Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Renter's rights?

By CosmicConservative
no_guns There is a story today in the news about a Colorado rental company that is telling their renters that they cannot have guns on the premises. The story seems to imply that this is a sudden ultimatum issued by the renting manager, but I suspect the actual message is that when a renter's current lease is up, they will have to sign a new lease that does not allow them to have guns on the premises. This, to me, raises a couple of legal questions. The first is related to the Civil Rights Act, which says that renters can't enforce rules that violate an individual's civil rights. Usually that is interpreted as renters can't refuse to rent to people based on gender, sexual orientation, race or age. But unless I am badly mistaken, the Second Amendment is a "civil right" and as such a renter cannot set rules that disallow the "right to keep and bear arms." I suppose that if this goes to court, that will be the primary argument made by the plaintiffs. But to me this opens the door to another, perhaps more fundamental, question about the renter/rentee relationship. Can the renter tell me that I cannot own legal products? I suppose this has been tested in the area of renters who disallow pets, or perhaps even children. But pets or children are living things. A gun is an object. What if a renter decided that they would not allow skis or kayaks on their property? Could they legally do that?

Comments (1)

Foobarista
I read the story, and it looks like it was an overzealous property management company, managing the building for what sounded like a government agency (or nonprofit running apt buildings? - couldn't tell exactly). Anyway, the actual owner rescinded this "decree" and pointed out that it was essentially a civil rights violation. As for what you can and can't do, there are some simple objects I've seen in leases, ie not allowing old-school waterbeds above the first floor.