Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Where is Greenpeace?

By CosmicConservative
Remember when G.W. Bush proposed doing limited tests of nuclear weapons to ensure that our arsenal was ready to defend this country against our enemies and how Greenpeace and other "environmental" groups went nutzo? There were demonstrations all over the northern hemisphere, and breathless news accounts on an hourly basis. Where are those brave souls now that North Korea is conducting tests and Iran is promising to? Have you seen them?

Comments (20)

fred
You won't find them if you don't look. For instance: http://www.greenpeace.org/international/news/north-korea-nuclear-test-091006 Type > and sort by date for more. First, you can't find a simple news article on CNN two hours after a story breaks. Now you ask the rhetorical question and don't even bother to look for an answer. I wonder about you sometimes, Cosmo.
fred
Sorry, that was supposed to be: go to Google news, type > and sort by date.
fred
I guess your blog doesn't like my keyboard. One more time. Type: greenpeace "north korea" and sort by date.
JSullins
Fred, Hm. I performed the search you suggested above. I did not find anything substantive. What I do see is someone motivated by emotions trying to make a point at all costs.... I think Cosmic was alluding to the absence of "demonstrations all over the northern hemisphere, and breathless news accounts on an hourly basis." If you take the time to read his post rationally, you will see you are not responding with relevant information. Now, I think the original post is meant to bring attention to the double standard that does exist in this country -- both in the media and within the membership of various far-left groups like Greenpeace. Let's face it, these groups hate GWBush more than the legitmately dangerous and arguably insane dictator of North Korea. Perhaps they'd rather have him be our President? If Greenpeace truly cared for the environment or for peace, they would spend their energy in massive protests and action against North Korea rather than exuding pure hate for GWBush. Let's see them intercepting some shipping and impeding the sale of missile technology! Let's see them draw attention to the plight of starving millions of peasants in the North! Let's see them do something useful. Let's not lie to ourselves, enemy #1 for Greenpeace is GWBush, not North Korea. I present that as evidence of the uselessness of the organization.
fred
The statement and implication of Cosmo's post is clear, and JS just reinforces it: "Greenpeace is silent on the matter of North Korean nukes; Greenpeace prefers Little Kim to George Bush." Now, the further implication is that current protests ar "insubstantial" because they don't match the volume of other protests. Also, Greenpeace doesn't actually care about the environment or peace. All of which is nonsense and your invocation of rationality is belied by your hatred of Greepeace.
Dadman
And virutally every liberal 'cause' is undermined by their irrational hatred of GWB. I'm a conservative and used to be a member of Greenpeace. I don't hate Greenpeace, I just believe they and other environmental organizations have lost credibility as they've become more political and less rational over the years. They seem more interested lately in playing partisan politics they they do in their original mission statement. It's a shame really...
JSullins
Well said Dadman. I would add that I don't hate Greenpeace either. For that matter, I find that holding any belief because of hatred is neither rational nor persuasive. What I said was that Greenpeace useless. Perhaps I should have said that I question their usefulness. :) Fred, do you argue that Greenpeace is more concerned with North Korea than with GWB? If so, I think I missed it.... If not, then I think you are conceding that they are, in fact, useless. When I see the members of any organization passionate about something or someone, that shows me what their purpose is. When I see passion about hating GWB and relative silence about one of the most dangerous regimes in the world today, it is easy to make a logical conclusion.
CosmicConservative
Fred: You continue to try to find some tiny little corner of my posts to focus a laser beam of criticism on while ignoring the entire point of the message. Show me the protests in Bonn, Fred. In Manhattan. In London. In San Francisco. A minor, ineffective news release just doesn't have the same impact as a thousand radicals in death's head masks burning GW Bush in effigy, now does it? You are losing more credibility with every post Fred. And I am truly saddened by it. By the way, I don't hate Greenpeace either, but I agree with their ex-director who says that they have become politically motivated, not environmentally motivated. At least I think it was an ex-director of theirs, but I'm sure Fred will find an error in that comment.
CosmicConservative
One other point, I was using "Greenpeace" as shorthand for all environmental groups, since they tend to flock together at the organized anti-US Imperialist rallies they hold so frequently. So it isn't just Greenpeace I have an issue with, it's the entire "environmental" movement. Greenpeace is just one of the leaders of that movement.
fred
Did you even look for stories of Greepeace protesting North Korea's nuke test before you started this discussion? How did you come up with this topic? What got you started on this.
JSullins
I think that's beside the point, really. Can we discuss the actual intended topic? Or perhaps you are in agreement in essence, so see no need for such discussion?
fred
Okay, I will concede. Nobody hates Greenpeace. But Greenpeace hates Bush. Not the next president, not Clinton, not Pappy, not Reagan. Hate Bush. There could be no reason at all for an anti-nuclear activist group to protest US nuclear proliferation any louder than North Korea except that they hate Bush. "I didn't hear them protest" India, or Pakistan, or Israel, or China. Bush. In fact, if Greenpeace could put Little Kim in the White House they would do so eagerly. Hate Bush. In fact, liberalism is primarily motivated by one thing and one thing only. Hate Bush. I think that is the intended topic, isn't it?
Dadman
Fred, your thick sarcasm really diminishes the point you are trying to make. If you doubt that much of modern day liberalism's rhetoric and action is motivated by an intense hatred of Bush, you're deluded. There's no question it is. In the minds of many liberals Bush is the primary enemy, not the evil bastards who murder innocent people in the name of Allah. That doesn't mean liberalism as a philosophy is completely devoid of rationality, it's just that much of that rationality has been completely overshadowed by contempt and hatred for George Bush. If more liberals could purge themselves of all the hate and contempt more red-state Americans might actually listen to them. I truly hope that doesn't happen any time soon...
fred
Dadman said, "...intense hatred of Bush... Bush is the primary enemy... contempt and hatred for George Bush... hate and contempt..." Speaking for myself only, I don't hate George Bush. I have sufficient perspective on history to realize that partisan passion frequently flares up (look at the last ten years or more) and our focus easily becomes misdirected. George Bush is mainly a figurehead. He does have the capacity to move off the reservation and act against his base from time to time... to the chagrin of those who would like to support him but sometimes find it difficult. For a liberal like me it's not Bush-hatred which is the motivating factor. It's simple opposition to many of the principles and policies Bush promotes. So, while to you it may seem like hatred of the man, especially if you focus on extreme personalities who make a point of being publicly obnoxious, to me it is more an adherence to what I feel are my liberal principles. One day not too far down the road, you conservatives will have to let go of the BDS paradigm in describing liberals. Can you give me a preview of what comes after that?
Dadman
I think the more appropriate question is what will liberals do when they no longer have GWB as the focus of their animosity. Can you give me a preview of what comes after that? The fact of the matter is the day after the Republicans lose control of Congress and/or the Oval Office there will still be implacable Islamist radicals plotting our demise, we will continue to have serious commitments in the Middle East including the need to finish what we started in Iraq, the planet will continue to warm (if you believe that stuff), North Korea and Iran will continue to be belligerent, the U.N. will continue to be a corrupt, useless organization incapable of achieving anything worthwhile, Islamists in Darfur will continue to commit genocide, the vast majority of Americans will still oppose same-sex unions, evil will continue to flourish in dangerous world... I often find myself wondering, what precisely will liberals do differently about all these things when they are in power again? Probably not much. They just want to be in power again...
fred
Yes of course, of course, that is always the more appropriate question: what precisely will the liberals do... their only aim being in power? We can take the moral superiority of conservative ambition for granted. Personally, I think the question is moot. I seriously doubt the Democrats will take control of Congress after this next election. And even if they do, it won't necessarily be a victory for liberalism. Just as many feel that the current GOP leadership has betrayed conservatism, there are just as many liberals betrayed by Democrats.
Dadman
As an independent conservative, Fred, I would very much like to throw all the bums out. BTW, I didn't mean to imply that conservatives are morally superior. I'm just amused by partisan politics and the bizarre notion that if liberals somehow begin to win elections again that all will be right with the world...in the world of moveon.org at least. In the wee hours of the morning as election results begin to come in, I imagine good liberal partisans weeping with joy, blowing horns, giggling with giddy excitement, rolling in balloons and confetti, celebrating the demise of those evil conservative bastards. But I'm old and wise enough to know that little will change. Even liberals must genuflect the altar of pragmatism and the realities of the world. That's what Bush has been doing and I predict even a liberal would be compelled to do it too.
CosmicConservative
Fred: As a liberal, can you give me a rational explanation for why activists can organize in the tens of thousands to protest the relatively tame and well-explained activities of George W. Bush, Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher or Tony Blair, but those same activists are conspicuously absent over the much more serious and unexplained abuses of Iranian mullahs, North Korean despots, Cuban gulags, and Venezualan thuggery? Worse, can you explain why those same activists actually wear Hugo Chavez T-Shirts? Don't they even see the irony of such things?
fred
Having never been an activist or been to a peace rally or protest (I was at a candlelight vigil once and paid into the Nature Conservancy for a while) I'm afraid I can't offer much insight. I dislike being associated with certain types almost as much as you do. My guess would be that perhaps since the US leads the world in both quantity of armaments and disarmement initiatives (Bush senior declared a voluntary moratorium on testing in 1992) it might make some sense to focus their efforts in a top-down approach. Plus, governmental policies of liberal democracies such as ours have been shown to be occaisionally influenced by people protesting in the streets. Perhaps as constituents of governments which purport to represent them, activists feel a stronger reponsibility to effect change in their own societies. There is no doubt in my mind that there is great hatred, but I believe the hatred is of the "military industrial complex" and "economic imperialism" and "corporatism" and so forth. Any pragmatic politician elected president of this country will represent these "evils" to the core of peace and environmental activists. Differences of policy between Democrats and Republicans are seen as minor by the hard-core. Personally, I've always been conflicted on the issues of nuclear arms and even on some environmental issues. I don't hate Bush. I wish he would retire from politics and move in next door to throw barbecue parties and I could borrow his gardening tools.
CosmicConservative
Fred: The reason I mention the hypocrisy of the Left on issues like their rabid anti-Conservative demonstrations compared to their relative silence when it comes to monsters like Ahmenijad or Khatami or Chavez or Castro (just to misspell a few...) is because I agree with you that the leaders of the movements, including elected politicians like Nancy Pelosi, understand that they are organizing the protests mostly because they think such protests will affect change in a democratic society. I get that. I have always gotten that. But what that ignores is what the message that gets received by rank and file activists is. When they are rallied around an anti-Bush cause, and told to create the most virulent hate-filled slogans possible, and when they get to dance around in front of the camera, all of that greatly reinforces their emotional attachment to their feelings about Reagan, Thatcher or Bush. So they become truly visceral connections. They have effectively been trained and rewarded for their hatred and so their hatred has become ingrained. They really mean it. Because that same reinforcement/feedback system is only put in place against those targets, and is never truly exercised against truly despotic madmen like Chavez, the end result is that they only truly develop a hatred for Blair, Bush, Reagan, Thatcher, etc. And when those figures then come out against someone else, the "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" dynamic comes into play and you end up with surreal spectacles like Cindy Sheehan palling around with Hugo Chavez, who truly does crush dissent in Venezuala, attacking Bush for crushing dissent while she publicly and fearlessly dissents against Bush with absolutely zero repercussions. That's what drives rational folk like me crazy. I pesonally believe that that partisan attacks of the past few decades have seriously, perhaps permanently, damaged our democracy. John Kerry and Al Gore (and other liberal voices, such as you here on this site) can make whatever excuses they want about their veiled accusations of electoral fraud, but the end result is not that they somehow get into power, the only result is that the population of the country as a whole starts to doubt the honesty and integrity of our elected public officials. The whole "Bush lied" meme that the Left has been putting out now for almost five years has had exactly the primary effect the Democratic leadership has intended. It has driven Bush's numbers to historic lows. But it has had a secondary effect as well, and that effect has been to undermine U.S. policy at home and abroad at a time when the U.S. needs to be focused on a serious threat to our national security. I have seen so many liberals trot out supposed quotations from Thomas Jefferson saying "dissent is the highest form of patriotism" or similar things. But the truth is that Jefferson never said any such thing. However, he did say this:
Political dissension is doubtless a less evil than the lethargy of despotism: but still it is a great evil, and it would be as worthy the efforts of the patriot as of the philosopher, to exclude it's influence if possible, from social life.
In other words, Jefferson said to dissent responsibly. My personal opinion is that the dissent in this country has become irresponsible. And on both sides. But my perspective, as a conservative, is that it is much worse on the left than the right. Perhaps that is just because we have a Republican President right now, and it may have been the reverse when Clinton was President, but even then I think the dissent against Clinton was of the sort that reflected on Clinton personally, not on the government as an institution. Nuclear arms are a fact of life. Someone is going to have them. Since that is a given, I want my country to have some to defend ourselves with. If you read my blog regularly, you will realize that I said I do not understand what gives the U.S. the moral authority to say that is OK for us, but not OK for Iran. So I am as conflicted as you are, but probably in a different direction. I also think the anti-globalization forces in the world are as misinformed and as irresponsible as the anti-Bush forces, although there is a lot of overlap between them. The entire history of the human race as far back as you can trace it is one long path towards a global intermingled religious, sectarian and economic society, with intermittent setbacks. To rail against WalMart or McDonalds or "U.S. Imperialism" as some sort of great evil is no different than to rail against the introduction of electricity, plumbing and roads in parts of the world that were living little better than the stone age. The world is converging, society is becoming one large whole, travel and communication technology makes this inevitable, unless a new dark age descends on us. Complaining about it, especially breaking windows at Starbucks, is just plain childish.