Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: World War Z

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, two movie reviews in less than a week. Z_movie I didn't realize we were going to see this movie. The Cosmic Wife and Daughter and I went to go see "Monster University" and after dropping them off to go park the car, I met up with them to discover that the wife and I were watching a zombie movie while the daughter watched the Pixar offering. I had been sort of intrigued by the "fast zombies" concept of the movie and figured "what the heck" and soon we were watching the world descend into an undead nightmare. I suppose this isn't really a movie review anyway, more a treatise on the concept of zombies in popular culture and the problems they present from any sort of scientific, rational or logical perspective. The movie was OK, not great, but as B movies go, it was an OK way to waste a couple of hours. I can't believe how much they spent making the movie and the end result, other than the zombies moving fast, is strictly your standard zombies vs humans story. I can't believe it's raking in the money it's raking in either. I had thought at the very least the movie might explore the concepts of swarming behavior by having humans swarm like locusts or ants, and it is clear from the visual effects and the initial montage of different animal swarms that this was originally supposed to be something that was explored, but in the end all that survived the editing process was a bunch of running, biting, jumping, shooting and screaming. But zombies... I have lots of problems with most forms of "undead" creatures, just from a thermodynamics perspective alone, but beyond that, zombies are particularly problematic from any sort of bio-mechanical or bio-chemical perspective. Unless the zombification process somehow revokes the laws of physics, zombies just can't work they way they are portrayed. In order for them to have any physical activities whatsoever, even just to LISTEN for a sound, they have to expend energy. That means they have to acquire energy from somewhere. Otherwise the end result of any zombie movie would be the use of zombies as infinite energy sources. Just put a bunch of zombies in a hamster wheel and let them run blindly in place and there you go, infinite zombie-powered electric turbine. Zombies are the solution to our energy woes. But in movie after movie zombies are portrayed as the perpetual motion machine of undead monsters. They just keep on going and going and going, even when they have had no food for days, weeks, months, years.... This movie in particular was noteworthy since the zombies had an urge to BITE humans but showed no particular desire to CONSUME human flesh. They just bit and moved on to bite again, leaving their infected victim to morph into a thermodynamically impossible creature themselves. Which brings me to the concept of modern "virus" zombies, or zombie movies where the humans become zombies because they are infected with a zombie virus. The problem here is that necrotic human tissue does not function. When you die, your body's cells undergo a biochemical process that effectively rots your tissue from the cellular level out. Muscle cells no longer have the ability to contract. Nerve cells no longer have the ability to respond to stimuli or send messages. The virus may infect a body, but once the human is dead, the virus is stuck in a dead body. The only feasible "zombie" process is a process where the human victim doesn't really die, but is instead driven insane by the virus and begins to act in ways we would recognize as "zombie" behavior. There is actual biological precedence for this. Many fungi are known to infect insects and cause them to behave in very specific ways which then helps to spread the fungus to new hosts. Ants infected by some parasitic fungi stop acting like ants and instead climb to the top of plants where they cling to a leaf or twig as the fungus erupts out of their bodies and spores are sent seeking new ants. But that sort of zombification is still biological. The zombie ants will die just as an uninfected ant would die from most things that would kill an ant. So why do I care about this? Because it is my opinion that biologically plausible zombies are far more frightening than the thermodynamically impossible zombies because they could actually exist! World War Z would have been a much better movie had the writers bothered to try to make a biologically and thermodynamically plausible zombie instead of a tired zombie retread. The zombies in World War Z, other than their tendency to swarm and move fast, looked and acted just like the zombies in "Plan 9 from Outer Space." You would think $130 million, modern CGI and an A-List actor like Brad Pitt would get you a better version of a zombie. You would be wrong.

Comments (4)

Dadman
I'm wondering now if you had seen 'Monster U' if you'd be telling us how unlikely it is that monsters would be attending university, or how unlikely it is, from an natural selection perspective, that any large creature would have fluoresecent-colored markings in our modern world. ;) Fiction is fiction, even when the subject is zombies. I like the zombies in this movie even though they were admittedly portrayed in a rather confusing way. They behaved as if they were the victims of some kind of zombie virus - biten, infected, and then zombified - but I seem to recall a character in the film making the point that they were undead rather than simply turned by a viral infection a la rabies. That's unfortunate, because I also prefer biological zombification. Such zombies are much scarier than the slow moving variety seen in most zombie films (most of which I've seen by the way). For the record, the best biological zombification film I've seen in recent years is '28 Day Later' directed by Danny Boyle. But, ultimately, either zombie approach is okay with me and I found the zombies in 'World War Z' to be entertaining. I thoroughly suspend disbelief when I sit down to watch a zombie flick (much like I do when I go see a Spiderman or an Avengers film). I want to be scared and, for me (and my wife), 'World War Z' delivered some excellent suspense and a few genuinely scary moments...and they did it without all the gratuitous gore than has become the stock-in-trade of the zombie genre. Both my wife and I appreciated that and enjoyed the movie.
CosmicConservative
As I said, this wasn't really a movie review. As zombie movies go, this one was OK. It just surprised me how conventional it was other than the fast moving zombies. I didn't dislike the movie, I just can't suspend disbelief enough to appreciate standard zombies. I can suspend disbelief enough to watch the Avengers. Perpetual motion, thermodynamically and biologically impossible zombies just go a bit too far for my suspension of disbelief to follow.
Dadman
How many zombie movies have you actually seen? I'm not exaggerating when I say I've seen nearly all of them produced in the last 10 years or so. With that in mind I can tell you that fast zombies are not really that uncommon, the zombies portrayed in most zombie films are of the variety that don't respect the laws of thermodynamics, and that the zombies in WWZ were nicely done and unique in some unexpected ways. Also, I don't think it's entirely fair to refer to this film as a 'B' movie. You just don't like the 'horror' genre. :) Anyway, if you're into zombies now I suggest you check out 'Shaun of the Dead' (a funny spoof of the zombie genre), Zombieland (another funny take of the genre that involves a Twinkie obession and Bill Murray as a zombie), and the popular AMC series 'The Walking Dead'. With the latter be forwarned that zombie gore is played up big time...too much even for my taste in fact. As I said, the absence of serious gore in WWZ is one of the things I appreciated about the movie. Later...
CosmicConservative
I honestly can't tell you the names of the zombie movies I've seen, mostly because I tend not to watch them in movie theaters but end up channel surfing and watching them as I stumble onto them and frequently never even see the name of the movie. I have seen Shaun of the Dead and thought it was pretty funny. I haven't seen Zombieland that I know of, and I have lately been watching too much TV for me to add another show to my repertoire. Yeah, fast zombies are probably fairly common now, Hollywood is nothing if not derivative. I suppose the next step is the "ghoul" movie. Ghouls are generally represented in undead folklore as the next step up from zombies, and the difference between ghouls and zombies is usually that ghouls are as fast as humans and they retain at least a level of cunning that allows them to plan and cooperate. In tabletop fantasy RPG games ghouls are significantly more difficult to overcome than even several zombies. The next step up from a ghoul is generally called a "ghast" and the major difference between ghouls and ghasts is that ghasts have all the intelligence, speed and cunning of ghouls, but they also have a supernatural ability to overwhelm humans from their mere presence, causing them to faint or fall unconscious. Ghasts are generally among the most feared of undead in RPG games until characters reach a level that they are mostly immune to the knocking unconscious effect and can reliably fight the ghasts without ending up drooling on the floor.