Say it ain't so Rocket!
SI.com - MLB - Report: Grimsley implicated Clemens, others - Sunday October 1, 2006 3:03AM
Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte and Miguel Tejada were among the players that a former major league pitcher accused of using performance-enhancing drugs, according to a federal agent's affidavit, the Los Angeles Times reported Saturday on its Web site.
I have blogged before on why I prefer Greg Maddux to Roger Clemens as a pitcher, even though Rocket's stats are marginally better than Maddux's. Over the years Clemens has been part of one controversy after another involving beanballs, throwing inside, busting up lockers, water coolers, and getting into fights with teammates and opponents. I've never liked his overly aggressive, intimidating style of playing. But I've had to concede that he has a better winning percentage than Maddux, although not by much. Maddux is still on track to equal or slightly better Clemens in total wins if he plays two more seasons and Clemens retires (again) this year though. Clemens has pitched two more years than Maddux, so if Maddux pitches two years after Clemens retires, then a comparison of wins would be on a year-for-year basis. Right now Maddux has a slightly higher per-year winning mark than Clemens does.
But this is disappointing news, although steroid rumors have swirled around Clemens for years. I hope it turns out to be untrue. Whatever my opinion of Clemens himself is, I'm a fan of clean baseball and would like to think that the two pitchers in my lifetime who are legitimately in the top five or ten pitchers of all time both did it on their own, without relying on trips to the pharmacy or a drug dealer to boost their career.
Maddux, by the way, is 14-14 this season, and there is a chance, if he is moved up to pitch the last game of the season, that he can go 15 -14 (or I suppose 14 - 15). If he does win 15 games this year, I think he will set another record for the most seasons with 15 or more wins. To provide just a bit of perspective on an "average" 14-14 record, the Rockies, who are 76-85 going into today's final game of the season, don't have a single pitcher with 14 wins, so even in his "dotage" and performing as a merely average pitcher, Maddux would still have been better than most pitchers in the league, and better than many teams entire pitching staffs.
Update:
Maddux did indeed pitch one last game for the Dodgers, and won that game, which clinched a playoff appearance for the Dodgers. Maddux ended the year 15 - 14 for yet another winning season with at least fifteen wins. The guy is simply amazing.
Comments (3)