Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

DOMA defenestrated

By CosmicConservative
Clarence Thomas, Antonin Scalia, John G. Roberts, Anthony M. Kennedy, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, Stephen Breyer, Smauel Alito Jr., Elena Kagan I probably part ways with the vast majority of "conservatives" on my attitudes about homosexuality and same-sex marriage. The problem I have with laws about "defending marriage" is that they are conflating the religious and legal aspects of the word. Those aspects should be separated entirely. The state should only care about the legal contract two people undertake to cohabitate. The church should only care about the rituals and customs of their congregations. It is perfectly reasonable for the two events to be combined by those who want to into one ceremony and celebration. But it is also perfectly reasonable to keep them entirely separate or to do one without the other. I don't really care what a heterosexual couple does behind closed doors so long as they both are OK with it and nobody is deliberately hurting someone else. I don't have any more interest in what same-sex couples do together. My problem with the DOMA was that it was bad law and bad policy. Throwing it out was the right thing to do since, among other things, the law created an untenable situation where state and federal law were in conflict. I don't care much for the politically correct hype surrounding this decision though. I'm sorry if it offends some gay people, but as far as comparisons between the pursuit of the LGBT community of "equal rights" to the struggles of blacks, native americans, asians or other ethnic groups are concerned, those comparisons are insulting and counter-productive. Being gay is not now and never has been comparable to being a slave. So just stop that, please.

Comments (1)

Jussayin'
The next logical step is to allow polygamy, after all, it is about "love", and what if you are "bi"? How can you deny them their marital bliss when they can't choose between a male and a female partner? And what about those who have come to "love" two women, or two men? What about incest? If the couple want to marry with no desire for children, how are you not a bigot if you look to deny brother and sister, or brother and brother/ sister and sister, or father and daughter, or so on, from their marriage equality rights? This also brings in a ton of new legislation needed to deal with the new benefits of SSM partners. It is a destruction of the traditional family unit. Countries that have accepted SSM have all had decreases in traditional marriage, as it has lost so much meaning. Marriage is not a right. Having sexual relations in any form or manner is not a right either. The ramifications of this will not be realized for years. And it can't be "put back in the box". Is this really progress, that we have reduced our society to a point where it totally revolves around sex, to the point where it comes to define our very beings? This is a sickness of the mind and soul. Moral relativism is on the rise. How long till just about every and any behavior be excused in the falsehood of it being freedom?