Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Magic Cards...

By CosmicConservative
A long time ago I used to play the game "Magic:The Gathering". I even played in a tournament once, and won a few games before being sent home by a guy with a deck full of moxes and lotuses (lotii?) If you don't know what moxes and lotii are, consider yourself lucky. Because the game was based on the concept of building decks out of randomly available cards, to play the game you had to buy packs of cards from which you would construct your deck. A pack of cards cost (back then) something like $7 and would contain one "rare" card, a couple "uncommon" cards and several "common" ones. Of course most of the best cards were rare so players ended up buying so many common and uncommon cards that they were virtually worthless, so the rare cards were the only ones that had any real value. I was unfortunate enough to begin playing just after the "beta" run, so my first purchases were from the "Unlimited" set (also known, I think, as "Third Edition") and the "Revised" set (aka "Fourth Edition"). The business model of the game is that you have the "base edition" cards, which make up the great bulk of cards sold, and then there are "expansion packs" which are "special" cards that you can add to your deck to make it more powerful, or just to mix things up with new creatures, spells or effects. Between each new edition, some cards are retired, others are added, but the bulk of the cards remain the same. The expansion packs are always completely new and different. Since I started after beta I missed out on purchasing the most collectible cards, some of which are worth hundreds of dollars even today, well after the Magic card market crashed about a decade ago. But I'm getting ahead of myself. So back then I was not willing to just shell out hundreds of dollars to buy cards (and neither was my wife) so I concocted a scheme to fund my Magic hobby. After building up a decent collection of reasonably valuable cards, I went to a local store which sold the cards and arranged a consignment sales system so that I sold my most valuable cards to individual buyers in search of specific cards to complete their decks. I paid the store 10% or something like that. But I made enough cash on the sale to purchase entire boxes of Magic Cards directly from Wizards of the Coast, which I would then open and pick out a few cards I wanted to play with, but then sold all the more valuable cards to fund more purchases of new cards. Doing this netted me a fairly substantial collection of cards, the vast majority of which were worthless. But some were valuable. I kept them in my basement home office in a couple of large cardboard boxes designed to hold collectible cards. I kept a few in a notebook with plastic card protectors. Then I went on vacation and my basement flooded. By the time I got home my entire collection had been in standing water (or under water) for days. They were totally ruined. Or most of them were. I did have one box I had stacked on top of other boxes and that box only had one section that had soaked up water. Surprisingly my insurance company paid for the lost cards at fair market value, which at that time was quite a bit more than I realized. I think I got over a thousand dollars for the ruined cards, money I used to buy my first serious amateur photography equipment. Equipment I sold a decade later to buy a guitar. So in a sense I guess my Magic hobby has funded two other hobbies, one of which I still enjoy. But I lost interest in Magic about that time and since then I've just kept that last batch of cards in a new box in my closet. I figured they weren't worth much, all of my really nice cards had been ruined. But for some reason, pure happenstance, that box included most of my "dual land" cards, cards that weren't that valuable back then, but have appreciated considerably since then. Last night just for kicks I pulled out my dual land cards and looked them up on eBay. My dual land cards are currently worth around $800 - $900. That's looking at what people are actually BIDDING on them, not what people are asking for them. Most of them are worth around $30 - $40, but a few are worth as much as $80 each, and I've got about two dozen of them. I do have a bunch of other rare cards, but most of them are only worth a buck or two. I probably have another two dozen cards that average in the $10 - $20 range. But all the rest of my cards are just junk. Wasted space. So I'm now trying to decide if I should sell out my cards for whatever I can get for them (I am estimating I can probably get $500 or so from a trader) or hang onto them in the hopes they appreciate more. My worry is that if I do wait, they will become worthless when Wizards releases a new edition or expansion that re-introduces the same card. I do have several cards that used to be valuable but are no longer worth anything because they were re-introduced. I'd hate to lose out on a potential for a chunk of cash because I waited too long.

Comments (12)

Drax
Okay. Some advice. First, an aside: Sturgeon's law: "99% of everything is crap." Now. What I suggest is for you to sell the cards in lots on Ebay. Separate the rares into piles where there is one dual land in each pile. (Look for some other great uncommons as well - such as Demonic Tutor, Sol Ring, Regrowth) Then take a picture. Then separate the "junk cards" into an equal number of piles. Put up for auction with the starting bid somewhere a bit below what the dual land would cost by itself. In the listing, put a good description of each rare (just the name). Give accurate representations of the conditions of the cards (especially the dual land). Ship them via the smallest flat rate priority box (setting the S&H for that price) and let them know how they will be shipped and how much it will cost. That way, you'll get quite a bit more than the price of a single card and get rid of the junk cards as well. A bit of trouble but it will maximize your take home.
CosmicConservative
Wow, my eyes are blurry... my head hurts, my neck and shoulders hurt... I just went through my cards trying to find anything of any value whatsoever. So, here's what I am doing. I am creating four piles of cards.
  1. Valuable cards. I am defining these as cards I feel confident I can get at least $5 each.
  2. Interesting cards. These are cards that seem to generate some interest online. In general that means that four of them sell for more than $1.00, which seems to be the bottom floor for selling cards. Anything that sells for more than $1 for four of them appears to be a card that people must buy.
  3. Other rare or uncommon cards that don't sell for more than 4/$1
  4. All the other crap
Right now it looks like I should end up with more than 40 valuable cards, around 300 cards of interest 500 other rare/uncommons and over 1,000 junk cards. The vast majority of my edition cards seem to be from the 4th and 5th editions, with a significant number of 3rd and a bare smattering of beta, although none of my beta cards are good ones. For expansion packs it looks like the largest group I have is Fallen Empires (yeah, the suckiest expansion in the history of the game) and Ice Age, with a few other packs I picked up over time just out of curiosity, plus a bare smattering of older expansions (Dark, Antiquities, Legends) that Drax here gave me for my birthday I think. I only have a few dozen of those though. It sort of pains me to go through this exercise because I remember having several really nice cards in large numbers before the flood. Of course I did recoup the cost of them, and probably at better prices than I could get today, but it still hurts to see a single Ornithopter or two Sol Rings or a single Shivan Dragon in my collection when I used to have probably a dozen of each of those. But, I do have some decent cards, but it seems that in the vast majority of cases if I have more than one of a good card, I only have three, not four or five. Three. That's a problem since most of the sales online are in sets of four since that's all of one card you can put in a deck. Anyway, It turns out I only have 16 dual land cards, not two dozen. I've got a smattering of other reasonably valuable cards (Mox Diamond, Nevinyrral's Disk, Wheel of Fortune, Wrath of God, Maze of Ith, Invisibility, Sol Ring, Regrowth, Demonic Tutor...). So I might be able to take your advice Drax. I dunno if I have the energy to manage that sort of a sales campaign though. That would probably be the best way to make the most money though. I suppose I should just sort them by value and start working through them...
Andy
Two of my sons were deep in to Magic. They have boxes full of cards. Gonna' give them the heads up on this. I know they have some valuable ones. Thanks, Cosmic.
Drax
The other way (easier, faster) is to simply make one listing. But, you have to do it right. Take several pictures (or scans) of your very best rares. You need to scan the front and backs of your dual lands. Then list each rare (and great uncommon) along with a general description of your bulk cards (set, what % of the whole collection, whether or not they'll receive more than 4 of just a few or a whole lot of cards.) Take a picture of the whole collection (in the box(es). Figure out how many large priority flat rate boxes it will take to ship. (You can get them for free at the Post Office.) Set the S&H for that amount. Set the listing for as long as you can before Christmas. (10 days). End it on Friday night or Saturday night. (Before 10:00 EST.) Start it at .01. Make sure that you use the title to put SIXTEEN DUAL LANDS. ("Magic collection lot" in the title as well.) Use the additional description space to put actual names of a couple of dual lands, Mox Diamond, Bird of Paradise (if you have one) Wrath of God...as many of the great cards as you can. You will get a goodly percentage of the market value for your dual lands and some of the best rares in one listing. And, maybe, if you get some people BWD (bidding while drunk) you'll do even better. (If you do it the other way I suggested, you'll receive more - and this is simply because you'll have more people bidding on smaller dollar price lots whereas a larger listing such as this precludes by cost the vast bulk of Magic buyers.) But, I don't know how much you'll "lose" since the dual lands will draw a bunch of people in - especially if they're in good shape.
CosmicConservative
I am using this site: http://www.mtgmintcard.com/mtg_category.php to do my lookups to decide what is and isn't worth selling. I am sort of surprised that some cards listed on that site sell for more on eBay than on the site. In most cases I assume it's "out of stock" situations. But the reverse is true too. Some sell for more on this site than on eBay. I am not separating my cards by common/uncommon/rare. I am instead just doing it by value. If a common card happens to have value (like "lightning bolt" for example) then I am putting it with the other cards that have similar value. I am still digging through my cards. Over the years they had become quite disorganized, so it's a real pain going through them. I wish there were easier ways to determining between "unlimited" and "revised" and also "fourth" and "fifth" editions... Sometimes I'm not 100% certain, and it can make a difference in the value of the cards. And what possessed WotC to come up with "Chronicles" which look exactly the same as the Legends, Dark, Antiquities, etc. cards they reproduced? How many people have paid for old cards and got Chronicles cards and never realized it?
Drax
Okay. Unlimited has a "feel" to them that revised and later sets don't have. That's caused by a bit of "pixelation" or some such which makes the pictures and printing a bit larger than revised. Look at the dates at the bottom of the cards for 3rd and 4th editions. Chronicles have an icon for the set from which they came BUT they are "white border" while the original cards are "black border."
CosmicConservative
Man, I am dead sick of staring at Magic cards...
CosmicConservative
So, other than my dual lands, I've only got a few that are even worth ten bucks. I dunno if it's worth messing with anything but the dual lands... I've spent too much time on them already.
CosmicConservative
OK, I'm done. I've pulled out every card that had any value whatsoever. Those that are potentially worth a dollar or more total about 250 overall. There's maybe 3 dozen that are worth $10 or more, with the 16 dual land cards by far being the bulk of the value of the entire "collection". So now I gotta decide what to do with them. I'm not a fan of eBay. I'm also notoriously lazy. So the prospect of running hundreds of eBay auctions doesn't really appeal to me. Even the prospect of running dozens of them doesn't sound very pleasant. I'd almost rather just sell the whole thing in one big lump, even if that means not getting the maximum value for them. What I would REALLY love to do is put my cards under my pillow and have the 3D printer fairy take them and leave one of the top-rated 3D printers in its place...
mtg theros
What are good magic the gathering booster boxes to build a green deck?
CosmicConservative
Theros, I don't know what the current build guidelines are, I haven't played Magic in years. I would suggest checking out Google Maps to find the distance from New Jersey to Brazil.