Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On colonizing newly discovered exoplanets...

By CosmicConservative
I don't know how much differently my mind works than other people's minds. For example, when I see the discovery announced of a "new earthlike planet discovered!" my immediate reaction does not stop with "Oh cool!" It immediately jumps to "Hmm... if that planet is actually a rocky planet with surface water, could humans actually live on it?" For example, there is a story out right now about a newly discovered "super earth" which is a planet about 45 light years away (right next door in galactic terms) that is in its star's "Goldilocks zone". Sounds good so far, right? But then it turns out that the planet is 7 times the mass of the earth. Hmm... seven times the mass? What does that mean? Does that mean gravity is seven times as much as earth? Because if so that means humans would experience a "g force" of 7g just trying to stand on the surface. That's comparable to the g force you would experience at the bottom of an extreme roller coaster loop. (Actually, a bit of research shows the highest roller coaster g force to be rated at 6.3g. Most are in the 5g range for their highest g force.) You MIGHT be able to stand up for a few minutes, but it would not be long before you simply could not stand. But what would the force of gravity be on a rocky planet with seven times the mass of earth? Well, fortunately we can do some math. If we assume that the "super earth" has the same basic density as earth (not much of a reach, Mercury and Venus have densities very similar to earth), then a planet with seven times the mass of earth with the same density of earth, would end up with a surface gravity of almost exactly 2g. 2g is not ideal, but it's not necessarily impossible to deal with. Especially with exoskeletons to help people move and special beds to support them as they sleep. How long a person could survive on such a planet is debatable, but if that planet has seas, sea life might be able to live with very little adjustment since sea life is generally buoyant. So even if humans couldn't live permanently on the surface, such a planet could very possibly be farmed extensively and short visits to the surface by humans would be possible. I don't know what sort of experiments have been done on humans to determine the absolute g limits for humans to be able to live permanently on the surface of an exoplanet without suffering so much from the different g forces that living wouldn't be worth it. But just for the sake of argument I'm going to say that living within .75 to 1.25 g is probably acceptable. That would mean g values of between about 7 m/sec^2 to about 12 m/sec^2. So, with those parameters, and assuming equal density with earth, what does that mean in terms of the mass of exoplanets? Well, it turns out that would mean that inhabitable planets would be those that range from 1/2 to about 2 earth masses. But... there is actually reason to believe that earth is somewhat denser than most exoplanets. For whatever reason our solar system seems to have a higher concentration of heavy elements than most star systems. I don't know exactly what that means in terms of density, but since iron is one of those abundant elements that is apparently not so abundant in other systems, and earth is almost a big iron ball, I think it's not unreasonable to suggest that many exoplanets probably have a density that is as much as 20% less than earth. So, if that is true and we find exoplanets with 80% the density of the earth, what masses are we now looking at as potential for habitation? That changes the habitable mass to be from .6 earth masses to 3 earth masses. Since we have found several exoplanets in the range of 4 - 8 earth masses, this is starting to look more promising. Of course by the time we reach out to such planets, we might well have developed bio and genetic engineering to such a degree that living on planets with much higher g forces might even be possible. I suspect that in the long run we are likely to find lots of planets with masses in the acceptable range. After all we have two in our own solar system, along with two more that are pretty close and a couple of moons that are also in that range.

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative
So.... I just realized something that I probably knew at one time. Saturn's "surface gravity" is very close to 1g. That's because Saturn is mostly gas so it isn't very dense. In fact it's just about as dense as water, while earth is just about as dense as iron. So we could "colonize" Saturn. All we would have to do is build huge floating balloon cities and the gravity on those cities would be quite comfortable for us. Presumably we could find lots more such planets in the galaxy. How hard would it be to build continent sized floating cities? I dunno, but if we can figure it out, our prospects for galactic colonization just got hugely more likely.