture (a shaky and ongoing process) I do not approve of rape under any circumstance. But I recognize that there are many cultures and that they hopefully evolve. Even in our own culture and in our lifetimes husbands raping their wives was tacitly approved by the law. Go back a little farther and rape as a widespread method of domination and humiliation hardly raised any eyebrows. Go back all the way to the recorded history of our culture and you will see that god himself used rape as a tool.
CosmicConservative
The answerer is not the one who determines if a question is rhetorical. The questions may have appeared to have been rhetorical since to answer them as your previous comments suggest you would answer them would defy logic and common sense, but I do not necessarily assume that logic and common sense are the things that motivate people, thus the questions, one of which, at least you finally partially answered, although with typical cultural relativism thrown in to obscure the answer. I guess since the "other" question was phrased more as a statement hoping for a response, I'll restate it as a question so we are clear on what I was asking. fred, since you have attacked Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld for selectively choosing which facts to reveal to support their political objectives, but you have applauded the NIE leaker's selectively choosing of facts to support THEIR political objectives, am I to conclude that lying and breaking the law is OK if it pursues your own ideology, but is wrong if it pursues an opposing one? Please expand on this with some attempt to provide a moral and ethical foundation beyond "I'm right and you're wrong." I did not need your self-serving lecture on the history of rape, by the way, and since I do not subscribe to either the concept of a living, fire-breathing deity who rules our lives, or the even more ridiculous concept that some book somewhere has captured that living, fire-breathing deity's divine actions, including his divine wrath, I don't accept your final point that "god himself used rape as a tool" as valid. I suppose you included it because you assume that I am some sort of fundamentalist since, as you libs all know, all conservatives are bible-thumping theocrats. So, in your newly "enlightened" state, you now "personally" believe that all rape is evil. But you suggest that other cultures may not agree, and that means that rape, although you disapprove of it yourself, may be actually OK so long as the culture it occurs in is fine with it. So I'm thinking that maybe "rape" in your moral code is something like "abortion" in that you support the argument that YOU may think it's wrong, but who are you to tell other people what to do with their body? Am I getting that right? I am trying to clarify since your point got kind of clouded up with your gratuitous religious slander.
fred
1. Yes it's true. I make distinctions between separate cases of lawbreaking according to my beliefs and politics. I'm glad that the initial leak occured because those conclusions only confirmed what many of us believed already. And I'm glad that Bush was forced to declassify more of the NIE: the mixed bag of conclusions is much more believable than a simple negative-only view. My ethics and morals are satisfied by this lawbreaking and forcing of the president's hand because the midterm election is in many ways a referendum on Iraq and we deserve to know as much about it as possible. I object to the administration's selling of the invasion because of what it needlessly led to: the death of tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians, thousands of coalition soldiers, an increased danger from terrorism and a very precarious situation in Iraq. Sorry I can't provide you with a moral formula. Perhaps it boils down to consequences. Could you ever support the illegal leaking of information? For instance, whoever leaked the database information to Beauprez... We know you think he should be prosecuted. But do you think he did the right thing? 2. I already know that you are an agnostic. So am I. But I think we can both agree that god exists at least as an abstract concept and projection of human values. I was only making the obvious point that in different times and places rape is and has been condoned, even to the point of being a manifestation of god. We would both try to stop any rape if we could anywhere in the world. But can you claim that if you were a member of another culture or even in our own cultural past that you would act as anything other than a member of that culture? I can't. Maybe you can.
JSullins
I must ask for forgiveness as I'm about to break topic.... but, wow: "But can you claim that if you were a member of another culture or even in our own cultural past that you would act as anything other than a member of that culture?" This kind of thinking I find frightening. This kind of thinking is what empowers people like Adolf Hitler. I personally pride myself on examining what my society / culture has to offer, and rejecting it when it does not conform to my personal criteria of morality. Would I have been a lone voice of dissent when Hitler was whipping up his masses? Heck yes! Do I reject the cultural garbage I see spreading in this country? Heck yes! In the former case I would have been put to death, I suppose. I consider myself lucky that all I am I likely to suffer now is the regular lampooning of my values by Hollywood. Meh, maybe I'm going overboard here. I just got back from a company lunch and I ate too much ;) No I'm not calling you a Nazi, Fred, or suggesting you endorse any Nazi beliefs. I'm suggesting that to accept any behavior because "everyone around me thinks it's ok" would be appalling.
fred
No, you're on topic. It's a difficult question. Congratulations on your conviction that you would be you in all times and places. To me, though, THAT kind of thinking is frightening.
CosmicConservative
fred: Whether an individual would commit certain acts, or approve certain behaviors due to environmental effects of their upbringing has no bearing on the fundamental morality of the acts or the approval. UNLESS there is no fundamental morality. Is that your contention?
fred
Now it is you ignoring several of my questions. :) But yes, I believe there is a fundamental human morality maybe best expressed simply as the golden rule. I am optimistic that we are slowly getting better at it.
CosmicConservative
Fred: I was out for a few hours, let me see if I can address your points from your prior email:
1. Yes it’s true. I make distinctions between separate cases of lawbreaking according to my beliefs and politics. I’m glad that the initial leak occured because those conclusions only confirmed what many of us believed already. And I’m glad that Bush was forced to declassify more of the NIE: the mixed bag of conclusions is much more believable than a simple negative-only view. My ethics and morals are satisfied by this lawbreaking and forcing of the president’s hand because the midterm election is in many ways a referendum on Iraq and we deserve to know as much about it as possible.
So you consider your personal interpretation of reality to be so absolute that you will even condone lawbreaking if it supports your own political beliefs. Do you grant this remarkable power to your opponents? Or do you consider yourself so infallible that only your ideology has this legal pass?
I object to the administration’s selling of the invasion because of what it needlessly led to: the death of tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians, thousands of coalition soldiers, an increased danger from terrorism and a very precarious situation in Iraq.
So do you acknowledge that the other side of the argument is that the invasion also stopped the needless deaths of thousands of innocent civilians, thousands, tens of thousands of soldiers such as those killed in Saddam's wars against Iran and Kuwait, and who knows where next? Do you acknowledge that there is another side to this argument that can tally up deaths just as impressively as you can? If so, are you willing to tally up those deaths and then abide by the decision that ends up with the fewest deaths, even if it is only one fewer?
Sorry I can’t provide you with a moral formula. Perhaps it boils down to consequences.
Since the consequences are impossible to predict, moral choices are generally considered to be valid only if they are made from current circumstances. Your approach boils down to Monday morning quarterbacking. I call it the Cindy Sheehan rule. She has said that she would like to go back in time and murder George W. Bush as a child. Since that would seem to lead to the consequences you would prefer, do you agree with Cindy that doing so would be the moral thing to do? If you see a distinction between Bush and Hitler, apply the same argument to Hitler then.
Could you ever support the illegal leaking of information? For instance, whoever leaked the database information to Beauprez… We know you think he should be prosecuted. But do you think he did the right thing?
I cannot "support the illegal leaking of information" because that is illegal. But I can say that I can conceive of a number of circumstances where leaking information could be morally correct, in spite of being illegal. I do not consider this one of those times.
2. I already know that you are an agnostic. So am I. But I think we can both agree that god exists at least as an abstract concept and projection of human values. I was only making the obvious point that in different times and places rape is and has been condoned, even to the point of being a manifestation of god.
I simply don't believe that this is a relevant point to the argument.
We would both try to stop any rape if we could anywhere in the world. But can you claim that if you were a member of another culture or even in our own cultural past that you would act as anything other than a member of that culture? I can’t. Maybe you can.
So first of all, it is not possible that anything resembling "me" could exist as a member of some barbarian culture. What makes "me" "me" is the result of a highly complex interweaving of genetics, environment, circumstance and happenstance. Your question is one that cannot be answered because the premise is fundamentally flawed. And it still is avoiding the question which is about moral absolutes. Your entire line of discussion here is one of moral relativism. I must admit I find that argument repugnant. I do not believe in God but I do believe in moral absolutes. It is always wrong to desire to do harm to others. Period. Cultural differences be damned. If "I" existed in some other culture and raped someone because I believed it to be OK (let's say it was part of razing a city of an enemy and raping the women was considered a legitimate "spoil of war"), "I", the REAL "I" believes that rape to be just as wrong as if I were to go nextdoor and rape my neighbor. If 6 billion human beings agreed that it was OK to rape someone in that situation, it would make it no less wrong in my view. Now, since you seem to be so strongly arguing for moral relativism, what is your position on torture? Is torture ever "right?"
fred
We have two interrelated topics going on here. 1. We both agree that there are times when breaking the law is morally acceptable. No need to list obvious examples. The question is, is there an absolute moral standard beyond our subjective belief and political leaning? Probably not. But I accept the law and the court system as the final arbiter--not on the moral question but the legal question. I can admire almost anyone who breaks the law on principle and who is willing to accept the consequences. So no, I do not consider my judgement in the cases of leaks of information to be infallible and my personal interpretation of reality is certainly not absolute. What a question. :) And yes, I grant that your judgement is different and may have a different moral basis. No problem. 2. Of course you couldn't be you in every time and place. And I'm not avoiding the question of moral absolutes. As I said, I believe in the golden rule. The problem is we certainly haven't achieved it yet. I think part of the key to getting there is understanding where we come from. I'd like to believe that if I were a Palestinian in the Occupied territories that I would be a moderate voice and seek change through peaceful means. But then, I am not a Palestinian. I strongly condemn suicide bombers killing civilians as a political tool. At the same time I think it is critical to try and understand them. Some of our Founders owned slaves and possibly raped them. We condemn slavery and rape but we make an effort to try and understand the cultural difference between then and now. Columbus committed some horrific crimes but we are often told not to judge him by modern standards. Do you see where I'm going with this? We condemn terrorism, slavery, rape and imperialistic conquest. But we need to understand and even empathize to a certain degree. I don't have an absolute adherence to moral relativism. But I think there are some definite perils to an attitude of moral superiority. I don't think that torture is ever right, especially as a routine method of obtaining information. But I can only hope that I would have the courage to commit torture as a last resort in the most extreme circumstances in order to hopefully save lives.
CosmicConservative
We've probably beat both of these horses well past their mortal limits. I think you have avoided the core questions I've asked enough times now that I am convinced you won't answer them, or can't answer them, any better than you have so far, so we'll move on to other things. But I hope you at least have a better understanding that much of the actual logic you employ to support your beliefs can be applied just as effectively by the other side. One quick example, let's say that the invasion and war in Iraq has resulted in the unfortunate deaths of 50,000 civilians. In the previous three years prior to the invasion the evidence is overwhelming that Saddam's regime killed hundreds of thousands of innocents. If you are going to use innocent deaths to justify objecting to the war, conservatives are equally able to use the lives saved to justify supporting it. Things are rarely as black and white as we would like. How 'bout that Yleris miniature sculpture, eh? ;)
Drax
Fred: "1. Yes it’s true. I make distinctions between separate cases of lawbreaking according to my beliefs and politics. I’m glad that the initial leak occured because those conclusions only confirmed what many of us believed already. And I’m glad that Bush was forced to declassify more of the NIE: the mixed bag of conclusions is much more believable than a simple negative-only view. My ethics and morals are satisfied by this lawbreaking and forcing of the president’s hand because the midterm election is in many ways a referendum on Iraq and we deserve to know as much about it as possible." This is simply saying that the "ends justifies the means." Since, in your opinion, the "end" is one you desire, the means used are morally and ethically correct. While I can agree with the concept in principle at times, this is not one of them. The "end" here was not to expose "the truth," but to affect an election. Had "the truth" been the reason for the leak, everything in the report would have been released, not just that which was harmful to the administration. And, even if the report in its entirety had been released, it wouldn't have been "the truth." It would simply have been the opinions of the writers. So, on no level can this leak be justified. "I object to the administration’s selling of the invasion because of what it needlessly led to: the death of tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians, thousands of coalition soldiers, an increased danger from terrorism and a very precarious situation in Iraq." Your reasoning has a fundamental flaw in it, i.e., that you believe that the deaths are "needless." (This is, of course, beyond your assertion that "tens of thousands of Iraqui civilians" died in the course of this action, a number which is hugely inflated -- certainly inflated if considering those civilians WE killed, rather than those the TERRORISTS killed.) Others believe that the war was necessary and whatever deaths occasioned by it "needful." I have no doubt in my mind that Saddam was seeking Nuclear technology and already had the means to deliver Nuclear warheads and was seeking larger range. I have no doubt in my mind that, if he felt it "needful," he would have used those weapons in his pursuit to create and rule a "Greater Arab State." "Sorry I can’t provide you with a moral formula. Perhaps it boils down to consequences. " Another refrence to "the ends justifies the means." "Could you ever support the illegal leaking of information? For instance, whoever leaked the database information to Beauprez… We know you think he should be prosecuted. But do you think he did the right thing?" Certainly there has to be times that information is being withheld by those in a position to withold it that should be released, whether to the public or to the appropriate party. Generally, this information is the kind in which the withholding party is hiding something which is harmful to him BECAUSE it is harmful to him. Criminal activity, for example. (Say, Enron) Activity which would subject him to civil suit. (Monica Lewinski, perhaps) One who "leaks" information in such situations does so, many times, to right a wrong, to get the information in the hands of the appropriate party or into the hands of the press for the bright light of the media to explore. This is not one of those situations. The person leaking the information had a BASE motivation, to affect the outcome of an election with a LIE. He knew the information to be a lie, and he knew that the MSM would promote his lie without any investigation or objective reporting. (Compare, for example, the press coverage of the initial leak to the later release of more complete information -- or compare the coverage of the motivation of the Administration for "witholding" the information, as compared to the subsequent coverage of motivation of the "leaker" in leaking his lie.) "2. I already know that you are an agnostic. So am I. But I think we can both agree that god exists at least as an abstract concept and projection of human values. I was only making the obvious point that in different times and places rape is and has been condoned, even to the point of being a manifestation of god. We would both try to stop any rape if we could anywhere in the world. But can you claim that if you were a member of another culture or even in our own cultural past that you would act as anything other than a member of that culture? I can’t. Maybe you can. " Societies change from within because someone decides that something is "wrong" and stands up against it or promotes a different way of thought. When enough people start to think that "slavery is wrong" or that "women should vote" or whatever, then things change. But, at some point in the past, there was a lone voice who was shouted down or killed for his thoughts. We are MORE than just a result of our culture, at least some of us. Can I say that I would be one of those who bucked the culture? I have no idea, but, those who flee other countries for the U.S. because they cannot stand their OWN culture, or are imprisoned (or killed) for staying and attempting to change their own culture posits the certain proposition that we are more than just a product of our culture.
fred
The evidence is overwhelming that Saddam killed hundreds of thousands from 2000 to 2003? Hmmm. Haven't seen the overwhelming evidence of a minimum of 66,000 murders by Saddam for each of those three years. But if you re-read my summary objection to the administration's sales job you will see that the innocent deaths for which we are responsible is just one item on the list. But I absolutely agree that we can apply the similar logic to our various positions and come up with entirely different answers. I never said otherwise. Recognizing this is kind of the essence of my particular flavor of moral relativism. So, should we remove George Washington from the one-dollar bill? Being a slave owner and god knows what went on at Mt. Vernon back in those day? Shall we abolish Columbus Day? There have been some serious violations of moral absolutism, you know.
fred
Drax said regarding the NIE leak: "While I can agree with the concept in principle at times, this is not one of them. So, on no level can this leak be justified." You'll have to take that up with Cosmo. He's the one who objects to people claiming a "superior personal interpretation of reality to be absolute". For myself, and as I've said several times, I'm simply content to let the justice system do its job. As for the moral justifications, you have your formula. I have mine. Drax honestly said regarding morality: "Can I say that I would be one of those who bucked the culture? I have no idea..." And yes, that is my exact thought on imagining myself to be Palestinian: FLEE!
CosmicConservative
Fred: You have an annoying tendency to mischaracterize the arguments of those who oppose you, then to base your argument on that mischaracterization in order to make a point. I did not "object to people claiming a 'superior personal interpretation of reality to be absolute.'" To put it as clearly as possible, I object to your claiming that YOUR personal interpretation of reality is so absolute that you excuse lawbreaking when it suits your ideological ends, but condemn the actions, including the LAWFUL actions of those who oppose your ideology. What I am objecting to is your smugly condescending double standard fred, not the concept of moral absolutes. If you do it, then stop condemning the other side for doing the same thing. One of my problems with your entire argument on this is that you play by a different set of rules than you allow your opponents to play by. At least you do until you are called on it, but it is a recurring pattern, just as is the pattern of you selectively quoting portions of a statement to mischaracterize it, set up a straw man, and then try to knock it down, then claim victory in the argument. That too is tiresome. Drax put my argument into much plainer words. You are engaged in both moral relativism and pursuing an ends justifies the means argument. Since both of those are completely counter to my own personal belief system, I don't think we are going to come to any agreement on this subject. But at least we have, I believe, distilled it down to its essence.
fred
Cosmo: You have an annoying tendency to mischaracterize the arguments of those who oppose you, then to base your argument on that mischaracterization in order to make a point. You did indeed “object to people claiming a ’superior personal interpretation of reality to be absolute.’” All you have to do is scroll up and read your own objection to my post. Problem is, I never claimed my perspective to be a "superior personal interpretation of reality" even though you said I did. I didn't. I know you think you tried to state it as clearly as possible, but when you quoted me and claim that I stated that "MY personal interpretation of reality is so absolute that I excuse lawbreaking when it suits MY ideological ends, but condemn the actions, including the LAWFUL actions of those YOU who oppose MY ideology"... ...I just have to ask, "What the hell are you talking about?!" Let's deal with specifics instead of your vague fuzzy complaints that I "engage in both moral relativism and pursuing an ends justifies the means argument"...? Give me a specific quote in context. Who knows, I may have to apologise and backtrack from an earlier statement. I can do that.
CosmicConservative
Fred: You have repeatedly stated that you are OK with breaking the law if you agree with the lawbreaker's political and ideological goals. Both Drax and I have pointed this out repeatedly. I'm not sure how much more plainly I can state that. This is what Drax and I are objecting to. It appears to me that this excusing of lawbreaking can only have one of two justifications. 1. You have absolute knowledge that your personal perspective on things is correct. It appears that there is only one reason someone would justify lawbreaking of this sort unless they had absolute knowledge of their own rightness, and that is: 2. You believe that any law is breakable by anyone who believes they are doing the right thing. Here is why I have tried to pursue this. 1 above is an expression of dogma, not reason. Or worse, theocracy. That level of certainty of the rightness of a position is not gained through reason or debate, it is gained through holy writ or zealous dogma. 2 above is the definition of anarchy. This is why I have called for the prosecution of both sides, and that I do not approve of breaking the law to advance ideological ends. The cases where I could entertain the breaking of laws are clear moral choices. You think you made a case for your law-breaking to be based on moral choices, but I think I effectively demonstrated that your argument which you think justifies the lawbreaking is just as effective used against you. Since it is that easy to challenge your rataionale for breaking the law, your position on this is clearly ideological, not logical. So that puts you in category 1 above. Your only defense of your approval of lawbreaking is that YOU think it is justified because of YOUR personal perspective on the universe. I'm telling you that you ain't that clever. You don't get to decide what is acceptable or not, and your attempts to convince us that you do have a valid argument have been easily rebutted. I don't like either category, 1 or 2. Both are repudiations of the very rule of law that has made civilizations like ours possible. If your approach to this were followed, then laws could be broken at a whim, and purely for the purpose of advancing a particular ideology. I'm not sure how that is much better than fascism, frankly.
fred
Cosmo said: "You have repeatedly stated that you are OK with breaking the law if you agree with the lawbreaker’s political and ideological goals. Both Drax and I have pointed this out repeatedly. I’m not sure how much more plainly I can state that." But both you and Drax have said that you yourselves are OK with breaking the law if you agree with the lawbreaker’s political and ideological goals. You just don't happen to agree in the particular case of the NIE leaker. Or did I get that wrong? Are you not OK with breaking the law if you agree with the lawbreaker’s political and ideological goals? How about if you provide an example of when you are OK with breaking the law and you agree with the lawbreaker’s political and ideological goals. That might help to clarify. Otherwise pleas state clearly that you are NEVER OK with breaking the law even if you agree with the lawbreaker’s political and ideological goals.
CosmicConservative
Fred, I am not OK with breaking laws to pursue ideological goals. I don't believe I ever said I was. I said I can conceive of times when a MORAL imperative would lead one to break laws, and I could agree with that. For example, in Nazi Germany I agree with those who broke the law to save the lives of Jews. In this case my ideological goals coincide with the moral imperative, but that is not always the case. Another example. I remain dead-set against both the Watergate breakin and the Iran-Contra Republican lawbreaking precisely because those were done for purely ideological reasons. There is some gray area where I can't unwrap my morality from my ideology, but those are fairly rare situations. The guy who leaked FBI database info to the Beauprez campaign falls into the purely ideological category, which is why I called for his prosecution. I think there is a clear difference between us on this issue, and I do think it is illustrative of the true differences between liberals and conservatives. I believe the rule of law is one of the few things that separates civilization from anarchy. Breaking those laws should be something that is done only for the highest and purest of purposes. Getting your man elected to some political office doesn't qualify.
fred
Can't you come up with a moral imperative a little more contemporaneous than old tried and true Nazi Germany? Surely there must be some other modern example of a case where your morality would lead you to support lawbreaking and yet be free of any taint of ideology.
CosmicConservative
Not many fred. I have pretty stringent standards for what constitutes an excuse for breaking the law. Your mileage may vary. Apparently it does.
Drax
Fred: If I came across, in my official duties, a secret memo which indicated that we were running a secret torture/rape compound which served no purpose BUT to torture and rape (you know, like in Saddam's Iraq...) I might feel compelled to expose that information. Or, if I found out that the government was systematically excluding women from even that most basic of things ... say.... reading (as Afghanistan) this, too, might compel me to come forward. There are many types of activity which would compel me to break the law. However, almost all of them would be due to the criminal act of some person which was being performed in the name of my country. Not only criminal, but irredeemable. I do believe in civil disobedience. I do believe that people should come forward with information that, perhaps they legally should not have or reveal, will prevent injustice. (Can we say Linda Tripp?) It is our moral duty to stand up to evil. But, policy decisions? A disagreement on interpretation of facts? Solely for the purpose of affecting the outcome of an election? Indefensible.
fred
Now Cosmo is "on record saying" he condemns Martin Luther King Jr. and a host of other lawbreakers fighting for similar worthless causes. And why? Devotion to moral absolutism. Never mind the fact that when pressed on certain inconvenient details of history, Cosmo cannot muster an argument. Moral relativism must not be aknowledged! Drax I was seeing some sense in your argument until you came up with Linda Tripp.
Drax
What was wrong with Linda Tripp? She had seen what happened to women who had dared to tell the truth about Bill Clinton. He had seen them dragged through the mud, slandered, defamed by the Clinton "Bimbo Eruption" spin machine. So, when she started getting information from someone who was involved with Clinton, potentially putting herself directly in the crosshairs of the Clinton Machine, she did the only rational thing she could do to protect herself...she recorded the conversations. Kinda like Monica saved the blue dress, eh? When you're dealing with scum like Clinton, if you don't have telephone recordings or stained dresses, you're just going to get eaten up.
fred
We could've used a few Linda Tripps back in the days of the Founders.
Drax
Lol. You actually think that citing Linda Tripp actually HELPS your argument! That's funny, man. Really.
CosmicConservative
fred continues to cherry pick, mischaracterize and otherwise obfuscate things to make straw man arguments to attack so he can convince hmself that he can win arguments. Sigh. fred. I said there were "few" situations where I would break the law because of moral convictions. I would like to think that civil disobedience of the type that Martin Luther King did would be one of them. However, the activiites of the Weathermen, Black Panthers and other "radical activists," including the nutcases John Kerry was affiliated with in the 70's who advocated the murder of Senators would not be laws I would break. And to reiterate my point, I didn't say that nobody should ever break the law, I said it should be only for the purest of purposes. MLK qualifies. Larry Hanauer does not. I'm no great fan of Linda Tripp, but I can certainly see why she felt it necessary to record conversations in case she ended up needing them to protect herself. At the very least I will say that she proved prescient. Monica's saving of the infamous blue dress was not illegal so far as I know. However, Clinton's secretary destroying evidence of Monica's visits to the Oval office certainly qualifies as illegal, I suppose you think that was heroic too.
fred
I see you don't appreciate the irony of applying the strawman "you are on record saying" when you so easily employ that shallow tactic on me. Oh well. Irony deficiency. MLK qualifies. Larry Hanauer does not. How about Oliver North? Does he qualify? Oops, my bad. The ACLU helped to overturn his conviction on a technicality.
CosmicConservative
Of course I think when I say "you are on record" I am applying the full context of your statements instead of cherry picking them the way you do. But no doubt my own vision is clouded by my bias, I may do the same thing to you, but you don't hesitate to call me on it so the irony goes both ways. Ollie North should not have protected Reagan on Iran-Contra. That was a sad, sordid stain on Reagan's otherwis stellar legacy. I did not share in the Ollie hero worship.