Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Memorable story moments in fiction

By CosmicConservative
As I have noted in a few other posts lately, I've finally gotten my motivation back to finish the novel I've been working on for eight years now. Yeah, eight years. No kidding. Seriously. Since 2005. My very first files on this book date back to a basic plot outline I put together on an airplane in 2005. My first rough attempts to create the opening scenes of the book were written a few days later. A few days after that I created the basic character portraits of the main characters. Eight years ago. Wow. Up to this point I have been focused entirely on creating a cohesive, comprehensible and compelling story with interesting and believable characters. Of course I don't know how well I've done that, but I've done the best I can, and as I read through the book myself, it feels pretty natural and seems to hold together well. If I make the final change I discussed in my previous post, then technically I can call the story finished. But there's something that I really, really want to do. And that is to not merely create a believable, cohesive and compelling story, but to create a story that provides the reader with truly memorable moments that they will savor and perhaps even come to identify with the story. Here are some examples of what I'm talking about. I suspect that most of my readers will immediately recognize every single one of these moments and it will evoke mostly positive memories of the stories they came from: balrog "You cannot pass!" "Please sir, I want some more." "Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn!" "Big Brother is watching you." "It is a far, far better thing I do than I have ever done..." "Are you trying to seduce me, Mrs. Robinson?" I'm not sure how to do this though. I know what I WANT to do, I want to have the story build up to a crescendo of tension and conflict, then capture that tension and conflict in either a memorable statement from a character, or else some equally memorable descriptive text. I want that moment to be seared into the reader's mind such that if they repeat that quotation or descriptive item, anyone who has read the book will immediately be drawn back to that moment and relive it in their mind. I really don't know if other authors deliberately attempt that, or if it "just happens." I am worried that trying to MAKE it happen might actually be counter-productive, sort of like trying to make a date successful with just the right line, and then sounding like a total ass. Still, that's what I want. I want there to be at least half a dozen moments in this book that are so compelling and have been so firmly embedded in the minds of the reader, that twenty years after reading the book, one sentence will pull them back to a moment that had enthralled them.

Comments (11)

Jack
I think trying to force or actively create a moment that will be remembered years from now in a novel or film, or other work of artistic expression, is like trying to capture lightning in a bottle. I believe those moments just do or don't happen. They cannot be predicted. Think about it. How many bad movies have we all seen? Yet, I'm pretty certain no writer/producer/director decides in advance to make a bad movie. That's just how the cards played out for those films. And novels too. I've read bad novels (in my opinion) by authors I like. It's okay to ponder creating those memorable moments and strive for that as you write your novel. But it'll just make you crazy if you second-guess yourself too much. Like I said, those moments will either happen or not and there is really no way to predict them. I say make the final changes you want, then submit it to some publishers. Or an agent looking for new clients. If they give your book any time, they will tell you what they think needs improvement, if anything. Not that they are the definitive judges of your work, but at least there will be some fresh eyes looking at it. Fresh eyes that make their living at this sort of thing. It's exciting seeing this come together for you. I wish you the best!!
CosmicConservative
Jack, thanks, I think you're probably right. In my own selfish mind I think the book has several memorable moments, but most of them are narrative descriptions of active events, like a combat scene or a dream or something. I don't currently have any actual dialog that comes to mind as being memorable, which makes me think that perhaps my dialog is too bland. Right now I'm pretty happy that my latest effort on the book is to finally complete all the little pre-chapter blurbs that I have decided to use as a foreshadowing, expository or narrative focusing device. And I'm really happy that I've only got about ten of those left to do. Those have turned out to be much more difficult than I expected. Once those are done I am pretty much at the point that I only have nagging issues that I just don't think are quite polished enough. Here's a short list of those issues: 1. I have some significant rivalry going on between the protagonist and his older brother. Because of their circumstances they are thrown into close partnership for the entire book, but both love the same woman and the older brother is jealous of the younger brother for three reasons (the woman prefers the younger brother, the older brother blames the younger brother for his father's leaving the family and the older brother feels that he should be the one the gods have taken an interest in). I've got a pretty good bit of dialog and action depicting that conflict, but I just don't quite feel I've got it exactly right yet. 2. I have a number of supporting characters that just feel cardboardy to me. But the irony is that when I try to really infuse them with personality, it feels contrived and actually seems to distract from the story. I just can't seem to find the right line between minor characters being background and being real people. 3. The story, in my mind anyway, has a fairly complex plot, with multiple simultaneous conflicts that the protagonist has to deal with. As such it feels when I am reading it that the conflict is fairly clear and obvious, but upon contemplating the book it has a vague feel that I need to make the MAIN conflict more compelling and personal. As it is that main conflict is almost a man vs nature level of conflict since the conflict is between one man and his handful of companions against a vast and overpowering military force. 4. There's no porn in the book. None at all. I had some in there but felt uncomfortable with it. (I shouldn't say "porn" I guess, but that's what it feels like when writing about writhing genitalia) In fact I even removed sex from the equation altogether since the protagonist's love interest is savagely raped and brutalized and spends the rest of the book dealing with what is essentially post-traumatic stress about it. I intend to have them finally consummate their relationship, but so far, in this book, it's strictly PG from a sex perspective. (Not to worry though, it's probably NC-17 from a violence and gore perspective).
Dadman
I've been insanely busy lately with work and getting my son ready to go off to college (we leave Monday), but I wanted to say I think it's awesome you've nearly finished your novel. I know you're considering self-publication, but I wouldn't rule out sending it off to some major book publishers for consideration. Why not?
CosmicConservative
"Why not" is because the average length of time for a major publisher to make a final decision on a submission ranges from six months to two years. "Why not" is because the average book publisher rejects over 95% of books unread because the author did not fulfill some process detail or satisfactorily suck up to the publishing house editor. "Why not" is because even when a book is successful, first time authors are routinely screwed out of reasonable royalties because they are told that all first time authors take a crappy publishing deal. Those are the main reasons. Add to that that the traditional book publishers are flat going out of business and most have made an editorial decision to avoid taking on new authors so they can focus on exploiting the established franchises that already exist. Times are hard in the dead-tree publishing world.
CosmicConservative
Sorry, not meaning to do that. Just venting my frustration with the traditional dead-tree publishing system, which I feel has been run more or less like a drug cartel for decades, with the blood, sweat and tears of authors providing lavish lifestyles for armies of publishing "professionals". I know a couple people who have published fiction books the traditional way, and their experiences have not been positive ones. For decades the publishing houses have had the power to force new authors to accept horrible contracts. To be fair though, best-selling authors gain tremendous leverage in future contracts, but I'm not one of those. Yet.
Jack
Yes, that is all true. It's very difficult for a new writer to get published and there's poor advances and little royalties if you do. My first instinct would be to try to go the traditional route but I realize my view on the matter is somewhat skewed because I know a bunch of published writers and even one, a hard science fiction writer, who's never received so much as a rejection letter. No kidding, he published the first short story he ever submitted and has had several novels published since. Another friend, a fellow screenwriter, wrote a spec script for a TV show about 15 years ago, and BANG, got himself an agent who got him on several TV shows and he's banged away at the keyboard from then on. He's recently made the transition to producer which is common for a TV writer. And my own Ferris Bueller-like experience in the film business certainly doesn't help. My first (real) film gets picked up by two major studios and earns millions of dollars. So my view is clearly out of whack. Sorry, CC, I am of no help whatsoever on this matter. If the wait-and-see from a publisher is 6 months to 2 years then the self-publishing would definitely be appealing to me too. But don't completely close the door on the traditional path no matter how remote success might be. Sometimes the puck does indeed go right past the goalie into the net. And when it does you will discover you're just as surprised as everyone else.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... yeah, using sports metaphors doesn't do much to inspire a Colorado Rockies fan who grew up rooting for the New Orleans Saints.... Still, I understand the points being made. Also, complaining about six months to two years to wait seems a little silly for a book I've already spent eight years on. Maybe it's just cold feet.
Jack
Nothing wrong with having cold feet. We are all just as much afraid of success as we are of failure. Failing can lead to people saying "I told you so" and succeeding can lead to life changes we're not ready for. And there's also nothing wrong with going the self-publishing route either. I'm just saying consider all your options. But I know you already know that. I'm a big believer that quality work finds its proper place in the market. Even though the market for novels and films are somewhat locked up by the established artists in those areas, new ones do push their way in. We see it all the time. New voices appear and take the limelight. My rule of thumb when it comes to your own work: you never, ever, ever say no to yourself! You never put limits on what you can accomplish! Put that burden on someone else. Let someone else tell you "no, we don't want your novel." If you say it, you've done their job for them. They're not doing your job so there's no reason to do theirs. And if the door is slammed in your face... so what! If you learned something from it you didn't fail. And the experience will better prepare you the next time around. Quick story: In 1991 I was trying to sell my first feature film. A film that took me five years to make (shooting it on weekends for one year and and four years of post-production as I slowly scraped together the funds). A distributor I sent it to in LA told me, over the phone, and I quote (because I'll never forget it!), "You can't write, produce, direct, or edit. You have no business being in this business." That was soul-crushing. And it certainly didn't help when the movie bombed and I was left with a master tape that was essentially a $40K paperweight. I was broke, exhausted, and heard a lot of "I told you so's" along with a couple other things like "silly dreamer" and "another one of Jack's hair-brained schemes failed." (I opened up a comic book and role-playing game shop in 1982 at the age of 22. End result: lost my shirt.) Okay, so the story is not so quick afterall. Sorry. Now where was I? Yes. LA distributor put me down. Movie bombed. Flat broke. Made a fool of myself. Etc. But 15 years later it all changed. No matter what happens, CC, just keep moving forward. Just. Keep. Moving. Forward. While you shop your first novel around, start outlining the second one. Keep. Moving. Forward. Back to that "15 years later". In 2006 I was making a real film, with a real Hollywood cast and a real crew. Where was that distributor? They had become a producer and that same year, 2006, they were making a $10K, shot on video, slasher film with unknown actors. And where was their film heading when 20th Century Fox rang me up about mine. There's was bombing. No one wanted it. If I ever cross paths with that person again you know what I'm going to say. Yep, you got it. "You can't write, produce, blah, blah, blah." (I actually won't because I'm not vindictive but I've said it many times in my mind.) The point is: you never know when you're going to be "up" or "down" in any given scenario. And we all have many "ups" and many "downs" throughout our lives. Just remember that when the result of your novel (whatever it is) comes back. And with two successful films to my credit, where are all those folks in my life that once said, "I told you so", "silly dreamer", and "...hair-brained scheme...". Well, let's just say the silence is f**king deafening! LOL! Writing a novel is an enormous accomplishment. Published or not no one can ever take that away from you. You did it once. You can do it again.
CosmicConservative
Jack, great advice. Just some background, I have written a book that was rejected, some 30 years ago now. It wasn't fiction though, it was actually a book on fly fishing in the South at a time when fly fishing below the Mason-Dixon line was practically unheard of. I also had a couple sci-fi short stories rejected, one with some pretty nasty comments similar to what you describe above. I was particularly called out on my supposed lack of literary merit, stuff like allegory, metaphor etc. And on top of that I created/invented and tried to market three board games, one of which ended up costing me several thousand dollars and quite literally ended up in smoke when I could no longer afford to store the games and literally burned them in a huge bonfire. Sigh... good times. On the positive side, I have had quite a bit of my work published, including science articles, fishing articles and for a short time had a summer hiking column that not only published my hiking stories, but also my photographs. And as a magazine editor I published hundreds of my own articles, reviews, etc. My biggest concern is that while I've gotten a lot of stuff "out there" (including software I have written) I have not yet managed to publish ANYTHING in the one field I really want to shine, which is fantasy/sci-fi. Oh well, as you say, sometimes the puck sails into the net. I am going over the book with one last proofread and minor editing sweep, and then I'll send it out to some folks who have agreed to do the final proofreading before I begin my marketing plan. I suppose I better get that marketing plan created, eh?
Jack
CC, I'm glad to hear you've been published. And also glad that you've gotten rejected. Why? Because it seems that with very few exceptions (one I mentioned in my previous comment) all of us get rejected at least once (most likely several times) before we see success. I was concerned that this was your first time to the dance which almost guarantees rejection. I have no scientific evidence to back that up but it just appears that the universe has it play out that way more often than not. :-D But since this isn't your first dance. And you've already seen rejection, I say you're due!