Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Royal Cosmic

By CosmicConservative
william-the-conqueror So, last night the Cosmic Mother sent me an interesting email detailing the supposed genealogical history of her maternal grandfather. The story (which was written up in a local newspaper upon his passing, so its got some level of credibility) is that at the age of 19, in 1893, this guy pulled up stakes and moved from Maine to Idaho, where he settled down to become a fixture as an early pioneer in the area. Now, think about that for a minute. Maine to Idaho. 1893. Now, I suppose he could have gone from Maine to Albuquerque and then up to Idaho, but in 1893 there weren't a whole lot of easy ways to get from Maine to Idaho. And the straightest, shortest, and most likely cheapest route took you through or very near the Lakota Sioux nation. No biggie right? Well, except that the last major "war" between the Lakota Sioux and the US Government took place in 1891. Just two years before my great-grandfather moseyed through that same region. That had to have been a gut-check. The guy must have had some serious cojones. But that's not what the story was about. That was a minor lead-in to the supposed family history of my great-grandfather. The real story was that he was supposedly a direct descendent of one of William the Conqueror's right-hand men in the "Battle of Hastings", which was the decisive battle for the control of England during the Norman Invasion. As a reward for his gallantry and bravery, William supposedly awarded my ancestor a royal appointment as Lord of a huge swath of land including some of England's most famous landmarks and towns. I'm not listing them because some of them are famous enough that a quick google search could probably determine who I am talking about. Anyway, this ancestor of mine had two sons. The eldest, of course, inherited all the lands, estates and fortune that William had granted to his father. The second son, as was the case in feudal society at the time, inherited nothing beyond a small estate and patronage. The eldest son had no male children, so all of that estate was absorbed back by the King and disposed of in the manner of Kings rewarding favored subjects. C'est la vie, I suppose. The younger son's children did OK over the years though. Most married well into other royal families and the genealogy indicates a number of important figures in the blood line, but the laws of inheritance favored only the first sons for many generations, and eventually one unfavored son apparently hopped on board one of the early ships sailing for the new world and appeared in Virginia in or around the mid-seventeenth century. It is from that individual that the Cosmic Mother's maternal line derives. Interesting stuff. If true then I have some slight taint of royal blood, and one of my ancestors was instrumental in the course of world history. Pretty cool. Of course I don't believe a word of it. But it's fun to speculate.

Comments (7)

Dadman
This would be fairly easy to confirm one way or the other. I for one believe it. If you look closely at the picture you posted you'll notice that the dude on the white horse looks a lot like Cosmic. Coincidence? I think not.
jussayin'
It was my understanding that the title of Lord (which it sounds like, given the land and so on) would remain with the family, going to the surviving sibling. It only ends when there is no direct decendent. While many "Lords" or whatever other hereditary titled persons, end up losing their lands because of fiscal problems through poor management, it is through them selling off the lands that they are lost. That younger brother would have had the title and lands passed to him on his brothers death. Yes, the first son got the goods, but if they died without an heir, the title would go to the younger son, or if he pre-deceased the older brother, if the younger son had a son, the line would continue through the nephew, even though his father didn't have the title.
CosmicConservative
Jus, I don't know the details, but I think the story is that the elder son had no sons, the younger son had sons but died before the elder son, so when the elder son died, that was it. But I not only don't know the details, I suspect this story is, like most such stories, somewhat embellished by the family over the years. That's why I said I don't believe any of it, but it's fun to speculate. I suppose I could do a rigorous genealogy search, but those cost actual money.
CosmicConservative
So I just did a quick search on some genealogy sites on the history that was published in the newspaper story I referenced. My oh my. It turns out that this specific story appears to be one that is hotly contested among genealogical historians who specialize on the English aristocracy. (I guess I should have expected such a subject to be that well discussed.) It turns out that just about every single generation in the story, starting with William the Conqueror's buddy, has a history that is contested. However, all of that would still leave the royal lineage intact. The problem appears to be with the connection between the individuals who first arrived in America in the seventeenth century, and who eventually settled in Maine. There is major disagreement on whether the individual who carried the family name onto North American shores had credible connection to the royal family back in England. Not the least reason for this is a slight difference in the spelling of the name. In defense the proponents of the connection claim that spelling changes of the sort in this case were common among New World pioneers because ship's registers were not filled out by the passengers and in many cases the passengers just adopted the misspellings rather than try to fight the issue from thousands of miles away. Anyway, as I said, it's an interesting story. The lineage involved, at least for several generations after the Battle of Hastings seems to match the story in the paper, so if the connection between the first American of the line and the royal family back in England is true, then the whole story is probably true. That seems to be the single major crack in the narrative.
Andy
That is very cool, and very interesting. I don't really know where the Reeves side of my family came from. I know "Reevers" were Brits that were kinda' the overseers of serfs for the Lords & all. One day at the store about 30 years ago, the discussion was about genealogy, family background, etc. My beloved Papaw was sitting there listening, so I asked him where our family came from. He said, "Mostly from down in the Rio Grande Valley." ;)
CosmicConservative
Andy, didn't you watch "Firefly?" Reavers aren't what you describe at all. They're interplanetary zombie marauders who do unspeakable things to their victims. You're saying you're related to them? Eeeewwww.
Andy
Heh! Nope! I indeed did NOT watch Firefly. Heh! I might be related to some folks that do unspeakable things to their victims, though. Maybe that's why Papaw was kinda' ducking the question... ;)