Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: The Guardian

By CosmicConservative
Kevin Costner and Ashton Kutcher starred in this movie about the rough-and-tumble life of U.S. Coast Guard rescue swimmers. That almost sounds like a joke doesn't it? Kevin Costner has had so many bombs, and most people see Ashton Kutcher as Demi Moore's boy toy who played a doofus on "That Seventies Show." Slight aside. I almost never watch TV, and I find virtually everything that airs on TV to be unwatchable, but I can watch "That Seventies Show." Of course I graduated from high school in 1977, so maybe that's not a fair comparison, but I actually like that show. Back to "The Guardian." The movie was surprisingly good. I hope it does well in the theaters. Kevin Costner and Ashton Kutcher both turned in surprisingly good performances. Ashton's was probably more surprising than Costner since Kevin has had some great performances in other movies in the past, in spite of his string of box office failures. There were the inevitable cliches, such as the cross-service rivalry bar fight scene and the relationship between the gruff old veteran (Kevin Costner playing the role of Ben Randall) and the hotshot young rookie (Ashton Kutcher playing the role of Jake Fischer). But such things are pretty much required in this sort of movie. You can see exactly the same cliches in "An Officer and a Gentleman" or "Top Gun." So I don't hold that against the movie. I also thought the main character's significant others (Melissa Sagemiller as a local teacher who falls for Fischer and Sela Ward as the long-suffering wife of Randall) did a fine job, particularly Melissa Sagemiller. I have always thought Sela Ward has a sort of smoky sensuality, and it is nice to see she has maintained that even as she has added a sense of wisdom and grace as she has gotten a bit older. One personal note is that some of the movie was filmed at Barksdale Air Force Base in Bossier City Louisiana, which is my old stomping grounds, having lived on the base myself for several years, and then living in Bossier City for several more years. Of course I have never seen a U. S. Coast Guard station at Barksdale, but maybe they have one. I would have been happier to see some B-52s, KC-10s and A-10s flying around during some of the scenes, since those are the main airplanes stationed at Barksdale, but I'm sure they only did a few scenes in Bossier City. I was a bit disappointed at the end of the movie, it seemed to be a bit contrived and unnecessary, but perhaps it was also a necessary cliche to pull off. In a way the movie has helped me deal a bit with the recent events in my own town. The movie is unflinching in its portrayal of life as something that you can lose in an instant of natural capriciousness or human error. It is easy to forget both how easy it is to find yourself in a life or death situation, and how many times such situations end badly. Costner did an admirable job of portraying a man who has stared at death many times. There were several particularly poignant moments in the movie, and Costner pulled them off with aplomb and skill. I give it four stars out of five. Cosmic says check it out.

Comments (2)

Dadman
My wife and I want to go see this movie. One of my daughters is dating a guy in the Coast Guard and he thinks the rescue swimmers are prima donna jerks - much like Air Force fighter pilots. Coincidentally, I also lived on Barksdale AFB for a time in the seventies and lived in Bossier City. Amazingly, I also graduated from high school in 1977...oh wait...that's right...you were there too. Nevermind... I love The 70's Show. Brilliant writing. It makes me laugh out loud everytime I watch it. Anyone who doesn't like the show is a dumb*ss...
CosmicConservative
If this movie is an accurate representation of what those Coast Guard swimmers do, they are entitled to be prima donna jerks. Well, sorta anyway.