Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL after four weeks

By CosmicConservative
How 'bout them Broncos? Peyton-Manning So, after a year and four games I am willing to admit that John Elway was right and I was wrong. Peyton Manning was a superior choice at QB than Tim Tebow. I still think Tebow should get a chance, and he would, I believe, be an upgrade at QB for several current NFL teams, including the NY Jets and Jacksonville Jaguars, but c'est la vie. Tim needs to work out his own life and as much as I enjoyed watching him pull miracles on the field, I have to agree that the current juggernaut that the Broncos have become is a more comfortable viewing experience. I really haven't been paying that much attention to the NFL so far this year. It is impossible to live in the Denver area and not be inundated with Denver Broncos status, so I know most of what's going on at Dove Valley and Mile High stadium, but beyond that I haven't watched a game or paid much attention to the stats. Looking over the current rankings, ratings and win-loss records, here are my thoughts so far, for teams other than the one wearing orange and a horse-head on their helmets:
  1. Tom Brady is probably doing more to demonstrate why I think he's the best QB in the NFL right now than he has done in some time. Yes the Patriots are struggling, yes Brady's stats are probably the lowest they've been in a decade or more, yes, they have yet to play an elite NFL team, but dude, they're 4-0 with an entirely new set of receivers, many of whom are rank rookies, and Brady is still managing to win with them.
  2. RG3 and Michael Vick are doing a real good job demonstrating why an NFL team might prefer a Peyton Manning style QB to a Tim Tebow style QB. Sure they are fun to watch, but people are starting to wonder if RG3 will ever fully recover from his knee injury last year, and Michael Vick is running around like a lunatic, but both teams are 1-3, and barely 1-3 at that.
  3. Dallas. Ha. Another year of mediocrity. Romo is having a pretty solid season again, but Dallas simply seems incapable of crawling out of the ranks of NFL also-rans. I suspect the NFC East will come down to the last week of the season again, and whatever team manages to scrape out a 9-7 season will win the division and get summarily kicked out of the playoffs by a serious contender.
  4. I think Seattle is over-rated.
  5. Tonight's game will go a long way to show if the Saints are back to their Super Bowl form or if they will have to fight to reach the playoffs again.
  6. I wonder how long it will be in NYC before people start calling for Eli Manning to be benched. I've always thought Eli was overrated, but this year he has been simply awful. The entire Giants team strategy right now seems to be "throw the ball as far as Eli can and hope for the best."
  7. Pittsburgh is 0-4 and looking like they're really worse than that.

Comments (7)

Drax
I agree that Peyton Manning is an upgrade from Tebow. Never thought otherwise, if he was 100%. C'mon. He's arguably the best QB of all time. How could he NOT be an upgrade? 1) I'll never agree on Tom Brady. I will continue to say that it's the system. He's good. Perhaps even great. But, put another good QB in that system and he'll be nearly as good - as has been established. Manning is far superior to him. 2) Really can't say any of that about either Vick or RG3. Neither has been doing much in the way of the "option" of whatever variety and it could be argued that this is WHY they haven't been doing well. (And Vick hasn't been much in the way of an "option" QB for nearly a decade.) Neither, for that matter has Colin Kaepernick. In fact, the ONLY QB who has been running "option" plays as a matter of course this year has been Russell Wilson - and the Seahawks are 4-0. 3) Jerry Jones made one trade two decades ago and drafted predictable high first round players for two years (following bottom-of-the-standings years). As a result, he got Irvin, Aikman, and Smith who delivered 2 Superbowl championships. Since then, when he's had to live from lower draft picks and free agency, he has SUCKED as a GM. 4) No. They're Superbowl bound. Great defense. Good running game. Best balance between running and passing in the game. 5) Saints are looking good. Really good on offense. They will only go as deep as their opportunistic defense takes them, though. 6) The NYG offensive line sucks. The defense sucks. Special teams suck. Eli is about what he has always been - high risk, high reward. Only, there's a huge imbalance in the risk to reward ratio right now. 7) Pittsburgh has been bad for a long time. Big Ben has been able to make some Eli-like plays which have covered up many of their short-comings. Now, though, like Eli, he has too many of the other aspects of his team which are incompetent to allow him to make up for the team's shortcomings. And, Tebow would be an upgrade in: Jacksonville, Buffalo, New York (Jets), Oakland, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Tennessee, Philadelphia, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Miami, and St. Louis
CosmicConservative
We'll see about Seattle. I'm not saying they aren't good, I just don't think they are nearly good enough to deserve the #1 power ranking in the NFL (which they held when I first posted this message) or the assumption that the rest of the NFC is just going to roll over and let Seattle run over them. They have not even dominated all the games they've won so far. Brady vs Manning is going to be another Cobb vs Ruth or Jordan vs Chamberlain or Nicklaus vs Tiger debate. I doubt it will ever be fully resolved. If Brady takes this team deep into the playoffs I think it will be one of his greatest years, whether his stats reflect it or not. His receivers so far are just barely managing to keep up with him. I saw five or six dropped balls or mis-run routes in just the few minutes of the game I did watch last week. If those guys ever do get on the same page with Brady, look out.
tomnnva
Week 5 is an indicator of the QB abilities between Manning and Brady. I like Tebow, I always pulled for the guy, but saying Manning is an upgrade in the QB slot is like saying a Saturn 5 is an upgrade to a Estes hobby rocket. Go Broncos.
CosmicConservative
Heh. Well, I might even agree with that Tom. Although I think the Cowboys had Denver today, until that last pick... I wasn't watching the game, I had some house work to do, but I heard about it. Dang I would have loved to have Romo out QB Peyton Manning and win that game...
Drax
They were both great. Historically great. That pick was a result of Romo in the process of throwing the ball when he had his forward foot movement stalled by a blitzing player causing him to lose power in his throwing motion, making the pass go slower and shorter allowing a diving defensive player to pick it off. But, from either perspective, we have two defenses which allowed around 50 points. Denver never punted. Not once. I will say that these rule changes allow for some spectacular QB/WR play!
CosmicConservative
I'm trying to stop rooting for the Cowboys, and trying to start rooting for the Broncos. But it's hard, I have too much baggage with both teams. I am hoping that Dallas comes away from this game with the realization that they can play with anyone, but I suspect they will just go back to being good/bad on alternate weeks and suck again next week.
Drax
I cannot root for a team (as a fan, anyway, i.e., a "Cowboy fan" or whatever). I can root for a team on an ad hoc basis, but not as a matter of course. I used to be able to, but that was when the player/management dynamic was entirely different - before Curt Flood. Then a "team" was a team, roughly consisting of the same players over extended periods of time. The "Big Red Machine," for example. Or the "Purple People Eaters." Now, there's nothing to be loyal TO. How can I root for the Cowboys when they would trade away Emmit? Or SF who replaced Montana with Young and traded away Rice? I'm not saying that I'm against free agency as I'm not. Just that it makes it difficult to treat a team as a "team" when the owner and the players treat it as a business. Now, I just root for (and against) certain players. For LeBron. Against Kobe. For Peyton. Against Brady. And, I do root against some organizations such as New England. Or Los Angeles. Or any of them from Chicago. *Ptui*